click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Betrayed by the State Dept.

Betrayed by the State Dept.

The U.S. State Dept. is doing almost the least it can in capturing Palestinian terrorists who have killed Americans in Israel.


I have disconsoling news for the families of the five American victims of Wednesday's terrorist bombing at Hebrew University: The U.S. State Department is not on your side.

I know this from bitter, bitter experience. Palestinian terrorists killed my son Koby, a U.S. citizen, on May 8, 2001. He was 13.

Koby was out hiking with his friend Yosef. The terrorists took rocks and bashed in my son's skull, then smeared the boys' blood all over the walls of a cave where the bodies were later found.

The State Department is now offering information about a reward for Koby's killers. But State seems to prefer that no one find out about it.

In 1994, State began Rewards for Justice, a system to help catch terrorist who kill Americans abroad. It promises up to $5 million -- up to $25 million for information related to 9/11.

But State, eager to tread the illusory path of Middle East peace, doesn't want to catch all terrorists. Since the 1993 signing of the Oslo Accords, Palestinian terrorists have killed 36 Americans. But until last year, the Rewards for Justice program totally omitted Americans killed in Israel.

Even now, State does almost the least it can. The program's Web site, for example, has only one page translated into Arabic. That page focuses on the al Queda killers, not Palestinians.

The department assures me that it is working on the translation. But the site has been up for six months already. Surely it can't be that hard to do a translation.

And the Internet is the only way a Palestinian can found out about these rewards.

In Bosnia, NATO helicopters have dropped leaflets -- translated into the local language -- in search of war criminals. America has air-dropped leaflets in Afghanistan, and publicized rewards on matchbooks in Pakistan.

After the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, the United States sent multilanguage leaflets worldwide, offering to pay for information. (They used matchbooks then, too.)

The Rewards for Justice site notes that ads publicizing the program "in English, Arabic, Spanish, French, German and Russian have appeared in publications as far ranging as The New York Times, Al Hayat, Paris Match, Die Welt, and Pravda."

Yet not one ad has appeared in a newspaper in the Palestinian territories.

No, a Palestinian can only find out about the program by going to the State Department Web site, clicking on "campaigns", then "kidnappings and murders" and then "Opposition to the Middle East Peace Process."

That's where Koby's name is listed.

Buried, rather. Even being fluent in English, I had a hard time finding the page.

In other words, to learn about the reward, you'd already have to know that the reward exists.

According to their heading, Koby was killed by "a person opposed to the Middle East Peace Process."

To say nothing of the neutered language that the site uses, rather than call these killers "terrorists." According to their heading, Koby was killed by "a person opposed to the Middle East Peace Process."

Makes them sound like rational political activists, not killers schooled in hatred so virulent that many terrorists lace their suicide bombs with rat poison so that their victims bleed more.

I call the State Department and ask: "Are you publicizing the reward? Will anybody see that there is a $5 million reward for information on Koby's murderer?"

"Yes," the State Department official tells me, "they can look on the Internet."

"How many Palestinian homes have Internet?"

"A lot, " he says. "They have high Internet penetration rates."

"How high?" I ask.

"I'll get back to you." Three weeks later, they still can't figure it out. "There are Internet cafes," he responds. Finally, he e-mails me that about 5 percent of Palestinian families have Internet access. Even that number, I believe, is inflated.

In Israel, the West Bank and Gaza, there are no Rewards for Justice ads on billboards, matchbooks or newspapers, as is done in other countries. No, instead the State Department's notice is buried as deeply as the body of my son.

My son was a true American. He loved Michael Jordan, Cal Ripen, the Atlantic Ocean, Delray beach, french fries, hamburgers and the Fourth of July. He deserves better. So do all the American victims of terrorism in Israel.

The Koby Mandell Act, a bill now before Congress, would set up an office in the Justice Department to seek justice for American families who have suffered the loss of a loved one at the hands of Palestinian terrorists.

It is time to make sure that the war against terrorism is fought for all U.S. citizens, including those Americans killed in Israel. It is time to pass the Koby Mandell Act and ensure that the search for justice is a mission, not a gesture.

August 17, 2002

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 6

(6) Larry Melsky, August 24, 2002 12:00 AM

State Dept's always been Anti-Semitic

Dear Mrs. & Mrs. Mandell :
As a Jew, I grieve with you for the loss of your son.Unfortunately,many of the employees working for the State Dept are apt to give nothing more than lip service, especially when it comes to the "Jewish Problem", as they see Israel and it's citizens.It's doesn't whether you're an Israeli
or American Jew. You're just another Jew, part of the everlasting "Jewish Problem" to the mainstay WASP majority established and still deeply embedded in the always apologetic, Anti-Jew do nothing State Dept.

If in need of help when in a foreign country, especially if you are Jewish (State Dept. apathy now applies to gentiles as well), don't count on anything more than lies and innuendos from those who are supposed to help American citizens.

The State Dept only seems to care about keeping relations with our
arab Allies( pardon me while I laugh ) on an even keel, no matter what they do to American citizens.

I wish you Mazal Tov in your quest for justice with the help of the Stee Dept, but I wouldn't count on it.In my opinion they are the enemies of the American public.

During WW11 the State Dept run by Sec. of State Breckedridge threw every obstacle and monkey wrench into rescuing the European Jews from the genocidal deaths that awaited them.

(5) Deborah, August 24, 2002 12:00 AM

Heartbroken also!

As a mother who has also lost a son, I cry for you and your family. I applaud you for all of your efforts in attempting to get justice for your son, I myself have been at it for three years only to be stone walled by the government... if it will help I will be glad to send emails daily to the state dept. May G-d bring you comfort.

(4) Michael Y, August 20, 2002 12:00 AM

america is not.....

America is not your true friend,your jewish family is.You cant expect an "oilcaholic" nation thirsty for arab oil and morally/spiritually bankrupt to put Jewish lives first.
Oil and Greenbacks(in g-d we trust)is who America bows to,not G-D ,nor does it have much respect for Jewish lives,
as the French foreign minister put it
"that shitty little country Israel".
Simply put; America is a young,immature and irresponsible republic,that will probably fall within 100 years if it remains on its downward spiral.
Sorry for any offence.However let the truth be told.Thank You for your time

(3) betti miner, August 20, 2002 12:00 AM


I feel that Sherri knows first-hand what it is like to lose a son to terrorists. Your story was very touching and I hope that Koby's death will not be in vain and that the Koby Mandell Act will pass and that the State Department will get off their hands and do something about terrorist attacks on American-Israelis and Americans like me. When this country gets rid of that squatter Bush who is living in the White House, then we can have justice for our Jewish people. Thank you.

(2) Rebecca Empey, August 19, 2002 12:00 AM


I cannot express my outrage at the evil of my government's State Department. I am so sorry for what happened to your son, and am sorry for my government's evil negligence and actions. There are many Americans who are speaking out about this-- there is hope yet! But please be comforted that "the Lord executes righteousness and justice for all who are oppressed." May the men who did this thing to Koby and Yosef (and all the many other people) be brought to justice-- if not by governments now, then by the Lord in the near future-- whose scepter is a scepter of righteousness. Men in governments who do not act justly when they have the power are just as evil as the murderers who slay little children.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment