click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Join 400,000 Aish subscribers
Get Email Updates




Say What?

Say What?

Do the things we tell our kids even make sense? Short answer: no.

by

I was in the supermarket the other day, and I overheard a child asking his mother for just about every kind of candy near the register. After the mother shot down several choices, the boy pulled one last bar off the shelf.

“Mommy! MOMMY! Is this one kosher?”

“Ooo, Mommy! Mommy! MOMMY! Is this one kosher?”

“No,” the mommy snapped.

I probably don’t need to tell you that we were actually standing in a kosher supermarket. Apparently, everything in the whole store is kosher except for the candy that they keep near the register. I’m not judging. What this mother did was a lot easier than explaining the real reason she didn’t want to buy it for him, with a bunch of impatient people waiting behind her:

“Look. If I buy you one, I’m going to have to buy one for all the other kids, because you can’t keep your mouth shut, or else I’m going to have to explain to each kid individually why you get to have chocolate and he doesn’t, and frankly, I don’t actually know the answer to that one. And then the next time you ask me, I’m going to have to come up with a reason that I said it was okay this time, but not next time, or else I’m going to have to spring for chocolate bars for everyone in the family, again.”

And it’s not like none of us ever stretches the truth with our kids. We’re not proud of it, but we tell ourselves that it’s just easier this way.

For example, a lot of people tell their kids that coffee stunts their growth. In fact, parents have been telling this to kids for generations, and our society has come to believe that it’s true. But there’s no research that proves it. Nevertheless, parents say it anyway, because they don’t want their children drinking coffee, the reason being that parents drink coffee in the first place so they can keep up with their kids. They don’t even want to think about how much coffee they’re going to have to drink if their kids started drinking coffee too. But this isn’t really something we want to explain to our kids, so we play on the fact that they want to grow big and strong, and combine that with our mutual lack of scientific knowledge.

“If you swallow the seeds, you’re going to have a watermelon growing in your stomach.”

“Like you, Daddy?”

This is also why we tell them that if they eat their vegetables, they’re going to grow up to be big and strong. Is this true? Doesn’t that have more to do with genetics and exercise? And even if they don’t eat any vegetables, chances are they’ll still grow up to be bigger and stronger than they are now. In fact, you’re not really sure what vegetables do. You yourself eat them so you won’t grow bigger. Are they magic? All you know is that your doctor keeps telling you to eat vegetables, so you eat vegetables.

“But why?”

“I’m the doctor. That’s why.”

There are many other things that we tell our kids that are not necessarily as true as they could be, such as, “I’m not going to say this again.” But the biggest is what we say when we’re trying to discourage our kids from lying:

“If you tell me the truth, I won’t get mad.”

No, you’ll get even. Most of us have had this conversation with our parents at some point:

“Aren’t you going to go easier on me for telling the truth?”

“Not after what you did!”

As parents, we find ourselves saying a lot of things to our kids, and most of these are things that we don’t want to have to tell them, or don’t want to have to tell them again, or never thought we’d have to say to another human being ever.

“Don’t lick the floor!”

(Seriously, you’ve never told your child before that he couldn’t lick the floor. How was he supposed to know?)

There are also a lot of things that we say to our kids that, upon closer examination, don’t quite make sense:

“What part of “Don’t hit your brother” don’t you understand?

Well, the “Don’t” part, obviously.

We’d always hoped we’d never have to say any of these clichéd parental things, but now we feel like it’s all we ever say:

“Don’t wipe that on me.”

“Close your mouth and eat your food.”

“Don’t hit your brother while he’s sleeping.”

“What would you like with your ketchup?”

“How would you like it if I spit in your soda?”

“Your shirt is not a napkin.”

“Why do you always get boo-boos after your bedtime?”

“Don’t eat ketchup with your fingers. At least use a spoon.”

“No, you’re not old enough to pour milk.”

“How do you know you don’t like it if you haven’t even tried it?”

“Of course you’re not going to like it now that you’ve said you’re not going to like it.”

“Don’t just stand there crying! Clean it up!”

“I said don’t lick the floor!”

“Alright, that’s it. I’m counting to three.”

I find myself counting to three way more often than any healthy person should.

I find myself counting to three way more often than any healthy person should. For a while, my son Heshy wasn’t even sure what number came after three. We’d watch him count his toys: “One, two, three, five, seven, fourteen, fourteen, fifteen…” So we started counting to ten. And it’s not like this really gave him more time anyway, because when we count to three, we stretch it out as long as we can. (I’m surprised he wasn’t counting: “One, two… two-and-a-half… two-and-three-quarters…”) To this day, my kids have no idea what’s going to happen when we get to three, but they have no desire to find out. Neither do I, because I’m pretty sure it will involve getting up.

I don’t know if I have a point. I guess my point is that our kids keep blindsiding us with questions and requests every minute of the day, and we don’t always have time to weigh all of our options. So we say whatever we can to try to turn them into decent human beings, and to get it over with before the next kid blindsides us with something.

But don’t worry. As you tell your kids, you’re the parent, and everything you do hurts you more than it hurts them (maybe you should eat more vegetables), and someday, they’re going to thank you for this.

Really? That’s going to be an awkward conversation.

Published: December 29, 2012


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 3

(3) Batsheva, January 4, 2013 8:29 AM

superb!

This was great, nothing like humor to drive home a lot of truth, keep on writing!

(2) C.D.Urbach, January 1, 2013 3:47 PM

You were, are and always will be....

THE NUMBER ONE HILARIOUS COMEDY WRITER For frum readers. Your humor is realistic, refreshing, and doesn't put down others. You might laugh at yourself...but we all relate to the situations. so it's like we are ALL actually laughing at human nature.....KEEP UP THE SUPERB WRITING.

(1) Dina, December 30, 2012 5:59 PM

LOLing for real

Best line EVER: "To this day, my kids have no idea what’s going to happen when we get to three, but they have no desire to find out. Neither do I, because I’m pretty sure it will involve getting up." Yup, I'm there! You keep writing, I'll keep laughing! It makes me smile just to see that there's a new Schmutter posted.

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!