click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Our Brother's Blood

Our Brother's Blood

A young Jewish man is stabbed in Jerusalem's Old City and dies in my arms.

by Moshe Simons

I sit facing my computer, and words fail me. I have just witnessed one of the most tragic and traumatic events of my life.

A Jewish young man died in my arms tonight. His sin? Being Jewish in Jerusalem.

At about 8:25 this evening, we got a call from the MDA dispatcher about a stabbing on David Street - the Arab shuk leading from Jaffa Gate to the Kotel. I immediately left my apartment and sped over to the chaotic scene not far from there on a Hatzolah ambu-cycle.

Upon arrival, a horrible sight greeted me. A young Jewish man, lying in a pool of his own blood, with a 15" knife sticking out of his stomach. After being at many bombings, car accidents and other traumatic events, this scene had the distinction of being the worst one I have ever seen.

His skin a very pale color, and his eyes half open, I reached him. The only people around were police officers, who didn't really know what to do. The young Jewish man was not breathing, and he had no pulse.

This is the nightmare of any EMT. Alone, as the only person with medical training at the scene, there is not much you can do. Many tasks need to be done, and many people are needed to do them. Starting CPR, connecting oxygen, starting numerous IV's due to massive blood loss and trying to stop the bleeding are some of the things that need to be done, but in the seconds that I was there, my mind stopped working. One cannot think rationally in such situations -- one must act like a robot, doing whatever could be done as quickly as possible. First, I called for backup on my MIRS, and then I started CPR. Even with all of the expensive equipment that we have, there are times that the only thing you can use is a simple pocket mask.

Using a bag valve mask on a trauma patient that you are having trouble opening an airway for is a waste of time. It is close to impossible to use on your own on such a patient. I took out my trusty face mask, and started mouth to mouth resuscitation. I felt his lungs fill up with air, and I was slightly encouraged. One of the police officers started chest compressions (as well as he could), and we continued basic CPR for a minute or two.

At this point, an ambulance with a paramedic -- Aryeh Yaffe -- arrived at the scene, along with Rafi Herbst and another volunteer. We now had four sets of hands instead of one, and could now start to try to save the young Jewish man's life.

We immediately searched for the wounds and tried to stop the bleeding. At the same time we tried to start an IV, but were having difficulty due to the massive amounts of blood that he lost. We continued CPR, this time with a bag valve mask and good compressions, and in the meantime, more volunteers from the Jewish Quarter arrived on foot, and quickly took my place. Shortly thereafter a MDA Mobile ICU arrived and continued to work on the patient - the doctor I saw on their crew was one of the best I have ever seen working under pressure and keeping his cool - as well as giving fantastic care to the patient.

Soon, we had three IV's running, and we were trying to restart the young man's heart using drugs. Atropine, Sodium Bicarbonate were used among other drugs, and soon we had a heart rhythm on the EKG, although we did not have a pulse. We moved the patient to the mobile ICU who transferred him to the trauma center at Haddassah Ein Karem, but the young man was pronounced dead in the operating room -- he had a massive gash in the veins and arteries in his stomach, and we could not save him. When I had arrived at the scene previously -- he was no longer with us, yet we tried everything that we could to bring him back -- to no avail.

What was the young man's crime? What did he do wrong? To us, the residents of the Old City, these answers are clear. The Arabs want us out of Israel -- out of Jerusalem.

The terrorism will continue -- and will get much worse in Jerusalem. One thing I can tell you -- we won't run. We will stand firm, and remain here until one side wins -- us or them. The battle is for the soul of the Land of Israel -- let no one think otherwise.

In the meantime, I'm sure you are asking yourselves: what can be done? The answer, as I see it, is threefold.

Physical help: This includes writing to congressmen, senators, politicians; trying to influence the viewpoint of others around you; visiting Israel; helping us in our struggle.

More importantly, we must realize that our fate is decided in Heaven. When a decree comes from before God, we must take a deeper look at ourselves and try to find what is wrong spiritually. Each of us must make additional effort in the spiritual realm to do more mitzvot and study Torah, and through that may we merit the rescinding of the terrible sword that hangs above our heads.

Let us cry together. Let us understand that a Jew murdered in Jerusalem must have an impact upon the entire Jewish nation -- we must realize the depths that we have reached. We are a splintered, fragmented nation -- each of us finding fault with the other. At the very least, let us join together in sorrow, and cry as one for the blood of a young man, murdered in Jerusalem simply because he was a Jew.

Written in sorrow by
Moshe Simons, EMT
Hatzolah & MDA Volunteer
Hatzolah Newsletter Editor
Jewish Quarter, Jerusalem

If you wish to help in purchasing medical equipment for Hatzolah in the Old City, please email

August 27, 2005

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 25

(25) Severino Enopena, September 27, 2005 12:00 AM

Revulsion: an understatement

It fails me every time trying to understand how human beings can be so narrow in their notion about others who are different from them in faith & in politics; then hatred, violence and murder become their preferred way to resolve their issues which would otherwise been a chance to ascend to a higher level of being with others. Revulsion is an understatement as people of this kind continually feed themselves with twisted religious notions and stoke their minds with unrealistic political ideals.

(24) Avichai Sheli, September 1, 2005 12:00 AM

Dear Moshe

We Jews in Finland, we crying!
May his family be comforted.....
Oh, why! my heart is heavy and I pray, and pray. Day after day...

(23) Anonymous, August 29, 2005 12:00 AM

why OH WHY...

wHY ARE THEY SO ADEPT WITH BOMBS, KNIVES AND ROCKETS.. AND THEIR HELLISH MASKS... THEIR HEARTS FULL of hatred and blood lust... to end a young mans life just as it was starting???

(22) Elisheva, August 29, 2005 12:00 AM

May Hashem Avenge this Young Man's Blood

Dear Moshe,
What can one say when a young life is snuffed out so senselessly. It's the worst tragedy ever. Yet we Jews have seen this scene played out in the last 5 years over and over again. I along with so many others have cried buckets of tears for all the Jewish (& gentile) lives lost in Eretz HaKadosh. Yes we need to cry out to Avinu Habashamayim and ask for mercy, and justice for our people. We need to love each fellow Jew as our own family member. We need to encourage one another not to give up. Moshiach is coming soon and in our day! The Arabs may think they are winning but their victory is shallow and shortlived. You will see, Hashem exacts His judgement on those who hate His people.May Hashem avenge the blood of this young beautiful young man whose life was snuffed out way to soon. May his family be comforted with all the mourners of Israel. Am Yisrael Chai!

(21) betty mccain, August 28, 2005 12:00 AM



See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment