click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Jewish American Idol

Jewish American Idol

An exclusive, advanced look at the new TV reality show.


One of the advantages of living in Los Angeles, the very nerve center of show business, is that with the right connections, one is privy to all sorts of inside information. Through an inside source who prefers to remain anonymous, I recently became aware of an exciting new reality TV show, scheduled to premiere this Fall on the new Jewish TV network, OyVision, that is certain to become a ratings hit, especially among Jewish viewers. It is called "Jewish American Idol."

Show Format

"Jewish American Idol" is the first Jewish-themed TV reality show in America. It will feature Jewish men and women of all ages competing in a constantly changing series of Jewish-themed challenges. Viewers will be able to call in and vote for their favorites. The contestants will also be evaluated by three celebrity Jewish judges. Offers have been made to Billy Crystal, Jerry Seinfeld and Roseanne Barr to serve as judges for the pilot episode. Each season, the top 12 contestants will participate in a "Jewish American Idol" tour of the U.S., Israel, and selected countries world-wide. And contestant auditions will be held in major cities throughout America.

The Challenges

Most High-Cholesterol Meal Consumed Within Five Minutes

Contestants will be able to put together their own meal, selecting from pastrami and corned beef sandwiches on onion roll, potato pancakes, knishes, stuffed derma, chopped liver, beef brisket, flank steak, challah, bagels, eggs and lox, gefilte fish, tzimmes, matzoh balls, and, of course, the perennial Jewish favorite -- Chinese food. After gorging for five minutes, the show's on-duty Jewish doctor will take contestants' blood samples and extract the cholesterol levels. Those with the highest cholesterol readings go on to the next round.

After gorging for five minutes, the show's on-duty Jewish doctor will take contestants' blood cholesterol levels. The highest move to the next round.

Best Case of Guilt Transferred from Parent to Child

Parents will select from such traditional Jewish guilt topics as: Your Father Worked Himself to Death to Send You to College and This is How You Repay Him, My Dying Wish is That You Give Me a Grandchild, Your Ancestors Didn't Escape the Nazis So You Could Not Go to Temple, I Don't Want You to Feel Compelled to Come to Passover Even Though it Could Be My Last One, and I'd Really Appreciate it if You'd Shovel the Driveway Now Unless You Really Want Your Poor Father to Have a Heart Attack.

Most-Convincing Rationalization

Parent contestants will do their best to rationalize to their friends, neighbors and relatives one of the following questionable career choices of their college graduate children: Tattoo artist, gang member, bartender, lion tamer, soldier of fortune, yoga instructor, coal miner, surfer, sushi chef, clown, rodeo cowboy, welder, trucker, Scientology processor, assistant manager at Jack In The Box, and hit man. Parents will be hooked up to lie detectors, which will determine the level to which they are actually okay with their kids' career choices.

Least-Athletic Activity Considered a Workout

Contestants will attempt to convince the judges, as well as the home and studio audiences, that they actually believe they are receiving a vigorous, beneficial workout by regularly engaging in one of the following "workout" activities: Sitting in a sauna, checking out sales during a walk through the mall, taking the dog down the street to relieve itself, vacuuming, dancing at their cousin Reuven's bar mitzvah reception, getting the cat out from under the couch, playing Air Hockey at Chuck E. Cheese, gardening, chasing dogs off the lawn, getting a massage, stretching, cracking their knuckles.

Jewish Obstacle Course Race

Contestants will race over a 10-mile outdoor course that features obstacles they must either avoid, jump over or get beyond. These obstacles include the giant pit of pork products, attractive non-Jews attempting to lure contestants to date them, vendors selling products at retail, CDs of church hymns, country clubs not accepting Jews, various home improvement projects, and a giant piece of Wonder Bread smothered in Miracle Whip.

Best Comment About a Relative Who Does or Did Something Better Than You

Contestants will be judged on how badly they can make someone feel based on their comments comparing the person to some friend, neighbor or relative who managed to achieve something far greater than the person in question, often with far fewer resources and privileges to accomplish it. Example: "By the time he was twenty-three, your Uncle Arthur, who was an orphan I might remind you, had already been awarded the Purple Heart, gotten a PhD in Economics, married, had three children, and had become Chairman of the Board of a company just three months after he'd started there as a shipping clerk."

I, for one, just can't wait to see "Jewish American Idol." If it's even half as good as last year's "Amish American Idol," I know we're all for a big treat.

In addition to being one of the Chosen People, Mark Miller has written on numerous sit-com staffs, performed stand-up comedy in nightclubs and on TV, and been a humor columnist for the Los Angeles Times Syndicate. He can be reached at

June 21, 2008

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 9

(9) Anonymous, October 18, 2013 2:52 AM

Honestly, I think this is a bad idea

I think this is a terrible idea that can only lead to more racist stereotyping and anti-semitism. We Jews get enough negative attention already we don't need to make fun of ourselves just for a few laughs and give the goyim more reasons to mock us.

(8) Freddy, March 18, 2012 12:43 PM

A better idea

List of predictable Jewish stereotypes aside wh not call the show "American Yidl"?

(7) Elam, August 17, 2008 4:18 PM

One hour chametz race

You could add a one hour chametz hunt .. Whoever finds the most chametz in a well stocked goy kitchen gets to sell it and keep the money :)

(6) David, June 27, 2008 3:16 PM

Other Exercise

One exercise to be considered is setting the table. Plus, doing it on Pesach is like running the marathon.

(5) Sam, June 26, 2008 10:11 PM

Vonder Bread?

I seem to recall that Vonder bread was invented by a Jewish Bakery and that Miracle Vip has a hechur.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment