click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Join 400,000 Aish subscribers
Get Email Updates




Time to Proclaim: I Am A Jew

Time to Proclaim: I Am A Jew

With the crisis in Israel, a non-Jewish columnist for the Montreal Gazette stands united with the Jewish people.

by Catherine Ford

He was slaughtered far away from Jerusalem or Ramallah. But Daniel Pearl's death and mutilation in Pakistan, because he was an American, but most importantly because he was a Jew, has done what no other act of barbarism accomplished.

The Wall Street Journal writer's death turned my heart to stone. Even last week's peace overtures from Saudi Arabia are no longer enough. Not after yet another Jew has been humiliated, slaughtered and his remains debased.

There is an apocryphal World War Two story about the German occupation of Denmark: when the Nazis ordered all Jews to wear a yellow star, so did King Christian X. And he encouraged all of his subjects to do the same. That Queen Margrethe II says it didn't happen doesn't in any way debase the symbolism. The myth continues because bravery and defiance in the face of hatred are always inspiring.

Today, those who hate Jews are able to do so because too many gentiles will not stand up and be counted as the Danish myth proposes. Too many non-Jews tacitly accept racism and discrimination.

No more. Today, I proudly echo Pearl's last words: I am a Jew. I join my husband, his family, our friends and my colleagues who are Jews.

I no longer accept the lies that hatred toward Jews is something individual and isolated.

I am a Jew because I can no longer accept the excuses made for anti-Semitism. I no longer accept the lies that hatred on the part of Arab countries and hatred shown toward the Jews in the West is something individual and isolated. It is not. Our silence for long years has encouraged Holocaust deniers, revisionists, baiters and haters to spread their poison.

I used to think there was a middle ground, especially when the question of Israel arose, that both "sides" were equally at fault. No more.

I can't agree with the actions of Ariel Sharon's government, with its eye-for-an-eye, death-for-death retaliation against the Palestinians, but my disgust for anti-Semites and Israel-deniers who populate Israel's Arab neighbors is worse.

For as far back as I can remember, the "solution" to the crises in the Middle East has been to reach an accommodation with the Palestinians and Arab countries. Yet the proposal by Saudi Arabia that Israel return Gaza and the West Bank in exchange for peace is not enough, even in the unlikely event the Sharon government would agree.

The West has a role and a responsibility in this conflict to affirm, publicly, our support for Israel and to demand others do the same. Only then will negotiations have any chance of success. I don't mean meal-mouthed political niceties, I mean insisting Israel's neighbors such as Lebanon, Jordan, Syria and Iraq, and all the Arab countries, accept Israel or accept the consequences.

There are few countries in the Middle East that share our civilized values and democratic principles as closely as Israel does. It is time to stand up and be counted in more than words.

We have the power and the moral responsibility to do so, and it doesn't need to be with bombs, even if we want to expand the so-called "axis of evil." We have a far greater hammer. We have the economic clout to impose sanctions. All we need is the will.

Israel's neighbors must accept responsibility for allowing terrorists, anarchists, dictators and religious fanatics to flourish within their borders.

The time for playing nice with killers is over. The time for "understanding" the plight of the Palestinians is past. It's now time to affirm on the world stage the inherent right of Israel to exist in peace. Israel's neighbors must accept their responsibility in fomenting hatred and open their borders to the displaced Palestinians. For almost 50 years, these countries have done nothing to alleviate the suffering of their kith and kin.

They have allowed terrorists, anarchists, dictators and religious fanatics to flourish within their borders.

It's not necessary to bomb Iraq or other countries into submission. Sanctions are more devastating. No truck; no trade. No immigration. No visas. No money or goods.

Bombing promotes self-pity and lets the evil-doers blame the United States for their sorry plight. Bombs are easy. They require no sacrifice on the part of the West other than money to pay for material.

How much more devastating to shun them. If we are committed to Israel, we have to show we mean it, and if that means less oil for SUVs because we refuse to trade honor for comfort, too bad.

It is time for all of us to stand up and say: I am a Jew.

Copyright Montreal Gazette 2002. All rights reserved.

Published: March 16, 2002


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 7

(7) Anonymous, March 19, 2002 12:00 AM

it's not "eye for eye"

a powerful essay. i take issue, however, with one comment of the author. The fact that she doesn't agree with Israel's "eye for eye, death for death" policy shows that she doesn't understand what it is like to be living under threat of constant and terrifying terror attacks. Israel doesn't strive for "eye for eye." You just don't see innocent Palestian civilians being killed. Rather, Israel defends itself by going after armed and dangerous terrorists, never women, children and innocent bystanders. Please don't equate the two sides.

(6) Michael Samuels, March 19, 2002 12:00 AM

I AM A JEW. No one will ever wipe us out. They have tried:the inquisttion,the holocost,forced conversions,now terrorists. They will keep trying,but they will not succeed.
WE ARE JEWS!!!! WE WILL SURVIVE

(5) Maryjane Williams, March 18, 2002 12:00 AM

If it means my death; I will stand besides the Jewish People

No, I am not a Jew... My heart and soul are with the Jews, they are Gods people and mine....I would die to protect them..

(4) Raffaele Ladu, March 18, 2002 12:00 AM

Well said

I am applying for conversion (as a Liberal Jew), and one of the reasons I want to join the Jewish People is to defend it against antisemitism.

(3) Chava Felsher-Buse, March 18, 2002 12:00 AM

Wonderful article

Those who bless Israel shall be blessed. All who curse Israel will be cursed. Powerful words our enemies must remember!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!