The square matzah or the round matzah: What shall you eat?

by Rabbi Berel Wein

No holiday has as much halachic literature published concerning it as Passover. And the questions under discussion reflect Jewish life throughout the centuries and in all of the countries and circumstances of the long Jewish exile.

In the middle 1850's, as the Industrial Revolution gained momentum in Central and Eastern Europe, an ingenious inventor in the Austro-Hungarian Empire created a machine to bake matzot. Until that time, matzot were always baked by hand. They were usually round in form and no two matzot were exactly the same in size, color and even consistency.

Many times, the matzot were baked by each family individually, though by the early part of the 18th century there were many commercial matzah bakeries throughout the Jewish world. The matzah baking in those bakeries was done by hand and almost all of the workers were women. Most of the women were widows who were able to live (survive is a better word) the rest of the year on the money they earned in the months of matzah baking.

The work was physically very demanding and tension laden, since the matzah had to be completely baked within 18 minutes of the time that water touched the flour at the beginning of the kneading process. The rabbinic literature of the ages is replete with warnings to owners of matzah bakeries not to exploit or verbally abuse the women workers especially those who were widows.

The invention of the matzah-baking machine raised a furor in the rabbinic world. Great rabbis permitted the use of the matzah-baking machine and in fact preferred its products to the hand-baked matzot. The machine did not get tired at 4 in the afternoon, its products were uniform and well-baked, and the machine suffered naught from any remarks addressed to it. It also allowed for lower prices for matzah, and produced far greater amounts of matzah to be distributed for the Passover holiday. However, there was determined rabbinic opposition to the new matzah-baking machine.

The main objections to the matzah-baking machine were two. One was the social and economic dislocation that new technology always creates to individuals trapped in the old way of doing things. The rabbis who opposed the matzah baking machine came to the defense of the poor women, especially the widows, who were rendered redundant by the use of the new machine. Such social concerns are an integral part of all rabbinic literature throughout the ages, no matter what the actual issue involved.

The second objection dealt with the fact that small bits of dough could remain in the machine for longer than 18 minutes, and thus became chametz -- and could potentially find its way into the matzah itself being baked in the machine.

Most of the chassidic communities in Eastern Europe refused to use the machine-made matzot on Passover. However, machine matzot gained popularity amongst the rest of the Jewish society, especially in the United States and Israel.

Great technological improvements in matzah-baking machines have occurred over the century and a half since its introduction, so that none of the objections to the original matzah machines are really valid today.

Nevertheless, there are yet large numbers of Jewish families that use hand-baked matzot today, especially for the Seder itself. It is obvious that our ancestors did not use machine-baked matzah when they left Egypt, and thus the tradition of eating hand-baked matzot has its place today, even in our technologically advanced world, as a symbolic reminder of the Exodus from Egyptian bondage.

Article from http://www.rabbiwein.com/

 

Published: Wednesday, April 02, 2003

Aish.com relies on your support. Click here to support us.

Visitor Comments: 2

  • (2) Hirschel Pekkar , May 14, 2007

    These articles tell us how good we can become

    Aish means fire, which gives light and warmth, something that every human being needs to live. To make matzah, first, we have to need the dough, but in order that the dough should become matza, the food of faith, and the food of healing, there has to be the "aish" the fire, the light of Torah, and the warmth of the love of a Jew, the real chi=18 min. life

  • (1) Michal , March 30, 2006

    Very interesting

    ...so that's what the whole discussion is about! Well, it came that far that I have never seen hand baked matzot-maybe that's a task for this Pessach:-) Thank you for giving this backgound information!

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field
Submit Comment

About the Author

Rabbi Berel Wein

Berel Wein, the Founder and Director of The Destiny Foundation has, for over 20 years, been identified with the popularization of Jewish history through lectures worldwide, his more than 1000 audiotapes, books, seminars, educational tours and, most recently dramatic and documentary films.

Rabbi Wein has authored five Jewish History books - Triumph of Survival, The Story of the Jews in the Modern Era, Heralds of Destiny, the Medieval Era, Echoes of Glory, the Classical Era, and Faith and Fate, the story of the Jews in the Twentieth Century - all of which have received popular and critical acclaim. His newest book is The Oral Law of Sinai - An Illustrated History of the Mishnah Logic, Legend & Truth.

Rabbi Wein, a member of the Illinois Bar Association, is the recipient of the Educator of the Year Award from the Covenant Foundation in 1993. Most recently, Rabbi Wein received the Torah Prize Award from Machon Harav Frank in Jerusalem for his achievements in teaching Torah and spreading Judaism around the world. Rabbi Wein lives and teaches in Jerusalem. Visit his site at http://www.rabbiwein.com

Related Articles

Sponsors