click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Denying the Holocaust

Denying the Holocaust

As a child, I was obsessed with the Holocaust and swore I would tell the story. Then I became a mother and everything changed.

by

As a child, I was obsessed with the Holocaust. I consumed all the books available on the subject -- a handful compared with the vast literature that exists today -- and discussed it endlessly with my classmates at Bais Yaakov of Boro Park. For us, the taboo topic that both tantalized and repelled with its mystery wasn't boys, but "de hurban" -- the destruction.

Before the morning bell, over lunch, after school, we'd chew over the same words: How could it have happened? How did our parents live through it? And, most important: How could the world have been so silent? The answers eluded us, but we continued to torment ourselves, as if in expiation for our very existence. We were branded, as surely as our parents were, by the numbers tattooed on their forearms.

"Never Again!" we swore, and indeed, later, some of us would join the Jewish Defense League. Others would take upon themselves the burden of witness: I will dedicate my life to recounting the horrors; this testimony will serve as armor; I will protect my people with the story. Others vowed: "I will defeat Hitler by embracing God and Judaism and make my life a testament to those who perished."

Perhaps I was more traumatized than other children my age -- not by my losses, but by the screams in the night.

I made not one but all three of those vows. Perhaps I was more traumatized than other children my age -- not by my losses (two grandparents, two uncles and countless hundreds of relatives, which wasn't unusual among families I knew), but by the screams in the night.

Every night, for years, my father would scream in his sleep: choking, inhuman wails. By day, he never spoke about the Holocaust. But I was woken by his cries, and huddled in a corner outside his bedroom, willing myself to hear and absorb each shriek. It was my duty, I thought, to allow them to engulf me, to tattoo my psyche.

I became an activist. At 16, I joined the Student Struggle for Soviet Jewry ("Let My People Go!") and at 19, the JDL. I was arrested for sitting down in front of the Soviet mission to the U.N., and was proud to have a record. For my people, I would sacrifice.

But more than anything else, I swore, I would tell the story. I wrote essays, poems, songs, plays -- with one theme. As a high school teacher in a yeshivah day school, I asked the principal if I could substitute Elie Wiesel for Charles Dickens. Later, I taught a course in the literature of the Holocaust at Baruch College to West Indians, Hispanics, Chinese-Americans and African-Americans. Many confided at the end of the term that I'd changed their perspective on Jews.

And I waited expectantly for the greatest challenge of all -- imbuing my own children with consciousness of the Holocaust. I wouldn't be like my father -- no screams in the night to sear their spirit. I'd begin educating them at a young age, read them books on the subject, talk to them openly, take them to the Holocaust centers that had recently opened. I would be the perfect teacher.

And then my children came and everything turned around.

The first was born high-strung, sensitive and nervous. It became a challenge to allay his many fears, and parenting proved far more formidable than I'd ever envisioned. How, I wondered, could I inflict the burden of the Holocaust on such a child? He was wrestling with so many inner demons; I couldn't add to his catalogue of terrors. Here I was working to assure him -- with the help of many practitioners I had enlisted -- that the world was a safe place, and then I'd tell him what had happened to three-quarters of his family? And so, I never shared with him the history, the heritage, I had so fiercely vowed to impart.

At birth, the younger one seemed different. A hardier constitution, I can tell already, I breathed with relief in the delivery room. More robust, cheerful, optimistic -- it was evident from the beginning. So maybe I can tell him, I thought as I watched him grow into a sturdy, happy child. But when I looked from one child to the other, I paused.

I was silent, as silent as the mounds of eyeglasses, the piles of shoes, the heaps of empty suitcases that still stand in quiet rebuke in Auschwitz today.

The older one has such a pessimistic perspective. How blessed is the younger one, with his vibrant personality outlook... Do I dare darken his universe? What if the Holocaust education I give him diminishes his spirit, even a fraction? I cherish his warmth, his belief in people, his conviction that the world really is a safe place. How can I tell him that it's not - especially not for Jews?

And so, irony of ironies -- I never told either. I, the voracious Holocaust reader, the impassioned Holocaust teacher, the obsessed Holocaust writer, never shared a single word about the Holocaust with my children. I was silent, as silent as the mounds of eyeglasses, the piles of shoes, the heaps of empty suitcases that still stand in quiet rebuke in Auschwitz today. I was more silent than the damned bystanders, the reprehensible spectators, the mute witnesses. The martyrs and the victims and the heroes of the Holocaust were, in my home, unknown and unsung.

Was I wrong? Was I right? On Holocaust Remembrance Day -- I remember wrenchingly the pledge I made never to forget, the pledge I could not keep. I think with anguish of the 6 million skeletons, and then quietly I put them, one by one, back into the closet.

Denying the Holocaust is from "The Mother in Our Lives," (Targum/Feldheim) a new anthology of Jewish women's writing edited by Sarah Shapiro.

Published: April 30, 2005


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 20

(20) Anonymous, August 8, 2012 3:19 PM

I agree with you

You are absolutley right not to tell your children. Your first obligtion is to be the best mother possible and bring up healthy stable children. They will have plenty of time to learn about the Holocaust when they get older. I'm sure your grandparents wouldn't want you to harm your delicate first born with their stories. He would just become another victim. We also brought up our children without Holocaust stories. Recently one of them, a 30 yr old mother of a lot of children, said, accusingly, "We don't know enough about the Holocaust because you didn't let us go to Yad V'Shem. " "So go", I told her, but she still hasn't ,nor have her children. And I know one of the directors of Yad V'Shem, who told me that she never took her children there, either. By the way, I was a very active member of the Student Struggle.

(19) Pat Volk, August 12, 2011 3:41 PM

Denial of the Holocaust

I watched a documentary about a very sick man who dedicated his life to proving that the Holocaust did not happen. It was so sickening and he was so repulsive. He believed it and set out to prove it.6 millionbodies",crematoriums,survivors. I think he was menatally unbalanced to say the least. he was sure that he was right and never changed his mind. I think he was a madman and he looked it.

(18) joy, May 7, 2005 12:00 AM

twins!!??

AsI read youur story I thought how much we were alike. The complete absorbtion into everything about the holocaust, the desire to be a jew "dafka" and then the 2 children almost exactly like mine!! The first had colic; -the second was very even tempered and smiley. I always had a very strong conviction that children of the holocaust survivors have a certain challenge in parenting amongst other things. The major difference though came when you said nothing whereas I have told and retold and watched movies and hbo specials with them. I do not know if this has changed how they look at the world (i sincerely think not - this generation is steeped in materialism and nothing seems to shake that) but I feel they have to know. How else do we keep the memory alive????

(17) Anonymous, May 7, 2005 12:00 AM

please tell your children

i understand that you worry about your children. i live in israel and every year holocaust day is part of life. my eldest daughter is very sensitive and in her 1st year at school they did a simulation of how people felt then. she was chosen as a jew where other children were chosen as nazis. after a short while she asked her teacher to remove her from the simulation but today as an adult (and a soldier in the army) she can watch programs and talk about it. tell them at an age where they can cope with it. sit with them and show them things that they can cope with and talk with them also at the same time. good luck.

(16) Sadeena Pinhasik, May 7, 2005 12:00 AM

Just shows us how H-shem is in command and not us-øáåú îçùáåú áìá àéù åòöú äùí äéà ú÷åí
The title however of this article is improper since the author is not denying the holocaust in any one, she just isn't publicizing it.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub