click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Should Israel Release more Palestinian Terrorists?

Should Israel Release more Palestinian Terrorists?

It won’t increase the chances for peace. It will just give the Palestinian another opportunity to glorify mass murderers.

by and

Every time there’s a public discussion about whether Israel should release more imprisoned Palestinian terrorists, my heart skips a beat. My daughter Alisa was murdered by Palestinian terrorists in 1995. Two of the killers have been in an Israeli prison since 1995, serving life sentences. I always worry that they will be among the ones released. So yes, it’s personal.

But it’s also much more than that.

It’s not just about my daughter’s killers; it’s about dozens of other Israeli and American families whose loved ones also were victimized by Palestinian terrorists. It’s about the future Israeli victims, if the released terrorists return to their violent ways, as so many of them do. It’s about what’s best for Israel’s national security. And, of course, it’s about what’s best for America, too.

Last year, Israel agreed to release more than 100 terrorists, some of them convicted murderers, in stages, as a gesture of “good faith” to the Palestinians. It was a measure of Israel’s desperation for peace, and of the Obama administration’s not-so-subtle threats to publicly blame Israel if the peace process derails. So to keep that process going, the Israelis took what everyone agrees is a serious security risk.

Now the Palestinian Authority (PA) is demanding that Israel release yet another batch of terrorists – even though the PA is threatening to walk away from the peace negotiations in the weeks to come.

Sadly, the Palestinian leadership never responds to such gestures with any gestures of its own, any steps that would show their desire for peace. Instead, the released killers are welcomed as heroes, with public celebrations, marching bands, and speeches from PA leaders heaping praise on the murderers. When Palestinians embrace terrorists, it tends to convince Israelis that the Palestinians still, well, embrace terrorism.

In a separate “good will” gesture, the Israelis recently gave the PA the bodies of five terrorists, two of whom were involved in suicide bombings that left 16 Israelis dead and more than 80 wounded. Here is how a reporter on PA Television described the two dead bombers at the March 12 funeral in Nablus: “The skies of Nablus adorn themselves with the stars who loved the soil of the homeland, in which they will lie forever having returned to it as Martyrs (Shahids).”

Imagine the uproar if after the funeral of Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh, a reporter for a mainstream American television station, declared: “The skies of Oklahoma City adorn themselves with this star who loved the soil of the homeland, in which he will lie forever having returned to it as a Martyr.”

PA Television then interviewed the brother of suicide bomber Imad Zubeidi, who said, “This is not mourning, but a wedding of Martyrdom – we are very proud that our brother gave of himself for Palestine.” And the sister of the other bomber, Maher Hbeishah, said, “He would always pray, ‘Allah, make us live happily and die as Martyrs’ – praise be to Allah, he achieved it.”

This is the culture of glorifying mass murder that the Palestinian Authority has created. If Israel releases 26 more terrorists, as the PA is demanding, that will mean 26 more celebrations, 26 more parades, and 26 more relatives on television, telling millions of Palestinian and other Arab viewers how wonderful it is to carry out suicide bombings.

You don’t have to be a prime minister or a seasoned diplomat or a four-star general to understand that setting more killers free just doesn't make any sense.

It won’t increase the chances for peace. It will just give the Palestinian another prime-time opportunity to glorify mass murderers.

It won’t help our ally, Israel. It will be just another one-sided concession for which Israel will get nothing in return – and will whet the appetite of Israel's enemies to keep demanding more and more.

It will send a message to the Palestinians that they don’t need to change their ways. They can keep on encouraging terrorism, they can keep promoting a culture of violence – and the Obama administration will keep on pushing to give them a sovereign state, even though we know that it will be a terrorist state. That won’t be good for Israel, for America, or for peace.

New Jersey attorney Stephen M. Flatow is the father of Alisa Flatow, who was murdered by the Palestinian terrorist group Islamic Jihad in 1995.

Reprinted with permission from

March 26, 2014

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 27

(23) LeAnn, July 13, 2015 6:24 PM

Thank You

Mr. Flatow, I would like to thank you for reminding us of these issues -- and what sets us apart. Even more deeply, I want to thank you for the scholarship your family provides in Alisa's absence. I owe nearly my entire Jewish education to that scholarship and I am forever in your debt. Little do we know when tragedy strikes how it changes our future, but you are determinedly working toward tikun ha'olam.

(22) DAS1951, July 12, 2015 6:35 PM

Terrible, but not quite as clear-cut as you think

Of course these terrorist acts are despicable and I sympathise with the families of the murdered, but the solution is not keep thousands of prisoners for ever ("throw away the key") or kill them (death sentence). (The latter is perhaps more obvious...)

Remember these people, many being surprisingly normal, are born into an atmosphere that is infused with hatred of Israel/Jews and a support for 'martyrdom'.

I suggest anyone interested to Google for Dr Sagit Yehoshua, an Israeli criminal psychologist who has turned her attention to "security prisoners" (as incarcerated terrorists are known) in recent years, and check out her research work.
Yes, she is controversial, but a quick check did not reveal any of her critics actually produced any relevant data.

(21) Charles Richman, April 7, 2014 6:33 AM

Absolutely no terrorist should be released

Releasing terrorist prisoners has two apparent consequences: 1. Increasing the probability of attack on Israelis. 2.Elevating the status of Abbas/Mazen in the Arab world that is hostile to Israel and the West.
The release of murderers from Israeli prisons is similar to the USA agreeing to suspend sanctions against Iran, with the Iranian’s failing to comply with any meaningful demands. Sanctions will not be able to be re-instituted toward Iran and it will in the long run only increase the potential violence and influence of Iran in the future and releasing terrorist prisoners who attacked or planned attacks in Israel should not be able to return to the disputed territories will only lead to more attacks on Israel. How easily we forget Itamar, Kiryat Shemona, Ma'a'lot, the Hebrew University cafeteria, terrorist acts in restaurants and discos throughout Israel and each and every murder of our brothers and sisters on Egged buses. Releasing prisoners is an insult to those who were killed or wounded and to their families.

(20) BOB JAMES, April 1, 2014 6:24 PM

RELEASE THEM WHEN U.S. releases all of theirs...not!

Why release a terrorist? United States tried it and wound up fighting and killing and chasing many of them again.

(19) Antonio Perez, March 31, 2014 4:19 PM

Terrorist Release

Why does Israel have to release murderers when other countries don't release their's? It's a double standard. They hate Jews and so they demand absurd things like this. No release. No to double standard anti-semitism.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment