click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Poland, Women & the Holocaust
Rabbi Benjamin Blech

Poland, Women & the Holocaust

Three groundbreaking works reveal disturbing facts about the perpetrators of genocide.


The horrors of the Holocaust demand of us more than mere remembrance or commemoration.

It is commendable that we have erected monuments for the six million and that we light candles in the memory of those who were so cruelly murdered. But lit candles do not enlighten us nor do they assist us to understand the events of the past in a manner that will help us to prevent a reoccurrence.

More than memorials, what will in the long run prove far more significant is the kind of work based on serious research that permits us insight into the truths – often hidden or buried from public view – that made the Holocaust possible. To reveal them is to pay the victims the greatest tribute of all by making their fate an impossibility for the future.

And that, I believe, is what makes three groundbreaking works of the past few weeks so very important.

The first is a new book, Hunt for the Jews: Betrayal and Murder in German-Occupied

Poland, published this October. Written by Polish historian Jan Grabowski, the son of a Holocaust survivor, a graduate of Warsaw University and currently a history professor at University of Ottawa, it records the massacres of Jews by their neighbors in his native Poland, until now a little-told chapter of Holocaust history.

Grabowski has suffered death threats but insists he will not give up his struggle to expose the truth.

Boycotted in the Canadian Polish community where he lives today, and no longer welcome in his homeland, Grabowski has suffered death threats but insists he will not give up his struggle to expose the truth.

“The purpose of my research was to discover the condition of the Jews who managed to avoid being sent to death camps and chose to live in hiding. My research brought me to the level of individual cases of people who chose to hide. I tried to understand how only very few of those Jews who decided to hide were able to stay alive until 1945,” says Grabowski.

Grabowski interviewed Holocaust survivors and local residents, primarily in Poland, Israel and Germany. In addition, he studied previously unpublished results of dozens of trials of Polish residents tried by the Communist regime for taking part in the killing of their Jewish neighbors.

To his dismay, Grabowski has found many Poles are still not ready to face the past and the fact that many of their ancestors took an active part in the extermination of the Jews.

Neighbors of Jedwabne

The same theme is the message of the movie Pokłosie (Aftermath), which hit the screens in Poland last November and will open this week in the US. Based on Princeton professor Jan Gross’s explosive 2001 work Neighbors, it examines the massacre of Jews from Jedwabne village in Nazi-occupied Poland and reveals that it was the Poles, not the Nazis, who were to blame.

“One day, in July 1941, half of the population of a small east European town murdered the other half – some 1,600 men, women and children."

“One day, in July 1941, half of the population of a small east European town murdered the other half – some 1,600 men, women and children." This is how historian Jan Gross summarized the massacre that occurred in Jedwabne, in northeastern Poland. Gross described the atrocities in almost unbearable detail: Men and women were hacked to death with knives, iron hooks, and axes. Small children were thrown with pitchforks onto a bonfire. A woman's decapitated head was kicked like a football. Local townsmen-turned-hooligans grabbed clubs studded with nails and other weapons and chased the Jews into the street. Many tried to escape through the surrounding fields, but only seven succeeded. The thugs fatally shot many Jews after forcing them to dig mass graves. They shoved the remaining hundreds of Jews into a barn, doused it with kerosene and set it ablaze. Some on the outside played musical instruments to drown out the victims' cries.

Till now historians blamed the massacre on the Nazis. Gross argues that “a virulent Polish anti-Semitism was liberated by German occupation.” Neighbors sets the record straight as to the identity of the criminals. As Publishers Weekly puts it, “In doing so, Gross has ensured that future histories of the Holocaust, particularly in Poland, will be more honest, because future historians will be answerable to his argument that the evil of the Nazis was not only forced on the Poles. In places such as Jedwabne, it was welcomed by them.”

The new film, Aftermath, brings that message forcefully to the screen. And like Grabowski, the film’s star Maciej Stuhr has already received death threats, and in several online forums there were comments such as “You are not a Pole anymore, you have become a Jew.”

Women & Genocide

Finally, there is one more addition to most recent Holocaust literature that deserves to be mentioned for its groundbreaking information. Published in October of this year as well, Hitler’s Furies is the exquisitely researched new work by Wendy Lower, already a finalist for the National Book Award.

Lower forces us to knowledge that historians have till now ignored the role of German women in the story of Nazi genocide and Hitler’s plan for the “final solution.” Her book is a deeply disturbing chronicle of women’s participation in the Holocaust, not only as “desk murderers” — secretaries and administrators whose weapon was not a Luger or a gas chamber but a typewriter — but also, as Lower reveals in chilling detail, capable of the same savagery as their male counterparts. This she takes pains to emphasize is a fact often overlooked by Holocaust scholars and historians, a shocking truth whose evidence has been hidden for more than 70 years. “Genocide,” as Lower puts it, “can be women’s business as well.”

It is now more than half a century after the Holocaust. Living witnesses will soon no longer be available to us. All we will be left with is their records, their testimonies, and their stories. Our mission is to make sense of them in a way that will help insure that the insanity of that time never again stain the history of civilization. Research that uncovers the truth needs to be valued as noble and necessary efforts towards that goal.

November 9, 2013

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 38

(29) Kenan Moss, December 20, 2013 3:50 PM

Pope John Paul ll and anti-semitism

All this brings to mind the convent built in the grounds of Auschwitz. The then Pope's reaction was that he had no power to intervene in the internal affairs of the Polish Church: this despite Cardinal Glemp's reply to the Jewish objection to the building on land which will forever be sacred to the memory of our family. Glemp said "this is just one more example of the centuries long persecution of the Polish people by the Jews". Was John Paul ll's respose appropriate; was it true? It was neither. In the case of the vast network of paedophilia protected by the chuch, the micro-management of the church by him was clearly the reason for the decission that the church was imputable.

(28) RebYid, November 15, 2013 5:04 AM

It seems that the Poles are also part of Amalek in their quest to eradicate world Jewry. Even though they may not be of the same ethnicity, their egregious monstrosities that they committed against the Jews is manifested in the fact that they have many things in common with Amalek. Only someone as evil as Amalek could've done what the Nazis did.

(27) Beverly Kurtin, November 14, 2013 4:08 PM

New York

Europe is not alone in its new rising Jew hate. I cannot wait to get that book to give to one of my Polish neighbors. I will bet that she will deny that it never happened.
The places we need to go RIGHT NOW are the schools and the churches to tell them what has happened and what is happening RIGHT NOW.
There CAN be another Holocaust and it CAN happen in the United States.
This Jew will not sit idly around waiting for it to happen again; I'm fighting it here where I live; all Jews need to do the same.

Richard Feldman, January 20, 2017 1:22 PM

Bringing exhibit to New York called Life in the Bedzin Ghetto, Before, During and After the Holocaust.

I'm working on a project to bring an exhibit: Life and Death in the Bedzin Ghetto Before, During and After the Holocaust to New York from the Martin-Springer Institute in Arizona. (Bedzin was one of the first towns attacked in Poland on September 1, 1939. The whole region of Zaglembie which includes the town of Oswiecim was made Judenfrei). If you are interested in learning more about this exhibit or want to help this project please contact me. Thanks

(26) Lea, November 13, 2013 7:52 PM

Thank you for this

I'm sorry that there are those who are commenting that they don't want to hear it any more. So to them I say, click to another page, put your head in the sand... but watch your back.

None of this is news to me. Although both my parents were born in the US (first generation) they made it clear to me what the Poles did. I have always known about the hatred of the Poles and the French as well (did I mention the Ukranians?). This is the ugliness of humanity and that ugliness and hatred is not dead.

My simple warning? If you are a Jew today, don't get too comfortable. Every time the Jews are attacked it looks different. Inquisition, pogroms, holocaust... it will come around again and it won't look like anything you've seen before. Have a valid passport and be ready to run home to Israel.

That said, I don't spend my time hating the Poles, but I do not trust them (or the French or Obama!). The truth should be known and noted.

Then, do all the good you can do in the world to tip the scales!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment