click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

When God Moved Out

When God Moved Out

Tisha B'Av and the truth of consequences.


Joan, a once-beautiful, recovering alcoholic, stood up at an AA meeting and told her story:

I married Jeff, my high school sweetheart, and we had two kids. I started drinking when our kids were little, but Jeff had no idea. I used to hide the bottles in very clever hiding places, and I drank vodka, so he never smelled it on my breath.

But then my drinking got worse. Often I couldn't get up in the morning to get the kids off to school because of a hangover, so Jeff found out. He warned me that if I didn't stop, I'd destroy our family. I thought he was just threatening and I didn't listen to him.

My drinking got worse. Jeff told me, over and over again, that he would divorce me if I didn't go on the wagon. But you have to understand that he was crazy about me and always had been, so I knew he'd never do it.

Then, in the middle of the night one night, I woke up from a drunken stupor. I must have been out for a long time, maybe the whole previous day. I looked around and discovered that Jeff and the kids were gone. I mean really gone. They had moved out and taken all their stuff with them. I couldn't believe it. Jeff was always crazy about me. I was sure he'd come back. I was sure until the day the divorce papers arrived by registered mail. Then I knew that I had ruined my life. That's when I started to come to AA.

Unheeded Warnings

On Tisha B'Av God walked out on us and took His house with Him.

Tisha B'Av marks the day when God walked out on us, and took His house with Him. Like the husband in this true story, He had warned us, the Jewish people, over and over again. Like the wife in this story, we were convinced that His love for us would keep Him with us forever. We continued to indulge in destructive actions, heedless of their effect on us and on our union with the Almighty.

And then one day – the ninth day of the Hebrew month of Av – God did exactly what He had said He would do. He permitted our enemies to destroy the Holy Temple, which had been the resting place for the Divine Presence in this physical world, and He removed Himself from our lives.

The Jews of ancient Judea had never known life without God in their midst. The Temple of Solomon had dominated their existence for almost 400 years. Daily life in Jerusalem revolved around the Temple service, and even those who resided far away were obligated to make the pilgrimage to the Temple three times a year. Life without the Temple and the Divine immanence it represented was as inconceivable as ... the New York skyline without the World Trade Center.

The terrible day the Temple went up in flames was a day of defeat and death, of calamity and consternation. Yet the prevailing emotion, more than horror or grief, was disbelief. Just as Joan could not believe that her husband had really left her, so too the Jewish people – even after 150 years of Prophetic warnings – could not believe that God had really left them.

If we, the Jews of today, cannot muster grief over the calamity of Tisha B'Av, then we can find our point of connection elsewhere: in our same propensity to ignore consequences.


Is it possible to be both smart and foolish?

God created an orderly universe, one of whose principles is that actions produce consequences. Yet the human capacity to ignore consequences is astounding. Witness the person who pays his hard-earned money to buy a packet of cigarettes emblazoned with the warning, in inch-high, bold letters: SMOKING KILLS.

Most smokers are not masochists nurturing a death wish. If you ask them, "Aren't you afraid of getting lung cancer?" they will answer: "Smoking won't kill me. Why, I know a guy who smoked a pack a day and lived to be ninety."

The same denial of consequences pertains when we:

  • Eat a second helping of ice cream, not believing that we won't be able to button our clothes tomorrow.
  • Flirt with a member of the opposite sex, not believing that it will negatively impact our marriage.
  • Cheat in business, not believing we'll ever get caught.
  • Hit or yell at our children, not believing that it will undermine the relationship a decade later.
  • Devote the best years of our lives to our careers, not believing that we may be forfeiting our chance to have a family.

How can Intelligent People Live In Such A Fantasy World, Where No Object Casts A Shadow?

False Prophets

God sent a steady succession of Prophets to ancient Israel to warn them that the consequences of their sins would be defeat, destruction, and exile. Why didn't they listen?

For every true Prophet, there were many false prophets. The Bible repeatedly exhorts the people not to listen to "false prophets." Thus, while Jeremiah was warning the people that if they did not change their ways, Jerusalem and the Temple would be destroyed, the false prophets were reassuring the people that everything would be okay.

The inner false prophet proclaims: "Do whatever you want, it's okay."

The voice of the inner false prophet proclaims: "You can do whatever you want, and it'll be okay." The voice of the inner true prophet proclaims: "Beware of the consequences of your actions!"

Ethics of the Fathers teaches that a wise person always asks the question: "If I do this, what will happen next?"

  • If I criticize my neighbor, what will happen next?
  • If I invite my pretty secretary out for a drink after work, what will happen next?
  • If I cheat on just this one exam, what will happen next?
  • If I yell at my mother, what will happen next?

Asking this question can save one from much folly and disastrous results.

Failure to contemplate consequences can lead to outcomes as insignificant as gaining a pound, or as significant as a divorce, or as cosmically catastrophic as the destruction of the Holy Temple and the departure of the Divine Presence from our midst.

The metaphor of Joan and Jeff does not totally apply here. On Tisha B'Av God "moved out," but he never divorced the Jewish people. God's Covenant with the Patriarchs promises that, no matter what we do, we will be His people eternally. God will never marry another people.

But even without a divorce, separation is a painful state. Being separated from one's beloved spouse, not living together, not sharing companionship, not enjoying an intimate bond – is that a consequence any wise person would choose?

By the time Joan woke up and went to AA, it was too late to save her marriage. For us Jews, it's never too late to reconcile with our God.

For Sara Yoheved Rigler's FREE WEBINAR FOR SINGLE WOMEN, go to

Published: July 17, 2007

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 63

(60) Sharon, July 30, 2012 10:59 AM

It is like "I can drive as fast / wild as I wish & nothing will happen to me - until the accident happens

(59) patricia, July 17, 2012 3:08 PM

G-d never moves out. We move out on G-d but G-d will always be there waiting for us to return .

(58) Anonymous, July 17, 2012 10:02 AM

Good to a point but the analogy breaks down

This article is good to a point but the analogy breaks down when considering the Holocaust. Such persecution/suffering that the Jewish people suffered cannot be understood by the human mind especially the killing of millions of Jewish children. It is time for G-d to take the 'wife back' and send Moshiach!

Miriam, July 20, 2012 2:52 PM


I agree with you 100% The holocaust is one of the many events, which I to this day do not understand how god could have just "walked out" on his children. Yes there was assimilation, but not everyone gave into it. Hearing stories of my own family members being shot for being jewish and observing the laws, in the way they knew how? That is not a way to take "revenge" on your nation, that is supposed to be the chosen one. Moshiac definitely needs to come now more than ever.

(57) Yehudith Shraga, July 16, 2012 6:44 PM

The problem is right the reason is wrong

The problems are stated correctly,and it may be enlarged by each person, BUT"Failure to contemplate consequences"is absolutly wrong, it is said by people to hide much deeper reason for it, and as Zohar states- when the Angle of Death knocks the person down,and puts the sword to his throat,the person opens his mouth and swallows the drop of poison runing down this sword straight into his mouth,in more everyday words,it is a patient who may not breath without oxigen,but goes with it to smoke, though the spark may blow the oxigen container,or may triger the set up of the sufocation which will end in intubation and lack of possibility of extubation and finally-DEATH, so do you still think that this person don't comtemplate the consequences-he undergoes the suffer and pain of the tremendous fear, because only he knows what it is not to be able to breath without oxigen or to sleep for years in sitting position, the drug abuser will tell you all his life in advance how it is going to end, but he will pay the last money for the dose, even if it is his children's bread money,even if it is a question of their life, and somebody still thinks that the reason is the lack of his/her understanding-NO, the reason is much deeper, and it is in the root of our nature, we are creation, which means the wish to enjoy,a wish to feel a pleasure,a wish to feel satisfaction, and there is nothing one can do against this fact, WHAT we ARE able to do is to redirect and find the pleasure and satisfaction in a different field altogether from the matirial one,and it is the spiritual development, which is endless and safe,BUT the price looks to our ego as an impossibly high! The ego should let another oppinion to have place within its realm= the wish to get for the sake of getting,and to get along with the fact that the endless pleasure may be only in the form of getting for the sake of bestowing,which is recieved by studing Torah and performing Mitzvot,no other way to brake a circle of addiction!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
Sign up today!