click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

The Moral Battleground

The Moral Battleground

What other country would, for showing such unparalleled moral scrupulousness, be vilified and libeled as Israel is?


And so now begins the second and most difficult stage. Inside Israel, there is both determination and dread as tens of thousands of Israel's conscript army are called to the front. Untold numbers of these soldiers will lose their lives as the result not merely of the genocidal aims of Hamas (and its Iranian puppet-master), but also the indifference and pusillanimity towards Palestinian terror displayed by world governments over the past six decades of Israel's fight for survival, along with the active encouragement of genocidal Islamists by leftists, Jew-haters, Muslims and useful idiots who were on such thuggish display yesterday in the co-ordinated demonstrations in British and other western cities.

Such people have made no protest at the bombardment of Israeli towns by more than 6000 rockets in the past six years, deliberately targeting innocent civilians. They have made no protest at the way Hamas has used Gazan civilians as human shields, situating its murderous arsenals beneath apartment blocks, in schools and hospitals and mosques in order to maximize the numbers of civilians killed (in order to manipulate all-too pliable western opinion). No, their protest only starts when Israel finally takes the military action aimed at stopping this genocidal barrage.

The worst thing is the moral inversion, in which the murderous victimization of innocent Israelis is ignored while their murderers are described as ‘civilians' when they are finally killed by the Israelis -- who are demonstrably taking care to avoid civilian casualties wherever possible. Tragically, civilians always die in wars; and unfortunately there will undoubtedly be more civilian casualties in Gaza -- along with deaths among Israeli troops -- as the war goes on. But the frenzied misrepresentations, double standards and moral inversion fuelling a hysteria in the west which in turn can only incite more genocidal violence are simply depraved.

Particularly striking in its malice is the way in which the treatment of wounded Palestinians in Israeli hospitals is ignored -- while news of the barbaric behavior of Hamas in Gaza's hospitals is airbrushed out of the picture. At WSJ's Opinion Journal, James Taranto noted that a report of this scene in a Gaza hospital briefly appeared in the New York Times a couple of days ago:

Armed Hamas militants in civilian clothes roamed the halls. Asked their function, they said it was to provide security. But there was internal bloodletting under way. In the fourth-floor orthopaedic section, a woman in her late 20s asked a militant to let her see Saleh Hajoj, her 32-year-old husband. She was turned away and left the hospital. Fifteen minutes later, Mr. Hajoj was carried out by young men pretending to transfer him to another ward. As he lay on the stretcher, he was shot in the left side of the head. Mr. Hajoj, like five others killed at the hospital this way in 24 hours, [my emphasis] was accused of collaboration with Israel. He had been in the central prison awaiting trial by Hamas judges; when Israel destroyed the prison on Sunday he and the others were transferred to the hospital. But their trials were short-circuited...

You won't find that passage now on the New York Times website because, soon after it appeared, it unaccountably vanished into the ether. Nor will many in Britain or the west be aware of this:

Dozens of Gaza Arabs are being treated in Ashkelon's Barzilai Hospital at the same time terrorists are bombarding the city. The medical facility, the largest on the southern coast, is in the line of rocket fire, and medical staff often have to stop caring for patients and run for cover during air raid warnings. The 500-bed Barzilai Hospital has close ties with Gaza City's Shifa Hospital, Barzilai deputy director Dr. Ron Lobel told the Associated Press. ‘It might seem completely absurd, but we have the privilege to be doctors. Our medical ethics do not distinguish between patients. We treat whoever needs to be treated,' he said One Gaza Arab woman refused to identify herself to AP [Associated Press] because of fear of retribution by terrorists if it were known that her two-month-old granddaughter is being treated in an Israeli hospital. ‘I am very sad and hurt. We want peace, not war,' she said as Israel began retaliating after hundreds of Arab rocket and mortar attacks, some of them lethal.

The moral inversion in the west is so egregious, so monstrous, that the better Israel is shown to behave the worse the vilification that rains down upon it. What other country in the world would show such restraint in the face of more than 6000 rocket attacks upon its citizens -- 6000! -- that it took seven years before going to war to put a stop to it?

What other country would treat individuals -- including proven terrorists -- from that enemy territory in its own hospitals?

What other country would continue to provide essential foodstuffs and other supplies to those enemies who continued to fire rockets at it?

What other country, when finally forced to go to war to stop the attacks, would show such concern to avoid the loss of civilian life that it contacts the population in enemy territory -- even households containing identified terrorists -- to warn them to flee from the imminent bombardment?

And what other country would, for showing such unparalleled moral scrupulousness, be vilified and libeled as Israel is?

This conflict is revealing just who is on the side of morality, decency and sanity and who is not.

Israel's behavior is moral, legal and proportionate. This conflict is revealing just who is on the side of morality, decency and sanity and who is not. The President of the Czech Republic, who is also the incoming president of the EU, has emerged in the former camp, declaring stoutly that Israel's behavior is both just and necessary. France's president Sarkozy, however, has called upon both sides to stop hostilities -- a moral equivalence which effectively gives Hamas victory by requiring Israel to abandon the defense of its citizens. Similarly in Britain, Foreign Secretary David Miliband has repeated his call for an immediate cease-fire -- while Prime Minister Gordon Brown, has apparently complained to Israel's Prime Minister Olmert that "too many" people have died.

Would that be, perhaps, too many Hamas terrorists who have died? Would Brown have preferred that more of them continued to live so that they could carry on murdering more Israelis?

In startling contrast Farid Ghadry, President of the Reform Party of Syria, has written:

We Arabs must be the ones to stop Hamas and Hizbullah, rather than support their demonic and twisted logic of resisting development, enlightenment, and progress of the region. Even when development and enlightenment stare them in the face, their instinct is to destroy them pretending to safeguard their honor, the mechanics of which supersede all else including a happy life of fulfillment and accomplishments. So while we abhor violence of all kind, Israel's campaign against Hamas must continue to the bitter end not only for the sake of peace but also to help Arabs realize they have a choice: Destroy like Gaza or develop like Dubai. Will this happen soon? Maybe not, but if a wake-up call and a nudge, once in a while, to pierce through the fog of deceit perpetrated by Syria and Iran is what it takes to see the light, then we stand by the West and Israel in the only hope that an Arab Renaissance in the Levant may actually have a chance of resurrection.

Alas, many in the west don't stand with Farid Ghadry. They stand instead with Hamas. Whatever platitudes they mouth, it is clear that they really don't want Israel to survive at all. The moral dividing line in this battle is very clear. Those who stand with Israel are on the side of morality, justice, and civilization. Those in the media and public life who denounce Israel for having the temerity to defend its people are the fellow-travelers of barbarism. Having done so much to embolden and strengthen Hamas and Iran, who are playing them for suckers, they are continuing to stoke the fires of irrational hatred and genocidal hysteria. As Israeli soldiers die, along with the Palestinian victims of Hamas whether as ‘collaborators' or human shields, their blood will be on these hypocritical western hands.

This article originally appeared in
Visit Melanie Phillips website at


January 10, 2009

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 22

(22) boruch nissim, September 6, 2009 3:24 AM

Israel's Morality BS"D

The govt., and much of the Israeli population are always running scared. Recently there was an advertising campaign in England and (I believe) other places. A poster depicting the Land of Eretz Yisroel showed Gaza with a thin line bordering it. The Arabs complained that Gaza didn't stand out enough, and the Israeli 'hasbara' committee (A failure) quickly took down the posters. Had the Israeli govt., 'hasbara' commitee and people any self-esteem they would have noted that in many Arab schools, etc. Israel is called Palestine. There is no mention of Israel. They should have alerted the Arabs to this and said 'when you demark Israel as it really is: 'Israel' then we will make Gaza stand out. The 'hasbara' campaign will NEVER WORK until the Jews there become proud Jews. The campaign will NEVER WORK until the Jews there declare: 'G-d gave us the Holy Land.'

(21) Cathryn Preston, January 25, 2009 6:44 PM

Media bias

Speaking of media bias, there was an article in the Brisbane Sunday Mail (Australia) on Sunday 25/1/2009. It was about 2 suspected US missile attacks in Pakistan. At the end of the article, it says, "The missiles destroyed two buildings, killing 10 people, at least five of whom were foreign militants". If this article was about Israel bombing Palestinian houses (containing terrorists and munitions, and civilians as human shields) in Gaza, it would have said "killing 10 people, 5 of whom were civilians", rather than saying how many were militants, or, dare I say it...terrorists! I'm sick of the media bias I keep seeing, it's infuriating. I'm in a constant state of indignation. I just don't understand why everyone seems to hate al-Quaida and Jemaah Islameeya, yet not Hamas or Hezbollah. Oh wait, I know why! Cos the first two were terrorist groups attacking innocent civilians, and the last two are ...terrorist groups attacking innocent civilians. Hmm... Also, I'm not seeing anyone protesting about America attacking Pakistan - I guess everyone either assumes it is self-defence (they killed some al-Quaida militants), or they just haven't heard of it cos the media doesn't think it's that big a deal. Infuriating.

(20) mark, January 12, 2009 6:45 AM

Mr. Ghadry of Syria

Mr Ghadry's honest editorial will not have him remain long in today's Syria nor with the living given Syria's national mindset.

(19) Anonymous, January 12, 2009 2:48 AM

we must attack , where were they during the rocket bombardment of sderot, and not defend

We are much too busy defending ourselves. That never works. We must attack all those who are blaming us. Where were they when we got bombed! Including the pope and others. I did not hear or see one word asking them to stop Hamas to stop!! WHere were they??

(18) oilthepoil, January 12, 2009 1:37 AM

Islamic Terrorism Is A Double-edged Sword

While it may be obvious to many of us that terrorist groups like Hamas has one primary objective: to destroy the nation of Israel. But there is another side to this terrorism. It also affects negatively human progress in the name of an Arab Renaissance in the Middle East as Mr. Ghadry of Syria had pointed out. Thus, if G-d forbids, these extremists win, it will not only the Jews who will suffer but also the Arab masses. In such an event, a Dark Age will surely have sweep across the Middle East.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment