click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Puncture: The Inside Story

Puncture: The Inside Story

How I made a Hollywood movie with absolutely no Hollywood experience and a little inspiration from my rabbi.


Have you ever watched a movie -- one of those terrible movies -- and thought to yourself, “I could do that. I could make a movie. In fact, my life is so fascinating that it would make an incredible movie!” Come on, I know I’m not the only crazy person who thought that. What may make me different however is that I may have been one of the few crazy people who actually followed through.

Indeed, with absolutely no “Hollywood” experience, I just executive produced a movie called Puncture starring Chris Evans (Captain America) which will be in select theatres shortly.

My story began in, of all places, shul.

My story (the story behind the story that is) began in, of all places, shul. I was sitting in the children’s service when the rabbi came in to explain the Torah portion Lech Lecha to the kids. He explained how Abraham had a comfortable life making idols. But that God had commanded Abraham to “go forth”. The rabbi said that as Jews we have an obligation to try new things, take risks and make the world a better place. I thought about the rabbi’s lesson to the kids but realized he was really speaking to me.

I, like Abraham, had grown complacent. I was a successful attorney, had tried some high profile cases, but felt like there was more that I could do. In particular, thanks to one of the cases that I tried, I had an important story that I believed the world needed to hear.

Years ago, my partner Mike Weiss and I took on a case involving a local ER nurse who was infected with AIDS by an accidental needle stick. Once involved in the case I realized the significant issues involved including:

- Accidental needle sticks cause thousands of US nurses, doctors, and patients to be infected by AIDS, Hepatitis C and other infectious diseases every year;

- Needle reuse in Africa and Asia directly cause 1.3 million deaths annually, 23 million hepatitis infections annually and 260,000 HIV/AIDS infections annually; and

- Large Group Purchasing Organizations are preventing new and life saving medical products from getting to market and costing the US health care system over $37 billion a year.

The case settled, but my mind never did. So in 2004 I decided to write an autobiographical screenplay about our case. I decided that our story needed to be turned into a film. There was a problem though: my screenplay was …uh…shall we say “weak.”

Hollywood rule number one: never write an autobiographical screenplay. Rule number one, broken.

Undeterred, I hired a New York based screenwriter named Ela Thier to take my vision and rewrite it. And she did. Superbly.

Everyone I knew in the movie business told me that the only way to get your screenplay made is to find an agent who will show it to the right people. The last thing you want to do, everyone told me, was to send copies of your screenplay to production companies, movie studios and actors. That’s a complete waste of time. But that’s exactly what I did.

Hollywood rule number two: never send indiscriminate scripts to random addresses. Rule number two, broken.

Ninety percent of the scripts that I sent out were returned to me unread. But I did manage to get two phone calls, and I flew to New York immediately to meet with both groups. By the end of the trip I had a deal with filmmakers Mark and Adam Kassen. The deal terms were that I’d give them a year and a half to rewrite the script, and try and attach a star and in return they would give me nothing. I know -- as a lawyer, not the best deal I’ve ever negotiated.

About 15 months later, they rewrote the script -- by Chris Lopata, and they signed an “A list” star -- Chris Evans. But there was only one problem: we had no money.

Mark and Adam Kassen told me bluntly, “If you raise the money, we’ll make the movie.”

And this brings us back to that day during the rabbi’s speech about Lech Lecha. I, like Abraham, had to take action. It was time to take a risk. At that moment, I decided that would put up the money to make the movie.

I realized that the money that I would put into this highly speculative and risky venture was like an idol - it had to be smashed. So I invested my money along with some additional capital that I raised from some friends to make the movie.

Hollywood rule number three: never, under any circumstances, put up the money to finance your own film. Rule number three, broken.

But as the saying goes, “rules are made to be broken,” and good thing they are. Puncture was admitted to the 2011 Tribeca Film Festival and selected to serve as one of the spotlight premieres. Millennium Films acquired the distribution rights and the film will open in select cities shortly.

So with this ten year movie making adventure coming to a close, I often find myself sitting in shul and wondering what lessons I’ve learned.

Well, I’ve learned that since we were exiled from the Garden of Eden, humanity has had to struggle. Struggle to do good deeds -- yes, but that is not enough. We must also struggle against injustice. We shouldn’t get discouraged if life presents us with seemingly insurmountable obstacles. We should face them fervently, because God has given them to us, and he knows full well that these obstacles are in fact very surmountable.

These are some of the lessons I’ve learned sitting through years of my rabbi’s sermons…and from making a Hollywood movie. So the next time you see someone dozing while the rabbi is talking, be sure to wake him up. He may be missing a life changing experience!

Puncture opened on September 23 in New York, Los Angeles and Houston and nationwide later in the fall.

September 24, 2011

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 12

(10) Jeongeui Bak, August 15, 2016 6:24 PM

this is what hapend in my country

I watched this movie long long year ago maybe 2years ago. Briefly i will introduce myself. I'm a nursing student from Korea. and went to US for 4mths as a governmental scholarship student. I had nursing practical period there. While I was there, I saw one thing really cool which is safety syringe. That moment just the movie passed my head. When I got back to Korea I could see what happened in my country. One hospital reused syringe which have used to patient. So that over 70 people got hepatitis C by not using safety syringe. In my country using safety syringe haven't registered as a law yet. Also like the movie they not tend to use it as matter of price. Safety syringe is three times expensive than normal one. I have an experience that i invented safety cup for young and old people. From that experience I wish I could invent "the other type of safety syringe", aka K-safety syringe. Make it more cheaper than the safety syringe now that using in the hospital(some hospital actually using safety syringe in some places such as Emergency room or Intensive Care unit. Especially big hospital). but the problem is small hospital that they even don't stock safety syringe. Thanks for reading my comments. Further questions are welcome.

(9) Thomas Kiser, August 8, 2015 4:31 AM

Im inspired!! By your story

One hell of a ride (Puncture). Loved the movie, but admired the risk even more!

(8) Renee, April 28, 2013 8:05 PM


This movie was just amazing. I am so glad it was able to be made! It's a movie that has really stuck in my mind.

(7) Theresa, August 1, 2012 4:01 PM

Puncture made me cry, but in a good way. I see how one man's passion for something had to carry on, with or without him. As a result, it made changes within the medical community. A great eye opener and I appreciate your passion for informing us the origins of the changes. I love true stories and this was truly a good one.

(6) George, March 15, 2012 10:29 AM

Do not be afraid!!!

Great Movie!!! This movie reminds me of this bible passage on courage: When you go to war against your enemies and see horses and chariots and an army greater than yours, do not be afraid of them, because the LORD your God, who brought you up out of Egypt, will be with you. Deuteronomy 20:1, RIP Michael

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment