click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

One People, One Heart?

One People, One Heart?

Let's unite on the first yartzeit of those eight innocent souls who were murdered during the Merkaz HaRav massacre.

by Doni Joszef

"We are uniting worlds tonight," whispered Rabbi Y.B. Soloveitchik in the ears of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, as he brought some of his students from Yeshiva University to join in a Chabad 'farbrengin.' The Jewish World is like a jigsaw puzzle, with countless sects, denominations, and factions somehow meant to fit beautifully together, yet we are all too often divided and at odds with one another. Rabbi Soloveitchik seemed overjoyed to piece together a small portion of these scattered puzzle pieces. But his hopeful smile soon faded into tears, as the Lubavitcher Rebbe responded: "I'm sorry, my dear friend, but we'll never be able to unite the Jewish world as well as Hitler did."

This seems to be our habitual national tendency. "There is a certain people scattered and dispersed... let it be recorded that they be destroyed" (The Book of Esther 3:8-9). We "scatter and disperse" -- splintering off and dividing into sub-sects based on differences, until our enemies step in, brutally reminding us that we are not as different as we thought. We are not divided; we are one and the same -- we are Jews.

Hitler's bitter reminder didn't come with one chapter addressing Chasidim, another addressing Zionists, another for the 'Yeshivishe Velt,' another for the Modern Orthodox, and yet another for the 'Unaffiliated.' He saw a forest, not its trees, and he set fire to that forest with daunting intentions of national extermination. Yes, indeed, we were united -- in a way by which we hope never to re-experience.

Can we unite without the help of gas chambers and suicide bombers?

Does it take a Haman or a Hitler to break down the walls of division and disassociation? Is there another way?


When I saw my brother handing out flyers that read: "B'lev Echad (with one heart) -- Jews around the world join for a historic celebration of Jewish unity " -- I couldn't help but roll my eyes, in a polite, encouraging way, of course. As any good older brother would do, I told him he was wasting his time. Jews like to do a lot of things, but "uniting harmoniously" isn't exactly one of our more frequent endeavors. An attempt to breach denominational boundaries to celebrate Jewish unity seemed to me a fanciful stretch, to say the least.

But, then again, isn't God eagerly awaiting our self-motivated attempts to unify His beloved Family, regardless of our minute differences? Wouldn't God shep nachas, as it were, from even the most delicate attempt to see past our fine-line differences and particularities sans the encouragement of our enemies?

I understand the complicated nature of ideological differences, made all the more acute when matters of Jewish law come into play. Nevertheless, upon some honest soul-searching, it seems to me that subtle specks of ego and insecurity fuel some of the bitter throes of resentment, irritation, and finger-pointing which characterize our strife and disunity.

Tendencies to condemn, nit-pick, and blame as a defensive means to conceal and alleviate personal insecurities are weaknesses that I understand; after all, they are my own. I'm no all-loving, all-accepting super-Jew, inviting you all to join me in congenial embrace. But I do believe that we can gradually surpass our insecurities, overcome our inadequacies, and -- slowly but surely, one Jew at a time -- flourish in our eternal journey together.

Jews around the globe will participate in a worldwide completion of the Talmud, as eight Torah Scrolls will be dedicated to the families of terror victims.

Call it naive, call it far-fetched, call it idealistic. B'lev Echad may have lofty aspirations, but it's a start. The B'lev Echad event is a novel concept, inspired by the first yartzeit of those eight innocent souls who were murdered in cold blood during the Merkaz HaRav massacre. Eight young lives were shattered for one reason: they were Jewish. Their slaughterer was not concerned about 'how Jewish' or 'what type of Jewish' his victims would be. Simply being a Jew was enough for murderous acts of hatred. should it not be enough for consoling love?

Jews around the globe will participate in a worldwide completion of the Talmud, as eight Torah Scrolls will be dedicated to the families of terror victims.

Free from the contamination of political orientation, Jews are uniting for what has been, and always will be, our common ground -- the Torah.

One by one, Jewish schools and communities around the world -- spanning across denominational realms -- have signed up to participate in this unprecedented experience. As of yet, over 25,000 people have signed up to participate, from all over the United States, Israel, England, India, Moscow, Belarus, New Zealand, Warsaw, Krakow, Berlin, Leipzig, Canada, Cologne, Frankfurt, Vienna, Chili, Mexico City, Honk Kong, and Sydney.

Unadulterated by agendas, politics, or fundraising, Jews from all around the globe are volunteering to participate, and there are numerous ways for one to do so (visit to get involved).

I am deeply inspired by this initiative. The program may be one small step for contemporary Jewry, but it is one giant leap for our eternal Jewish Family.

For more information, or to sign up your school and/or community to participate in this worldwide event,

February 14, 2009

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 4

(4) abraham, March 21, 2016 12:22 AM

we are holy our loss is the loss of all

they are fighting themselves the enemies of their own pepşe the friend of values fake value of money and hate and search for palace by a old bad of clthes of religous
we do not have any bad religous or berayer even our sinner are their sin because of living dirtie of not jew

(3) rena, February 23, 2009 3:27 PM

I agree with Ruth

We all want Moshiach now. We all want and need to serve Hashem in the Holy Temple. Let's stop our sinas chinam & show how we can join together without another Hitler, ch'v!

(2) Mike Sherwood, February 16, 2009 7:51 AM

Could we have gone further

Although born Jewish I lead a secular life up until three years ago (now 53)I decided to study my faith and met the local Chabad Rabbi amongst others. I then started attending many different Shiurim and heard Loshon Hor from different sects of how this one does this and that. Mumbai went some way to reuniting Jews but couldn't it have gone further in uniting people with different faiths as it says in the Torah "Love thy neighbour as thyself" which many Jews seem to forget then we will most definitely be "a light unto all nations".

(1) ruth housman, February 15, 2009 12:12 PM

one people BlevEhcad

I didn't know about this initiative. I think it's a wonderful idea. This involves open ness, lack of judgment of the practices of others, and it's about LOVE.

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment