click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Join 400,000 Aish subscribers
Get Email Updates




Partly Jewish?

Partly Jewish?

Most children raised in interfaith families lack the tools and knowledge to make informed choices.

by

This past Friday Susan Katz Miller wrote an impassioned piece for the New York Times entitled “Being Partly Jewish.” In response to the alarming results of the recent Pew study on American Jews, Mrs. Miller asserts that children in interfaith families are not lost to Judaism. She writes: “In the course of a year, my family celebrates Yom Kippur, Rosh Hashanah, Sukkot, Simhat Torah, Hanukkah, Passover and many Shabbats. We also celebrate All Saint’s Day and All Souls, Advent, Christmas, Lent and Easter.” The article asserts that by exposing children to different religions, they will be able to choose their beliefs for themselves.

Mrs. Miller claims that dual faith parenting is an exercise in letting go. But would we ‘let go’ of our children in any other area that we truly care about?

My parents raised me to reach for academic excellence. How did they do this? They sent me to private schools with rigorous curriculums. They made sure I did my homework. They praised my high marks and expressed disappointment when I worked below my potential. When I was in high school, my father took me to visit his alma mater, the Wharton School of Business. I’ll never forget sitting on the empty bleachers with my father in the Hutch gym at the University of Pennsylvania on that visit. He told me,: “This is your legacy. But, as you know, Ivy League legacies aren’t just passed down. You have to earn it. If you want to attend this school, then you need to spend the next four years working for it.”

And I did. But the choice that I made to get there was an informed one. My parents had given me years of the best education possible. If I was weak in a subject, they hired a tutor. I spent hours in SAT prep courses. I was given the opportunity to take advanced placement courses.

Without a strong Jewish education, there simply is no informed choice.

But what if my parents had told me that an Ivy League education was a nice idea but a high school diploma was a fine choice too? And what if they had taken me for occasional visits to the University of Pennsylvania without giving me the kind of education that would make it possible for me to gain entry into the school at all? What if they had showed me around the beautiful campus a few times a year and forgot about the SATs altogether? Would I really have had a choice then?

This is what it is like when a child has only the most basic, superficial knowledge of Judaism. The campus looks impressive. The students are brilliant. The professors seem to have so much to teach. But what does any of it have to do with me?

And if the high school diploma is a choice that is equally valued by my parents then why would I choose the more challenging path of a college degree? Without a strong Jewish education, there simply is no informed choice. Most children raised in interfaith families are skimming the surfaces of conflicting beliefs without the tools or the knowledge to be able to examine their own choices.

And even if a person is informed and ready to make a real choice, what does it mean to be ‘partly Jewish?’ Can I be partly married? On Monday, Wednesday and Friday I’ll be married. And on Sunday, Tuesday and Thursday and maybe Saturday, I’ll be single? It’s absurd because by definition, commitment is whole. We don’t give only half of our hearts to anything that we care about. We can’t know the depth of love that is possible in a marriage before we make an absolute commitment to another person. So too, we will never know the truth of the Torah and the beauty of Judaism if in our hearts, we think we are only ‘partly Jewish.’ (It bears mentioning that according to Jewish law, there is no such thing as ‘partly Jewish.’ If your mother is a Jew, you are totally Jewish, like it or not.)

Moreover, young children do not make these kinds of commitments. They absorb the values and ideas in their homes, but the real commitments come later in life when they set out on their own. Even children from the most observant homes will eventually have to make their own choices to commit to Judaism. This happened to me when I finally arrived at the Quad freshman dormitory at University of Pennsylvania. I felt free for the first time in my life. No curfew. No rules. No one questioning my decisions.

So I experimented. I kept kosher. I went to Hillel on Shabbos. But on every Thursday and Saturday night, I went partying with the rest of the kids in my dorm. I searched for truth and questioned my beliefs. But I was lucky. I had been given a Jewish day school education; without that, I wouldn’t have had the beliefs or the knowledge to be able to examine them. And when the good-looking, Catholic football player sitting next to me in Philosophy 101 asked me out, I didn’t say no because I felt like I was ‘forced’ to be Jewish. I said no because I had the ability to make an informed choice and an authentic commitment.

I wanted Judaism, and I wanted all of it. Today, I am a psychologist. I am a writer. I am a mother. I am a wife. I am not ‘partly’ any of these identities, and I am not ‘partly Jewish’ either. Instead I am blessed with wholeness. I am a whole Jew for my whole life because my parents cared enough about Judaism to give me a real choice.

Published: November 3, 2013


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 83

(54) Beverly Kurtin, April 17, 2014 7:50 PM

My granddaughters...

They know they are Jewish as they were born of a Jewish mother, my daughter. But they need me to spend some time with them to help them become active as Jews. Being mulato, they are gorgeous (you expect a Jewish buby to say anything less?) and it is my hope that they will raise their children to be Jews.
My son's son is lost to Judaism. I've not seen him in over a decade because of a falling out with his father. But he is lost to us.
Yes, I mourn the loss of any Jew, particularly one who is lost due to mixed marriage.
It is sad, very sad. What with is going on in the Ukraine, making Jews once again register themselves and declaring their property, and in France...the United States will eventually turn on Israel and subsequently her Jews. It is a sad time for humanity.
NEVER AGAIN? It is happening.

(53) alesandra, February 4, 2014 7:38 PM

Losing Jewish Legacy

I have personally experienced the down side of what you are talking about. My Jewish great, great Grandmother, a Cohen, had changed the spelling of her name and emigrated to America in order to survive religious persecution in Ireland. She emigrated to a Religious colony in Chillicothe, Ohio, probably with all good intentions of remaining Jewish. Unfortunately, that did not happen. I have spent many years trying to get back in. I emigrated to Israel with all three of my children after my non Jewish husband divorced me. We successfully lived in an Orthodox community. We went to Shul. We practiced all the feast days. I worked at the Chabbad House in the Rova. I desperately tried to get a conversion that would allow me to marry a Jew and keep my Jewish status but, alas, that never happened. Now my three beautiful children are lost souls to Judaism and are assimilated into Gentile communities because we were deported by refusal to allow us to.stay and convert. I am forced to stay alone in a single state because I refuse to marry or even date nonJew.

Jeff, February 5, 2014 6:00 PM

Jewish Law?

I'm sorry for what you are going through, and especially your children. According to the author of the article, she states that "according to Jewish law, there is no such thing as ‘partly Jewish.’ If your mother is a Jew, you are totally Jewish, like it or not." If that is Jewish law, I don't understand why you and your children weren't allowed to stay? While I can understand a community wanting to maintain a stronghold of beliefs and law, I don't understand the refusal to accept those who whole-heartedly wish to be a part of it?

david, April 18, 2014 1:02 AM

I hope that you can still be a friend to the Jewish people

Alesandra,

Although you are a gentile, you have committed yourself to marry only a Jew. Jewish law expressly prohibits such a union.

Although Jewish law reflects a mandate to all mankind to "be fruitful and multiply", you refuse to discharge that obligation by marrying a partner who is eligible to marry you in the eyes of Jewish law.

That which Jewish law forbids, you seek to do. That which Jewish law requires, you steadfastly reject. At a certain point a person has to realize that G-d loves you, and He made you a gentile. So it must be pretty okay for you to be a gentile. There is no obligation to become a Jew, but becoming a Jew entails a lot of obligation. I hope that you find your truth, happiness and a good and appropriate husband soon.

Anonymous, May 7, 2014 4:23 PM

David you appear very knowledgeable, what are your thoughts?

David how do you address the issue of children of Jewish fathers experiencing genuine antisemitism with menace attached to it when most of the wider world, especially antisemites, define Judaism purely in racial terms -and though even when made aware of the matrilineal rule, refuse to care about the matrilineal rule? I have had 4 such incidents ( thankfully no more than that, but it was enough to be disturbing), and I am more than happy not to identify myself as Jewish. In addition to having had these experiences I am concerned by the rise of antisemitism and politicians like Jobbik wanting to come to London to speak, and wanting people to go back 5 generations to prove they are not Jewish ( in his view then, not only am I Jewish, not only are my children Jewish, but my great great grandchildren are Jewish and worthy of negative treatment). Simultaneously Orthodox members of the Knesset want to change the Law of Return to exclude people such as myself and my offspring, so that should the lunatics take over the asylum, I and my children will have no refuge anywhere. I reassert that I don't want to be seen as Jewish, or any other religion. I just don't want to be placed in a catch 22 situation of being labelled Jewish by people who hate Jews, and simultaneously rejected by the Jewish community itself. I want a practical answer to these very real issues- any thoughts? ( Btw saying these issues would not be occurring had people like my parents not intermarried and in essence telling me that I should never have been born, really isn't helpful. And telling me to lie about my background to everyone as a pre- emptive measure isn't either. I don't announce my personal details unless I know people well anyway- hence this anonymous post. But as I am a real person, at times I also need to have honest communication in order to have meaningful interaction with other human beings. Sort of a necessity if you don't want to become really depressed really quickly!) Cheers.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!