Peace in Israel: A Jewish Perspective
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Peace in Israel: A Jewish Perspective

Peace in Israel: A Jewish Perspective

Peace in Israel is possible, but ultimately not through the force of arms.

by

The State of Israel may be 58 years old, but we are still fighting for our existence. We do not need the experts to tell us that this ceasefire is merely a respite; experience has taught us that lasting peace in the Middle East is a chimera.

The Declaration of Independence in 1948 defines the State of Israel as a Jewish country. No other country on earth is defined in terms of its religion. There are many countries where the majority of the population is Moslem or Christian, but a Christian has no right of return to England or France or the United States, nor will Egypt or Iran accept every Moslem. Every Jew, however, has the right of return and can become an Israeli citizen on demand. Why? Because Israel is the Jewish homeland and a place of refuge for world Jewry.

This is an inspiring concept, but it presents the Jewish people with an extremely challenging issue; how to define a Jew. It is absurd to call yourself a Jewish country if you have no clear idea of what being Jewish means, and yet that is precisely our situation.

HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE

To appreciate the problem from a Torah standpoint, we need some historical perspective.

At the time of the Exodus over 3,000 years ago, the world Jewish population stood at well over a million. All things being equal, the Jewish population today should be roughly equivalent to the Chinese; yet there are only 14 million Jews worldwide.

No doubt this enormous discrepancy is partially attributable to our blood drenched history, but most of the attrition in our numbers is the result of fallout. It took a lot of self-sacrifice to be Jewish throughout most of recorded history, and many Jews elected to drop out under compulsion or when the opportunity presented itself.

For example, in 1492 when the Jews of Spain were faced with the choice of conversion or expulsion, two thirds elected to convert rather than face exile. As the creation of the Inquisition attests, this conversion was no more than lip service, but over the course of generations these Jews disappeared entirely. Five hundred years down the road it is impossible to distinguish between the descendants of these conversos and ordinary Spaniards.

We owe the survival of the Jewish people to the Jews who chose to pay the cost of being Jewish in a hostile world.

We owe the survival of the Jewish people and therefore by extension, the existence of the modern Jewish state, to the Jews who elected to remain in the fold throughout the ages and pay the cost of being Jewish in a hostile world. The most recent evidence of the enormous cost of being Jewish is the Holocaust, an unprecedented phenomenon in human history. Not that genocide is rare, but systematic genocide on such an enormous scale when there is no territorial dispute between the contending racial groups to trigger the violence has no historic parallel.

The Holocaust in particular has a special connection with the establishment of the modern State of Israel. The collective guilt and horror of the nations of the world at the immensity of the atrocity perpetrated against the Jewish people was the major factor behind the recognition granted by the international community to the nascent Jewish state. For a brief moment, the peoples of the world recognized the necessity of a Jewish refuge. The State of Israel was paid for with Jewish blood -- the blood of the six million victims of the Holocaust as well as all the Jewish blood spilled over the last 2,000 years.

MODERN ISRAEL

The majority of Israelis are secular and perceive themselves as members of the developed world; the aspirations of the modern Israeli are more or less the same as the aspirations of Western Europeans or Americans. Walking around Haifa or Tel Aviv feels little different than walking around Manhattan, Los Angeles or Toronto. The cars and buildings are not as big, but the people look and feel the same except that the language is Hebrew instead of English.

We have a long, long way to go before reaching end of Jewish history.

Is this what all the bloodshed, suffering and self-sacrifice of the past 2,000 years were about? Is this an appropriate culmination of the mighty heritage of the Jewish people? Did the heroic Jews of history surrender their lives to preserve their faith and stubbornly cling to their unique Sinaic covenant so that their descendants could enjoy the "good life" in the Holy Land and recreate a Hebrew speaking version of New York?

Modern Israel is not the culmination of Jewish history. It may be a step toward the fulfillment of our destiny, but given the fact that there is nothing particularly Jewish about happily pursuing the "good life" sheltered and protected by the might of the Israeli army, it is clear that we have a long, long way to go before reaching end of Jewish history.

THE DIVINE RESPONSE

The Almighty has made a covenant and He will not allow Jewish destiny to slip into oblivion. If the present situation in Israel fails to justify the existence of a Jewish state, Divine Providence will by necessity react with a tailor-made response designed to deliver the clear message that the Jewish nation requires. Israel will not be allowed to simply live peacefully here in the Holy Land when a wake up call is in order.

World Jewry and in particular Israeli Jews will be forced to confront the issue of their Jewishness and to reflect on the significance of living in a Jewish country. We are compelled to face these issues existentially when we are forced to pay a price for being Jewish in a Jewish country.

Jews are an extraordinary people. When I encounter non-Jews, I always attempt to enquire if they have any idea how many Jews there are in the world. The general response is hundreds of millions. This makes sense to me. Who could really believe that a people who are less than one percent of the world population could accomplish so much? Jews have won 30 percent of the Nobel prizes in science since they were awarded. Much of the intellectual progress made in the 20th century was fueled by the ideas of three Jewish thinkers: Albert Einstein, Sigmund Freud and Karl Marx.

Jews are an appreciable percentage of the intelligentsia of the developed world; they are doctors, lawyers, professors, writers etc. out of all proportion to their numbers. In prestigious universities they are a large percentage of the student body. Jews are at the forefront of all movements for social justice, and despite their relatively tiny numbers are responsible for a lot of the philanthropy in the Western world. They have managed to rebuild the Jewish state after a 2,000 year hiatus and to revive a dead language, both unprecedented accomplishments in the annals of human history.

Jews themselves are the only people in the world who do not realize how special they are. The desire to fit in and be like everyone else prevents them from focusing on the significance of their Jewishness and reaching clarity about what being a Jew means. There is little urgency in defining a Jew if Jews are identical to other people anyway. They need to be reminded that they have a unique historic mission which sets them apart, and it is essential to their security and well being to understand this mission and define it clearly. Divine Providence will present them with thought-provoking stimuli whenever they show signs of ignoring their Jewishness and abandoning their mission.

CONFRONTAION

There is no question that a terrorist is fully accountable for his evil acts. It goes without saying that anyone who commits indiscriminate horrors in God's name will ultimately suffer due retribution. In addition to this fact, let us touch on the behind-the-scenes workings of Divine Providence that transcend the willing agents of destruction.

God will not let us ignore the question.

The suicide bomber who blows up a bus and the Hezbollah terrorist who aims his Katyusha rockets at innocent people with the declared intent of killing as many Jews as possible are powerful spiritual stimuli. They force Israelis to confront the existential issue of their Judaism. Why us? Why is it our fate to suffer bloodshed no matter how reasonable we try to be and no matter how many withdrawals we make? Why is it necessary in today's world, where civil rights have finally become entrenched in all developed countries, to maintain a Jewish enclave in the Middle East at such great cost? If we are really no different than other people, why is it worth sacrificing our children's lives to maintain a Jewish State? Perhaps we would be better off in the U.S. or Europe?

God will not let us ignore the question. The Jewish people signed a solemn agreement with God to be a "kingdom of priests and a holy nation". This undertaking is our social contract; it defines our place in the world as God's representatives. And this is especially true about the Land of Israel. The Almighty's promise to Abraham to deliver the land to his children is clearly conditional on their observance of their covenant with God. For I have loved him, because he commands his children and his household after him that they keep the way of God, doing charity and justice, in order that God might then bring upon Abraham that which he had spoken about (Genesis 18,19).

Peace in Israel is possible, but ultimately not through the force of arms. Our forefathers who were driven out of Israel twice knew this well, and Divine Providence treated them with greater severity than it treats us. Instead of sending them a wake-up call, Divine Providence banished them altogether.

In contrast, the typical modern Israeli is ignorant of the need to hold on to the Covenant of Abraham in order to hold on to his country. Providence will not banish him; it will provide him with stimuli to prompt a series of soul-searching questions that if taken to heart, could provoke genuine change.

This is no doubt painful, but the thrust is entirely benevolent. In Jewish thought ignorance is never bliss and the acquisition of knowledge is always painful. But through the workings of Providence, the Jewish people are learning. When the lesson is fully internalized there will be lasting peace.

Published: August 19, 2006


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 39

(39) Anonymous, August 28, 2006 12:00 AM

This is so true, though I certainly encounter Jews in Israel who might not consider themselves religious as such but nevertheless are partially observant and/or proud of our heritage. I believe that we need to learn to be far less divisive though also sensitive to our differences, remembering that the many who hate us do not differentiate between those of us who are observant and those who are non-observant. All that matters is that we are Jews. People do not normally become more observant when treated disrespectfully, but are more likely to respond with kindness, acceptance and a genuine attempt to be understanding of where someone is at.

I truly believe that Hashem is bringing His people home, home to orthodox Judaism and home to the country of Israel, with many baal teshuvas and also people not halachically Jewish but with Jewish neshamas who are converting in larger numbers than for many centuries.

With regard to those treading the difficult path of a ger, all dayanim need to be aware that a genuine convert does not in reality "choose" his or her path any more than a born Jew - if the Jewish spark that Hashem gave you at birth has woken up and is sufficiently strong, you have to come home whatever it takes and can no longer truly live a life worthy of the name until you reach the mikvah. Unnecessary bureaucracy and lengthy delays in some places sometimes of up to several years, injustice and even downright cruelty from a few need to be replaced with fair, honest, just and sensitive scrutiny from all rabbis with a depth of spiritual understanding, integrity and wisdom, and a concern not to add any more suffering than is truly necessary to the immense trauma, confusion and pain that is already inherent in the genuine conversion experience.

Beyond the criticism, because we are all human and can all make mistakes and sometimes be less than noble in our personal motivations, ultimately, I believe we need to be aware that the true protection for Israel comes from Hashem. It seems that sometimes what we perceive as bad at the time, difficult and unjust suffering, actually opens up the possibility of transformation and growth in ways that would otherwise not develop. And it is when we have tried our best and everything seems impossibly difficult that we need to trust Hashem and His protection which He has promised the Jewish people all the more, because that is when Divine Providence can step in, in unexpected and awesome ways. The same infinite G-d who opened a way through the Red Sea and sustained our ancestors with miracles in the Desert has not changed and has the same infinite power as before. And the covenants made with Avraham and with Moshe are just as binding today as when our people were at Sinai. If the Creator of the entire Universe chooses not to use His power or to reveal it in ways that we ask Him to do, it is not because He cannot do so but rather He has chosen not to at that time. But when He does, it can be totally beyond our wildest expectations.



(38) Corena, August 27, 2006 12:00 AM

An education I needed

This is truly freedom of speech.

(37) R.Wise(FFB), August 27, 2006 12:00 AM

Rabbi Weisz, First of all, kol hakovod to you and others in the kiruv movement who are dedicated to bringing Torah to the uneducated.
Your article seems to be focused on the typical modern Israeli who is "ignorant of the need to hold on to the Covenant of Abraham in order to hold on to his country." The key word that I picked up in your statement was "ignorant." And one who is ignorant of Torah or lacks an education is often referred to as a "tinok shenishbah." So if he is a "tinok shenishbah", he requires a role model to envelop him with love and to teach him.

Who are the role models if not for the educated within the Orthodox community? But the role models are not necessarily demonstrating exemplary character traits. Perhaps the soul-searching questions should be asked by the role models. I wonder -- are they in fact modeling the 13 attributes of Hashem toward one another and toward the tinok shenishboh?

(36) Miriam Grossman, August 26, 2006 12:00 AM

from a BT

Rabbi Weisz, It is very inspiring to see large observant families in cities like Toronto, Baltimore, Brooklyn, Denver, Dallas and Los Angeles. Israeli streets are filled with the young and the old who are steeped in Torah. In addition, we are living to see more and more Jews coming back to traditional Judaism. We are blessed that you and your colleagues are in the kiruv movement and that you dedicate yourselves to teaching thousands of Jews how to live more Jewishly. Just think of all that Aish HaTorah and other such organizations have done to repair the damage done by secularism. Those Jews who are less observant have fewer children and the non Orthodox Jewish movements are beginning to fail. It is very sad to see so many of our people losing their Jewish identities, but I believe that we are also seeing a rebirth of traditional Judaism. Please keep these positive thoughts in your heart. You touch many people with your wisdom. I cannot thank you enough.May Hashem bless Am Yisroel with a life of Torah and peace.

(35) jeanne stern, August 25, 2006 12:00 AM

excellent short biography

Unhappily my daughter has no idea of the history of our people. She thinks we are taking the land from the Arabs. I'm horrified at her ignorance. Thank you for your help.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!