click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




The Four Sons

The Four Sons

The Four Sons serve as a wonderful model on how to transmit our rich heritage effectively, tailor-made to each child's capacity and unique way of learning.

by
Blessed is the Omnipresent. Blessed is He. Blessed is the One Who has given the Torah to His people Israel, Blessed is He. Concerning four sons does the Torah speak: a wise one, a wicked one, a simple one and one who does not know to ask.

With these words, the Haggadah introduces the Four Sons and explains how each should be taught.

The Four Sons serve as a wonderful model on how to transmit our rich heritage effectively, tailor-made to each child's capacity and unique way of learning.

The values of the Torah are timeless and so every generation finds a new way of interpreting the Haggadah which has meaning in it for them.

Below you will find one way of understanding the Four Sons in relation to modern day, as well as some ideas how to transmit the key lessons of the Haggadah to your children geared to ages 8-14.

A_Note_To_Parents

You can look at the four sons as four generations of Jews in America today. The first generation of eastern European Jewry who emigrated to America at the turn of the century are represented by the Wise Son. This is the Jew who grew up with a strong connection to the Jewish way of life. It is inconceivable for him to think of working on Shabbat. He would work from Monday to Friday, observe Shabbat and get fired for not coming to work, and look for other employment the next week. He knows why Judaism is important. His commitment is unshakable.

His son, the second generation, is represented in the Wicked Son. This is the rebel who wants to succeed in his new life and take on Western values. Although he has grown up in a home full of Jewish values and an integrated Jewish life, he rejects this in favor of integrating into Western society and becoming accepted as the new American.

His son, the third generation, is represented by the Simple Son. This child has spent Seder nights at his grandparents' table, has seen his grandmother light the Shabbat candles. He has a spattering of knowledge picked up at Hebrew school, but he doesn't know the meaning behind any of the symbols and is not very motivated to go beyond what he sees.

His son, the fourth generation, is represented in the "One who doesn't know how to ask." This child does not have memories of his great grandparents. He celebrates the American holidays and other than knowing that he is a Jew, has no connection whatsoever to Judaism. He sits at a traditional Seder night and does not even know what to ask because it is all so foreign to him.

Today there is a fifth son, who is off in India or out at the movies on Seder night, not even aware that Passover exists. Anyone sitting at the Seder table is still connected to the Jewish people and heritage just by being there. We just need to get him curious and interested enough to ask a question that interests him and you can open the door for him.

Discussion_Questions

  • Ask you kids to look at the questions each of the sons ask. How do we know from their question which son they represent?
  • Why do you think the Wicked Son and the One Who Doesn't Know How to Ask get similar answers?

Suggested Answers

  • The Wise Son asks a very detailed question which shows that he is very interested and is searching for a satisfying answer.
  • The Wicked Son does not so much ask a question as make a statement. He's saying, in effect: "What do you care about all this?" It's clear that he wants to ridicule us for keeping all the detailed laws of Passover, and is not really looking for an answer. And that is the reason why we don't actually answer him, but, instead, reaffirm to the rest of the family why we keep Passover each year.
  • The Simple Son's question seems similar to the Wicked Son's, yet the tone is different. He is asking out of genuine interest and wants to understand more about the meaning behind the symbols he sees. In fact, the answer he receives is similar to the Wise Son's, because, if he continues to inquire and learn about why we keep our traditions, he will one day acquire wisdom.
  • The Son Who Doesn't know How To Ask doesn't even know enough to ask a question and must be encouraged to ask by his parents in a gentle manner. In a way, he is similar to the Wicked Son, because, by not even taking enough interest to investigate his traditions, he shows that he is tuned out and will end up cutting himself off from the Jewish people, just like the Wicked Son.

Judaism requires one to take a responsible and active role in the world. The One Who Doesn't Know How to Ask has relinquished the natural drive to ask. He takes no interest in what is going on around him and demonstrates a lack of care. Once we stop caring, we can easily permit bad things to happen, and wait for others to stand up to fight for what is right.

Activities_Ideas

I. "Whose Question?"

Prepare four cards with the names of the four sons, each one of the sons representing the four generations (as explained above).

How to Play: Whoever picks the card, has to ask someone else a question about anything to do with Passover or anything about Jewish tradition from the perspective of that particular son.

For example, the Wise Son might ask questions like:

  • "Why did God bring 10 plagues, when he could have taken us out of Egypt in any way at all?"
  • "Why does the matzah represents freedom and slavery at the same time?"

The Wicked Son might ask questions like:

  • "Come on, do we have to read all this before we get to the meal?"
  • "What's the big deal about eating marror? Now that we're all free, why remember the bad times?"

"The Simple Son" might vaguely remember eating matzah at his grandfather's Seder, but he can't remember why. He might ask, "What's this?" pointing to the matzah or any other symbol on the table.

"The One Who Doesn't know How to Ask" doesn't have a question. So try to coax him to ask. For example:"Johnny, have you ever tasted matzah before? It's kind of hard and not so great for the digestive system."

II. "Pass It On"

Ask your kids, if they wanted to pass on a family tradition through the generations, how would they ensure that it gets passed on?

Ask your grandparents or older people at the table if there are any family traditions that have been passed on through the generations?

How are our Jewish traditions passed on through the generations? Look at the Seder night as a model.

(To make this section fun for the younger kids, see "The Four Sons Models.")

Published: April 2, 2003


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 4

(3) Mopo, March 13, 2013 5:23 PM

The fourth son

I have seen it describes as the son who doesn't know TO ask, as well as doesn't know HOW TO ask.
Is there a difference?

(2) YOU!!! CRANK DAT SOUJA BOY!, March 18, 2010 11:59 PM

Great explanation

I learned a lot!! THANKS A TRILLION!!

(1) Eleanor Karp, April 6, 2009 12:41 PM

The Wicked Son

Wicked as noted in the dictionary means evil, with evil intent, depraved. This is a very harmful description of any child. I suggest rebellious, or defiant.

Mopo, March 13, 2013 5:25 PM

Wicked

I believe the Haggada was first written in Hebrew. I would suggest investigating the meaning of "rasha" if you want the most accurate description.

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub