click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

The Fog of War

The Fog of War

Root causes and resolution to the war in Gaza.


The notion that truth is the first casualty of war finds expression in the fog of the current Gaza conflict -- a truth masked by oft-repeated cliches such as "cycle of violence" or unconscionable allegations of "genocide." If we want to prevent further tragedies in this conflict -- let alone frame the basis for its resolution -- then we have to go behind the daily headlines that cloud understanding and probe the real basis of the Israeli-Hamas conflict.

The proximate trigger for the present hostilities was the deliberate and consistent attack on Israeli citizens by Hamas. Over 6,000 rockets and mortar shells have been launched at Israel since its Gaza withdrawal in the summer of 2005, including hundreds while the supposed truce between Hamas and Israel was in effect.

When Hamas then unilaterally declared the truce over and tripled its rocket-fire, Israel was obliged to act in self-defense.

Yet even this proximate trigger does not tell the whole story. It is rather a symptom, or proxy, for the root cause: the unwillingness of Hamas -- and its Iranian patron -- to accept the legitimacy of Israel within any boundaries in the Middle East.

The root cause: the public call by Hamas for the destruction of Israel and the killing of Jews wherever they may be.

While the rejection by Hamas of any peace with any Israel -- or the existence of Israel itself -- is a foundational root cause, there is a much more pernicious and sinister one that is all but ignored in the fog of war. This is the public call by Hamas, in its charter as well as its contemporary declarations, for the destruction of Israel and the killing of Jews wherever they may be.

Jews everywhere -- not just in Israel -- are referred to as inherently evil, as responsible for all the evils of the world, as defilers of Islam, and, repeatedly during these hostilities, as the "sons of apes and pigs." This genocidal anti-Semitism -- and I do not use these words lightly or easily, but there are no other words to describe what is affirmed in these genocidal calls, covenants and declarations - this culture of hatred, this is where it all begins.

In the words of Prof. Fouad Ajami following the 2002 terrorist massacre of Israeli civilians in Netanya sitting down for their Passover meal: The suicide bomber of the Passover massacre did not descend from the sky; he walked straight out of the culture of incitement let loose on the land, a menace hovering over Israel, a great Palestinian and Arab refusal to let that country be, to cede it a place among the nations.

The bomber partook of the culture all around him: the glee that greets those brutal deeds of terror, the cult that rises around the martyrs and their families.

Morevoer, Iran not only joins in these genocidal calls, but has become the epicenter of calls for Israel to be "wiped off the map." In Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's Iran, one finds the toxic convergence of the advocacy of the most horrific of crimes embedded in the most virulent of hatreds and propelled by the avowed intent of Iran to acquire nuclear weapons for that purpose. Iran is not just a bystander to the conflict, but an actor and choreographer involved in the training, supplying, financing, harboring and promoting of Hamas.

The Iran "connection" to the present hostilities is too often ignored or sanitized. As a senior commander of Hamas has said, "Iran is our mother. She gives us information, military supplies and financial support." It is all the more tragic that innocent civilians are dying in Gaza because of hostilities supported by Iran, whose criminal accountability is marginalized.

As well, Hamas not only threatens the safety and security of Israeli citizens. It shields itself behind its own Palestinian citizens, thereby threatening the safety and security of Gaza itself.

Recognizing the root causes is important, not only to appreciate the basis of the conflict, but the basis and framework for its resolution. That resolution, in the end, will not be military but diplomatic, political and juridical - and organized around the following initiatives and undertakings:

1. A comprehensive -- and enduring -- cease-fire and framework to end hostilities must be put in place. For such a cease-fire to endure, the casus belli that gave rise to the hostilities must be addressed and redressed: Hamas must cease and desist from its policy of targeting Israeli civilians and terrorizing Israeli civilian populations.

2. A robust international protection force - with the necessary mandate, mission and numbers - should be employed to ensure that the cease-fire is respected, both to protect against the targeting of Israeli civilians and the use of Palestinian civilians as human shields: the ongoing double war crimes of Hamas.

3. The international protection force must be empowered to secure a total interdiction of the smuggling and manufacture of weapons on Gaza, lest the capacity for the casus belli be renewed. For example, Hamas must not be permitted to resuscitate its tunnel system of weapons smuggling and the exploitation of the Philadelphi corridor for this purpose.

4. Another Hamas instigation underlying this conflict - remembered daily by Israelis - is the case of kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Schalit. For two-and-a-half years he has been held incommunicado and denied his rights as a detainee; Hamas has even denied access to the International Committee of the Red Cross. Such manifest disregard for his basic rights must end. Indeed, 100 Hamas terrorists captured in these hostilities can be returned in exchange - there is admittedly a severe disproportionality between the freeing of an illegally abducted soldier and hundreds of terrorists, but it is one that Israel may be ready to accept.

5. The deployment of an international protection force should allow for the opening of humanitarian corridors and border crossings, and the withdrawal of Israel forces from Gaza, following the lines of the 2005 Agreement on Movement and Access concluded with the Palestinian Authority.

6. Humanitarian assistance must be immediately deployed to those in need, and Israel and Hamas must allow this assistance to be delivered. There can be no mistaking the fact that Hamas's tactics of launching rockets from civilian areas and using border crossings to smuggle weapons directly hinders humanitarian efforts.

7. With order restored, an international trusteeship under the auspices of the United Nations should be given governing authority over Gaza. Ruling Gaza is a job that Hamas cannot be trusted with, that Egypt has rejected, that Israel does not want, and that the Palestinian Authority has not been given the authority to do by the Palestinians.

Palestinian society in Gaza must be freed from the cynical and oppressive culture of hate and incitement.

While a UN governing authority would understandably be treated with mistrust in Israel, it would be a stabilizing presence that is simply the best of all available options. It can serve as an institution-building, state-building authority that can be the basis for the emergence of a peaceful, rights-protecting Gaza as a constituent part of a nascent, peaceful and democratic Palestinian state.

8. Palestinian society in Gaza must be freed from the cynical and oppressive culture of hate and incitement. It is true that one makes peace with one's enemies and not one's friends, but it is equally true that no peaceful solution - to this particular conflict in Gaza, or to the larger geopolitical conflict in the region - will be possible if resources continue to be poured into textbooks, summer camps, refugee camps and pervasive state media that serve the sole purpose of demonizing Israel.

The next generation of Palestinians must be one capable of keeping the peace with Israel. It is in the interests of neither Israelis nor Palestinians themselves to perpetuate this false "clash of civilizations." Admittedly the implementation of these objectives may be difficult - some may say even impossible - to secure. But the time has come to realize that if we want to protect the lives of both Israelis and Palestinians in the long as well as the short run, such initiatives and undertakings are unavoidable.

The death of any innocent -- Israeli or Palestinian -- is a tragedy. It is urgent to act now for a just resolution, and for the prevention of further tragedies.

This article originally appeared in the Jerusalem Post.

January 17, 2009

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 9

(9) Dvirah, January 28, 2009 3:04 PM

Treat the 3-yr-olds like 3 yr olds

I agree particularly with point 7, even though the UN is not a fair mediator. But the Palestinian's behavior, if analysed phsycologically, is that of a 3-year-old - and a 3-year-old does not govern him/herself. So let's treat these destructive children accordingly.

(8) Janna, January 21, 2009 11:49 PM

What a nice wake up!

First of all, Hamas cannot exist in a peaceful environment, so it needs to feed off a constant state of conflict and war in order to keep the people in line. They care nothing for these, their own people, except for how they can be used to achieve their own murderous objectives. Hamas cares only about Hamas - they write their own rules as they go. They teach hatred to their children to keep a robust inventory of future suicide bomber terrorists. You can't have peace with such "people" for longer than it takes them to regroup and rearm. Secondly, why this great faith in the U.N.? They are the world's largest source of sanctioned anti-Semitism and they cannot be trusted with oversight of Gaza! How is it that Hamas was shooting missiles from a U.N. sponsored school? Why the silence from the U.N. after that was reported? Surely they'd be outraged that any U.N. facility would be anything less than neutral ground? And third, "humanitarian aid" is something we Westerners believe in, not terrorists like Hamas. Any such "aid" arriving in Gaza would immediately be redirected to Hamas "officials," for those with proper political connections. The average Gazan would never see the food and clothing because to give them aid would be to relieve them of their distress, and that wouldn't be good for Hamas - they must be kept downtrodden, ragged and hungry. And anyone foolish enough to send money - well, you know what that would be used for. Gotta keep those missiles coming, gotta pay for that new apartment for that suicide bomber's family. Israel must be allowed, must allow itself, to finish this job and wipe out Haman - oops, I mean Hamas. (Same idea.) Israel needs to stop worrying what other nations think - because nothing it does, or does not do, will be good enough to win their approval, anyway - and act decisively to protect itself. Am Yisrael Chai!

(7) Anonymous, January 19, 2009 1:16 PM

With all due respect...

I hold Mr. Cotler in high esteem, but his proposal is flawed from the outset. Number 1 in his program is to get Hamas to "cease and desist" backed up by number 2 an"international protection force". This didn't work in Lebanon and there's no reason that it will work in Gaza. Only all-out war with the destruction of Iran's islamic regime, along with its proxies Hezbollah and Hamas, as its goal and result will bring quiet. Every day that the inevitable is delayed strengthens the enemy resulting in many more casualties than necessary.

(6) zamaaz, January 19, 2009 12:54 AM

Misery is their bedmate...

The Gaza hostilities proved further that war in Gaza in not only on the question of Israel occupation of Palestine, nor retaking the whole of Canaan…The Palestinians leadership in Gaza represents a kind of culture after generations of life in misery and conflict, their hands cling to weapons rather than plows…They desire the goodness in the hands of foreigners, rather than themselves. They find difficulty living away from ‘blades of swords’…and have willed to spill the blood of all their people to sow all over the world hatred against Israel…sacrifices, involuntary, humans – an abomination before The Almighty…a prophetic prelude…What have we done? Israel has unilaterally declared cessation of violence. Thanks to The Almighty for such wisdom. An act of goodwill to the entire world, and good faith in the side of Israel. My prayer was granted also. But will Palestinians response equally? No, they will continuously provoke to make the gesture of peace a lie…Unfortunately, the war goes on…and even more devastatingly…and the blood shall be on the heads of the Palestinians. Their vexation against Israel keep them blinded. Their animosity and madness built them walls. They are not capable of seeing wisdom…misery is their bedmate… it is their lot! (These notes were being written while observing an Aljazeera documentary about Palestinians)

(5) Anonymous, January 18, 2009 7:55 PM

Where does Arab Charity Go?

If Arab charity went anywhere usefully, Gaza would be an industrialized community with exports and the trappings of a successful and enlightened culture,with women demanding and acquiring equal rights and oportunities, as in Israel. The latter will be eventually outnumbered by the Arab population. Many of the Arabs there are successful workers and businessmen. Hopefully they might enlighten the rest of their prople and allow the survival of an area that constitues only a minute sliver in the midst of an Arab-dominated sub-continent.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment