Memories of Holocaust refugees, but with a different ending.

by Menucha Chana Levin

Since 1948, Israel has provided a home for millions of Jewish refugees from around the world – Morocco, Iraq, the former Soviet Union, Ethiopia.

What is not so well-known, however, is that Israel has also taken in and sheltered persecuted non-Jews seeking asylum from war-torn countries in the Balkans and most recently, Southern Sudan. A fascinating but little-known story is that of the “Vietnamese Boat People.”

In the late 1970s, after decades of civil war, the North Vietnamese totalitarian communists defeated the South Vietnam regime. In the aftermath of this Vietnam War and the fall of Saigon, hundreds of thousands became refugees. An estimated one million people were imprisoned without formal charges or trials. The new communist government sent masses to “re-education camps” which – rife with abuse, torture and executions – is where 165,000 people died.

Meanwhile, 145,000 South Vietnamese were brought to the United States. For the rest – hoping to escape Communist persecution and torture – there was no choice but to perilously attempt escape by sea.

The sea raged with ferocious waves and Thai pirates.

The risks were huge. The refugees had creaky, wooden boats, overloaded with human cargo. There was the constant surveillance of Communist patrol boats. The sea raged with ferocious waves and crawled with savage Thai pirates.

Despite the risks, hundreds of thousands fled. Many had no experience on the rough seas and were blown off course. Many suffered at the hands of pirates who robbed, raped and killed the passengers. Others tragically drowned in storms, by dehydration and disease, or other ocean mishaps.

One refugee, Kiem Vu, described his experience:

The people know there is no going back. Either they will make it, or die somewhere in the immense and unforgiving sea... There is no sight of land, nothing except the rumbling sky, the quivering winds, and the trembling heartbeats; the people are crying for help. Soon, they run out of food, raw fish have become their main source of nourishment, but even that is rare... Even their clothes are wet, and they have had to sleep through the coldest nights. Their spirits and strength are greatly diminished. Why is freedom so hard to find? If not in the vast ocean, then where is it?

For one fragile fishing boat crammed with 66 refugees, a miracle was about to occur. Adrift in the South China Sea for nearly a week, they were lost. Their little boat was leaking and waterlogged. They were without food and water, and their clothes had been shredded by the high winds. Ship after ship – from East Germany, Norway, Japan and Panama – passed them by, ignoring their desperate SOS signals, in violation of the most basic code of the sea.

Miracle Rescue

Then on June 10, 1977, an Israeli freighter ship called the Yuvali, en route to Taiwan, sighted the nearly naked passengers. Captain Meir Tadmor telegraphed Haifa for permission to take them aboard, even though his ship carried only enough life rafts and jackets for his 30-member crew. Still, he had no choice but to pick up the refugees, he said, because "they are poor in body and morale."

Captain Tadmor plucked the refugees from their rickety boat 400 kilometers south of Saigon. The refugees – doctors, professors, bankers, nurses, fishermen, and 16 children under age ten – hadn't had anything to eat or drink for days.

Yet the Yuvali found no port willing to accept its surplus “cargo.” Captain Tadmor made an unscheduled stop in Hong Kong to get the refugees desperately-needed medical attention; authorities in the British crown colony refused to allow them ashore on the grounds that the Yuvali was not scheduled to call at Hong Kong. Equally inhospitable were authorities in Taiwan: they put a police cordon around the ship to prevent anyone from getting off. The refugees received a similarly cold reception at Yokohama, Japan.

The rebuff awakened some poignant memories in Israel. Ships carrying Jewish refugees from the Nazi Holocaust sought in vain to enter ports in the Mediterranean, the Black Sea and the Caribbean. They wandered the seven seas looking for a haven and were summarily turned away. Some, like the SS Struma, were abandoned without food, water and fuel – then torpedoed and sunk by a Soviet submarine, killing 768 men, women and children.

And so, Menachem Begin’s first act as Israel's new prime minister was to offer asylum and resettlement to the 66 Vietnamese. Only then did Taiwan allow the group to disembark, where they were whisked to Sung Shan Airport for a flight to Israel.

As Begin explained to then-U.S. President Carter:

"We never have forgotten the boat with 900 Jews [the St. Louis], having left Germany in the last weeks before the Second World War... traveling from harbor to harbor, from country to country, crying out for refuge. They were refused... Therefore it was natural… to give those people a haven in the land of Israel."

The government of Israel offered a ceremonious welcome, with Minister of Absorption David Levy uttering some words of rebuke to the rest of the world: "Let them do as we have. May they lend a hand to save women and children who are in the heart of the sea without a homeland, and lead them to safe shores."

Where are they today?

Those rescued on the Yuvali became the first of three groups of Vietnamese refugees to be resettled in Israel. From 1977-79, Israel welcomed over 300 Vietnamese refugees.

Many of the Vietnamese refugees eventually left Israel, seeking life in more familiar surroundings. They left not out of disappointment and frustration, but as grateful emigrants.

Others have remained, forming the core today of a thriving Vietnamese community in Israel. Kien Wong lives in Haifa, has a growing multi-generational family, and owns Yan Yan, a popular Chinese restaurant. (see film clip below)

Kien Wong owns a popular Chinese restaurant in Haifa.

Another of the refugees, Hanmoi Nguyen, who has raised five Hebrew-speaking daughters in Israel, is featured in the documentary film, The Journey of Vaan Nguyen. Nguyen had been the son of a wealthy landowner in Vietnam and returned to his native village to reclaim his ancestral property and settle scores with the Communist functionary who kicked him out at gunpoint. In an eerie parallel to the Holocaust survivors who returned to their homelands to reclaim their old homes, Nguyen is met with suspicion and hostility at his old village.

This summer marks the 25th anniversary of this unique rescue story. The Talmud says that saving one life is like saving a whole world. In this case, in those stormy seas south of Saigon, 66 precious souls were given a new lease on life.

Published: November 19, 2011
Hear related audio on this topic.

Like this article? Help us create more. Aish.com exists
only through the support of our readers.

Visitor Comments: 15

(12) Shoshana, November 29, 2011 9:01 PM

southern Sudan

The story about the 300 Vietnamese that were taken into Israel is truely beautiful and I had never heard it before. I am really proud that Israel did this wonderful act. BUT when you mention the Sudans it is a different story altogether. FOUR THOUSAND of these Moslems are infiltrating every month. If this keeps up Israel will soon be one-third Moslem. These people are for the most part a low-class criminal element, deseased, uneducated , roudy and dangerous. In the areas that they live Jews are afraid to walk down the streets. Just because of the Holocaust memories we should not be required to destroy our lives here in Israel. Also for those who think they are "refugees" , they are not. The official international definition of a refugee is one who flees from his country to a second one. If he flees to a third he is not considered a refugee( these Africans are infiltrating from Egypt). But whatever you want to call them, the situation is unbearable already. But that is not all. The country is filled with Ethiopian Christians who are doing missionary work amoung the Jewish Ethiopians. There was a whole article about heartbroken Ethiopian parents who said that for 2000 years they stayed Jewish in Ethiopia to come here for this. And what about the increaslng incidents of swastickers painted on our synogoges right here in Israel and how many have been burned? It's almost always Russians and not the Russian Jew, but the same anti-Semites who are coming over here for a free handout. The situation has gotton so bad that there are people who do not think that Israel should even be called a Jewish state anymore.

(11) Anonymous, November 27, 2011 4:45 AM

Conflict

The general tone of this story is beautiful but I do find it very hard to reconcile our history and the moden reality. Australia alone took 100000 vietnamese refugees. Surely with our history we could do more than accomodate the numbers we did. Although the story is nice, the reality is that we should be ' a light unto the nations' and demonstrate that by doing more. I dont mean this in a criticism. I personally find it hard to reconcile our history with the fact that we took in 70 vietnamese refugees out of an estimated umber of 1.5million

Kosher Food Chemist, December 1, 2011 1:19 PM

Re: Conflict

If you will sadly look back to 1922 you will see how Ben Gurion turned ships back filled with what he described as 'religious Jews.' He didn't want "those" types in "his" country. Try looking at the positive side of Project Solomon & Moses where over 100,000 Ethiopians those that have a tie with Israel & Judaism have stayed & benefited themselves & Israel. The U.S. invited itself into the VietNam conflict so they should have taken in a lot more people. How much would you like the small State of Israel to do considering its limited economics and mongrels at its heels day & night? How many desperate Jewish people do you have sitting at your Friday nite & Saturday Shabbat table? There are so many Jewish people out there that don't eat all week and look desperately for someone to invite them for Shabbat so they can get their weekly sustenance. Israel has been the first country to offer assistance without prejudice even to those countries that despise her. Remember it was the Jewish people that taught the world "to turn the other cheek" and we are a light unto the nations I noticed you did not mention the UK, Greece, France, Italy, Spain or any other EU country; why is that? Shabbat Shalom & Shalom Al Yisrael

Shoshana, December 1, 2011 4:37 PM

Australia

Australia is a little bigger than Israel, and a little bit richer, my dear Anonymous, Nov.27 at 4:45 AM (Wow! I guess the conflict really didn't give you much sleep).

(10) Linda Rivera, November 21, 2011 10:38 PM

Israel, Light to the World, Thank you!

So good to read of Israel's kind act to a desperate people! If only this kindness had been shown by the nations to Jews trying to escape the Holocaust.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub

About the Author

Menucha Chana Levin

Menucha Chana Levin is the author of two novels "The Youngest Bride" and "The Castle Builders" published by Israel Bookshop Publications. She has lived in Jerusalem with her family for twenty years.

Related Articles:

Sponsors

    Upcoming Holiday

    • Shavuot: May 27 - 28, 2012
    What would a world without Torah look like?
    Why did God wait 49 days before giving the Torah?
    A fascinating, big picture overview of the holiday of Shavuot and the Ten Commandments.