click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Scrooge Season

Scrooge Season

Mankind should be our business.


I had two thoughts as I watched Disney’s latest production of A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens, directed by Robert Zemeckis. One was that I’m glad I didn’t go to the 3-D version! The other was that I’m glad I’m not a small child. The movie was simultaneously terrifying -- and slow moving. It’s hard to believe it will be a hit with the younger set, or that parents will even want to risk it.

Which is a shame, because despite the drawbacks in the current film, the story and its message remain important. As Jews we need to put aside the ever-present Christmas theme and ignore Dickens’s slightly anti-Semitic portrayal of avaricious characters, and instead focus on the possible lessons to be learned.

Perhaps the most famous passage in A Christmas Carol occurs near the beginning of the adventure when Scrooge receives a terrifying (I jumped out of my seat!) nighttime visit from the ghost of Jacob Marley. Marley appears wearing the “chains he forged in life” -- through his greed and self-interest and lack of compassion for others. He comes to warn his former partner of the dangers of that path.

"But you were always a good man of business, Jacob,” Scrooge replies.

“Business!" cried the Ghost, “Mankind was my business. The common welfare was my business; charity, mercy, forbearance, and benevolence were all my business. The dealings of my trade were but a drop of water in the comprehensive ocean of my business!”

This is, of course, the point. But Scrooge needs to see it all laid out for him -- the pain of the past, the potential for the future -- before the idea is real to him, before he can change.

Most of us aren’t given that opportunity. We aren’t visited by ghosts and we don’t travel through time, in either direction.

But we can all reflect on the folly of self-absorption and selfishness, on the dangers of indifference to others, on the price we will ultimately pay for time ill-spent, time that can never be recouped or reacquired.

This is true for us as individuals as well as in any positions of leadership we play -- whether it’s community work, politics or as the CEO of a large corporation. “Mankind should be our business.” It should never be business as usual. The needs of others should always be paramount. Individuals and corporations are accountable.

John F. Kennedy recognized this is a speech he gave to the Florida State Chamber of Commerce on November 18, 1963 (note the date -- it certainly gives his words an added poignancy; yes, time really is short):

“I realize that there are some businessmen who feel only they want to be left alone, that Government and politics are none of their affairs, that the balance sheet and profit rate of their own corporation are of more importance than the worldwide balance of power of the Nationwide rate of unemployment. But I hope it is not rushing the season to recall to you the passage from Dickens’ A Christmas Carol… [here he quotes the passage we mentioned above] Member and guests of the Florida State Chamber of Commerce, whether we work in the White House of the State House of the in a house of industry or commerce, mankind is our business. And if we work in harmony, if we understand the problems of each other and the responsibilities that each of us bears, then surely the business of mankind will prosper. And your children and mine will move ahead in a securer world, and one in which there is opportunity for them all.”

Click the media player to watch a video of the speech (article continues below).

This is a lofty goal, a noble goal. We may not reach it, but it is worth striving for. Although I didn’t enjoy Disney’s latest effort, I do believe that a high quality presentation of Dickens’ famous story (perhaps one of the earlier versions) will help drive the point home and keep it reverberating in our hearts and minds for days and weeks (and perhaps even longer) to come. That’s the real power of movies after all.

Click below to watch the movie trailer

November 15, 2009

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 9

(9) Debbie, December 22, 2009 5:44 PM

saw it

My husband and I saw it in 33 IMAX and I did have to turn my head a couple of times for all its intensity!. Giving shouldn't be reserved for one day a year, as our Jewish Heritage teaches us. Plus giving can come in many forms, not money alone. I don't think the movie inspired me more than my FFB upbringing, but one point will stay with me. My friend pointed out to me that the most important part was towards the end when the large man passed ES on the street and Scrooge practically begged him to let him donate to the cause. We should all look at people who ask of us to give as messengers and bearers of opportunities for us to gain merit in the World to Come. i.e. "Thanks for asking!"

(8) Anonymous, November 30, 2009 8:33 PM

Are you Dickens?

Surprised and glad to hear such a sound comment on The movie is very well done. I'd argue your vision of anti-jewish points neither in the book nor in the film, but I did enjoy over again how Dickens is great and easy at giving us lessons of universal good and mercy - this is what I've seen in your article too - thanks for that!

(7) Steve, November 22, 2009 6:53 PM

1 who has time for movies? 2 who can [or wants to] afford it? 3 guess for a guy who is pushing 60, I am a Scrooge!

(6) Alan Drake Tyree, November 22, 2009 4:13 AM

Another opinion About Disney's A Christmas Carol

I saw the 3D version of Disney's A Christmas Carol. I thought it was going to be funnier with Jim Carey in it, but it seemed to be almost strictly by the book, and bland. I was disappointed. My favorite takes on Charles Dickens A Christmas Carol is The Muppets Christmas Carol, because its funny, cute, and has good music, but I also like Scrooge, with Bill Murray. It's funny, yet still has a good message.

(5) Anonymous, November 21, 2009 6:30 PM

Note from a traditionalist

In my humble opinion, THE BEST version is the 1951 film with Alastair Sim. You just can't improve on perfection.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment