click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s Capital: A Historic Watershed

Recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s Capital: A Historic Watershed

It is the Jews alone for whom Jerusalem is at the core of their religious faith.


It’s a seismic event, a great decision and a historic watershed. This is where blackmail and intimidation are faced down. This is where appeasement ends.

President Trump’s speech recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital has signaled that, for America, the century-long Arab attempt to destroy Israel’s legitimacy – the essence of the Middle East conflict – has failed.

Trump was careful and subtle. He did not say all of Jerusalem was Israel’s capital. The US will support a two-state solution if Israel and the Arabs agree to it.

The boundaries of Israeli sovereignty in Jerusalem or the borders of Israel itself will be left to the parties to resolve. And he merely started the process of moving the US Embassy to Jerusalem.

It was the balanced, strategic and principled speech of a statesman.

This is not to downplay the risks involved. The incendiary threats of vengeful violence should be taken seriously. But the Arabs need no excuse to try to murder Israelis.

The purse-lipped refusal by Western countries to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital didn’t prevent the Palestinians from hurling rocks from the Aksa Mosque at Jews worshiping below and stabbing them in the street, all in the name of the Jerusalem status quo.

Appeasing those who threaten violence doesn’t reduce it. It encourages it.

Appeasing those who threaten violence doesn’t reduce it. It encourages it. The more concessions are offered, the more the Palestinians believe even greater violence will deliver them final victory. That’s why the Oslo-process offer of a Palestine state led to the Second Intifada; that’s why the expulsion of Israeli residents from Gaza led to the all-out rocket onslaught against civilians in southern Israel.

The cause of Arab and Islamist terrorism is religious fanaticism and incitement and not the actions of its victims.

The purpose of political violence is to make people buckle through fear. The reason violence against Israel never stops is that its Arab perpetrators know the West will respond by urging concessions upon their Israeli victim and punishing it when it refuses to stretch out its throat to the knife.

Britain, France and Germany have obligingly once again genuflected to the men of violence by disapproving of Trump’s speech. If they had said they too would now recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, the threat of violence would lose much of its point.

At the most prosaic level, it is bizarre not to acknowledge that Jerusalem is Israel’s capital. It is where its seat of government is situated, the official residences of its president and prime minister, its Supreme Court and numerous ministries.

But of course, recognition reflects a far deeper and broader reality – which is why it’s much more important than moving the embassy. For it makes explicit what by moving the embassy would only be implicit.

This is because the Arab war against Israel is not a conflict about the division of land. It is a war of extermination based on a refusal to accept that the Jews have any right to that land. And Jerusalem is central to that refusal.

There was nothing in Trump’s speech to preclude the Palestinians from having control over part of Jerusalem in any eventual settlement. Yet they are trying to incite the Muslim world to violence over his recognition that other parts of Jerusalem constitute Israel’s capital.

The Jews are the only people for whom Jerusalem has ever been the capital of their national homeland.

That’s because they deny the Jews any rights to Jerusalem at all. And that’s because they need to suppress what they can never admit: that Jerusalem was the capital of the Jews’ ancient kingdom which preceded Islam and the Arab and Muslim conquest by many centuries.

It is the Jews alone for whom Jerusalem is at the core of their religious faith. Trump was in error when he said Jerusalem was at the heart of three great religions.

Jerusalem is not mentioned in the Koran; Muslims pray toward Mecca, their holiest city. But for Jews, Jerusalem is the holy of holies. It is mentioned in the Bible more than 660 times, it is integral to the liturgy and forms the direction of all Jewish prayer and historic longing.

The Jews are the only people for whom it has ever been the capital of their national homeland.

Far from the Israeli presence there being illegal, the Jews are the only people who are entitled to the city as a matter of international law, historical truth and natural justice.

Which is why the refusal by Western countries to recognize the unique Jewish right to Jerusalem has been so malevolent. It’s not just that this made Israel into a second-class country, uniquely prevented from asserting its own capital. Much worse than that, it gave legitimacy to those who wanted to eradicate altogether the Jews’ right to the city and the land.

By their opposition to Trump’s speech the British, French, Germans and the rest have revealed that, like the Palestinians, they don’t think the Jews have the right to any part of Jerusalem at all. They appear to think that Jewish Jerusalem, part of the State of Israel since its creation in 1948, can be bargained away to those who would destroy the Jewish homeland altogether.

Those who say Trump’s move makes peace less likely couldn’t be more wrong. Recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital is the essential step without which peace can never be achieved – unless it is the peace that follows surrender, conquest and extermination.

This op-ed originally appeared in the Jerusalem Post.


December 10, 2017

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 7

(5) Deborah, December 14, 2017 3:16 PM

Jerusalem is Israel's Capital. Period.

Let those who were already violent and murderous continue in their debase behaviour. That will not change history or reality.

(4) Pierre Adida, December 11, 2017 6:29 AM

Trump is creating the buzz to divert the attention from his scandalous collusion with Russia and from his sexual assaults. UK, Germany and France have a huge problem with their Muslim community. No one has a sincere attitude on this matter. As a proud liberal Jew I have the same emotion as the other Jews when we talk of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. I just believe that it was quite risky for Trump to make such a unilateral statement. I firmly believe that Trump’s motivation is NOT Israel, but his own personal interest.

Eli, December 11, 2017 2:30 PM

who cares why he did it

You can only speculate why Trump did this at this particular moment in time. From our perspective as Jews though all that matters is that he did it. In Proverbs it states, "A king's heart is like rivulets of water in the Lord's hand; wherever He wishes, He turns it." Clearly this action came from Hashem so we should hold firm to the belief it is for the best. Think of Trump's statement as a precursor to when Hashem will announce to the world that Jerusalem is the capital of Israel. The steps leading up to that great event are audible to anyone who listens for them.

MESA, December 11, 2017 3:21 PM

I don't care about his motives. Past presidents have promised to do this and then reneged even when they could've used it as a distraction tactic. The simple fact is that Trump made this declaration. And it was the right thing to do.

(3) FredUSMCIDF, 12/10/2017, December 10, 2017 8:33 PM

President Trump recognizes Fact over Fiction

President Trump,s recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's Capital City is a statement of the obvious, and validates a 3000 year old declaration by the Highest of Authorities (Greater then the UN, the Vatican, the ICRC etc. The time is long past due for the world to accept the facts that there is no such people as the Palestinian People, and that they are a made up nationality created in 1964 by the Arab League, and the now defunct Soviet Block. Stop buying into the Big Lie taught to the Muslem World by Haji-amin-el Husseini the late Grand Mufti of Jerusalem as passed on to him during his WWII stay in the Third Reich by Dr. Joseph Goebbels. The "Palestinian People" do not even meet the basic Anthropological definitions of what constitutes a separate and distinct people.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment