click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Twilight: A Love Story?

Twilight: A Love Story?

Why the vampire series captivates today’s girlie girl culture.


The Twilight Saga has taken teenage girls everywhere by the throat. Pun intended.

"People don't want to just read Stephenie Meyer's books; they want to climb inside them and live there," wrote Time magazine, adding, "[Fans] dress up like her characters. They write their own stories about them and post their tales on the Internet. When she appears at a bookstore, 3,000 people go to meet her. There are Twilight-themed rock bands."

If you haven't heard of The Twilight Saga, then for the past six years you have have managed to avoid contact with all females between the ages of nine and 19. Teenage girls wait days to catch a glimpse of the movie-adaptation actors. They pull out their hair. They scream and cry. They hoard merchandise ranging from the chintzy Twilight-themed school supplies, room decorations and clothing, to the downright bizarre. Twilight-themed tattoos, shower curtains and cookbooks are just the beginning.

Twilight-themed school supplies and cookbooks are just the beginning.

Beyond its corporate identity as an outlandish marketing phenomenon, blockbuster film, and publishing explosion (over 100 million books sold), Twilight has also reshaped the sensibilities of a generation. I grew up under the pounding brand waterfall of "Girl Power!", the slogan of the first of many neon-wearing, skin-flaunting girl bands to catch the pop-psychology female-empowerment wave that began long ago with characters like Rainbow Brite, Jem and the Holograms, and even Strawberry Shortcake. Right around when I turned 12, Rainbow Brite suddenly grew up and girls my age grew up with her.

Today, the same kids who dreamed of going to elementary school at Hogwart’s now dream of going to high school in Forks. But Twilight seems to touch a deeper nerve. Behind the obsession with vampirish good looks, Twilight grabs at a stray chord in the heart to play something so vivid and haunting that girls won't let go.

Why the obsession? What chord hath been strummed?

One in Four

I admit, I like Twilight. Guilty as charged. I couldn't put the books down.

But then I read another book a few months later that put the Twilight phenomenon into much clearer perspective. Called Reviving Ophelia: Saving the Selves of Adolescent Girls, quoted a study conducted in Rhode Island in the 1990s:

Teens were asked to respond to questions about the circumstances under which a man “has the right to have sexual intercourse with a woman without her consent.” …At least eighty percent of these teenagers didn't know that a man never has a right to force sex.

She goes on to depict the daily sexual harassment and pressure teenage girls suffer as they walk the gauntlet that begins around fifth grade and ends, hopefully, after college. Her depictions of interviewees read like war stories except for the fact that these are the typical experiences of young women growing up in America. The teasing. The blackmail. The gossip. The labeling. To say nothing of the rape and date rape that is now documented to harrow the lives of one in four women in America today. The depression, cutting, suicide attempts.

This is what counts for normal growing up in today's generation? "Girl Power" wasn't the half of it. Today's pop culture has become a morass of barely disguised pornography masquerading as the natural next step after The Disney Channel. Think Britney Spears and Miley Cyrus, stars so aggressively vulgar that the Spice Girls look chaste in comparison.

Enter Twilight. Stephenie Meyer, a stay-at-home mom in Utah, inadvertently started a revolution. Teenagers sick of being used as pawns in advertising's lowest-common-denominator manipulations woke up to the themes of Twilight, took a mass breather, and it changed them.

The Power of Ahava

What are these oh-so-powerful themes in Stephenie Meyer's oh-so-successful Twilight? One word: love. Twilight is a love story. There really isn't much more to it.

But not love the way the American advertising industry defines it. Love a lot more like the way our Jewish tradition defines it. Love, in Hebrew, is ahava: literally, I will give. I will take care of you. I will make personal sacrifices for your wellbeing. I will do whatever it takes, go to whatever lengths, to give you everything I possibly can. That's love. That's ahava. Ahava doesn't compromise, or lose faith, or become blinded by passing seductions.

The more we give, the more we love.

The real secret, teaches Rabbi Eliyahu Eliezer Dessler in his famous Strive for Truth, is that the wonderful feelings of fulfillment and happiness that we all long to experience – the bliss and magic of love – come about not through getting but by giving love. When we open our eyes to the person standing in front of us and move our hearts to care for them (care being an active verb), we feel love. Our hearts flood with something wonderful and indescribable. We experience connection of the most profound human experience.

The best part is that the more we give, the more we love. We can tap into this power at any time. There is nothing more noble or more beautiful.

Of course, nobody ever said it was easy. Just as it does for all of us, love forces Bella and Edward to make a large number of very tough choices, moral dilemmas that revolve around the central themes of our human lives: immediate gratification vs. altruistic, long-term commitment. The body vs. the soul. That this is played out under the extreme circumstances of werewolves and vampires makes it more fun, but, ironically, no less relatable.

Will you choose to become a member of the Volturi, the evil vampires who feast ruthlessly and elegantly on human blood, or will you choose to be a member of the Cullen family, the vampires who overcome their powerful desires by satiating themselves on animal blood instead? Will you fight hard for revenge like Victoria, or for kindness like Carlisle?

How far will you go for the one you love? Will you risk your life? Will you give up everything to change in fundamental ways? Rabbi Lawrence Kelemen says that the purpose of marriage is to tell your partner, in word and deed, "I am here to make your dreams come true."

Young women around the world want to know what will happen to Edward and Bella because they matter. Their values matter. Sure, there's violent danger to Bella's life at regular intervals, the Cullens have to up and fight some bad guys, and Bella waffles a bit between her best friend, the werewolf, and the love of her life, the vampire. But at the end of the day – please excuse the unabashed sappiness – it's the fact that Bella and Edward just love each other so much that keeps the story going. Will love win?

Twilight has given an entire generation a mental picture of what it looks like to choose heroism over fear, true greatness over superficial power, love over lust and exploitation. Sick of the alternative, teenage girls from New Zealand to Japan to the United States are latching on with the thirst of a vampire. Against all odds, they believe that love really does conquer all.

They’re right. By choosing ahava again and again, we can create our own happy endings.

November 12, 2011

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 23

(14) Montana, February 8, 2015 5:05 AM

Truly Beautiful

I really thought the love story was well treated and beautiful though of course, it was a little on the corny side. It was such a breath of fresh air to have a hero who could act like a gentleman!

(13) Edward, April 17, 2014 9:30 AM

Edward The Great

I can see what the Marxists have done here to smear my name. Don't ever think that you are better than everyone else if in your "virtues" you lack integrity. This is what holds the Dorian's together.

For all time we will hold our national identity because it's in our blood and when the time comes, the dormant supressed spirit will know what to do.

Like I said, a personal insult that hasn't gone unnoticed.
The reason they still suffer is because the "romantic-fallacy" has been executed well and they want to believe that "those" aren't "out to get them". It's love and virtues that will always reveal the true natures of all nations of the world..

(12) Teenage girl, December 18, 2011 4:32 AM

Back again with a warning

I find him bitterly ironic people would encourage young girls to read this on the grounds it's a good book for young girls. Have you read the third book, in where Bella runs way from home with Edward and Jacob? It's so cold, Bella may freeze to death, so the solution the boys decide upon is that she must sleep with Jacob. Indeed, in the same sleeping bag, which Edward blithley permits. In the next chapter, Jacob attempts to force himself on Bella. The originial vampires were metaphors for the supressed sexuality of the Victorian age, and many were thinly veiled metaphors for sodomy. Werewolves were used in mideval Europe to explain the concept of serial killers. Disturbing? Without a doubt, and yet Twilight is passed off as decent literature. case be? “His eyes burned with sincerity for a protracted moment—playing havoc with the rhythm of my heart—and then turned playful" I have little doubt a sentence like this would give any decent english teacher a heart attack. What, to sum up, does this show impressonable readers? 1) Romance is ALL physical. Rare do they rave about something not related to the love of thier lfe's eyes, hair, skin, "scent" (remarkably predatory) 2) This rubbish is passed about as good writing. I shall applaud anyone who can make sense of the above sentence. I do not mean to be rude. Perhaps this book is good for goyish girls with its message of waiting unitl marriage, but it's quite a bad idea for jewish girls. Isn't it somewhat foolish, with our determination to protect us young girls, but expose us to shmutz? I saw what happened to my friends. One was so repulsed by what happened in the last she looked physically ill. You may disagree, but please consider before handing the books over to your delighted daughter.

Montana, February 8, 2015 5:07 AM

Well would you want the love of your life to freeze to death? Get real! And though you may call it schmutz, it sounds like you've read all three books.

rth, March 28, 2017 4:35 PM

The original vampires were actually just literal bloodsuckers, not a metaphor.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment