click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Why the Jews?

Why the Jews?

The durability of anti-Semitism is a horrifying marvel of history.

by Michael Gerson

It so happened that this week, on the day I wrote about Holocaust denial in the Middle East, a homegrown denier took a rifle into the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum -- an institution where I sit on the governing board. The museum counts about 1.7 million visitors each year who learn about the history of murderous racism -- and now one who decided to add to that history.

That day, out of curiosity, I did something I rarely do. I read the comments on my column on a number of Web sites that publish it. In addition to the normal political vituperation, the level of anti-Jewish feeling was appalling. The European genocide, some contended, was exaggerated by Jews for political purposes. Jews were behind the Bolshevik Revolution, the rise of Hitler and the outbreak of World War II. They control the newspapers, radio, television and book publishing. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is right to expose the Holocaust myth, they wrote, and Israel is perpetrating the real holocaust against the Palestinians.

Of course, these are the views of a small, self-selected group of the unbalanced -- hundreds out of millions. But the Internet allows these obsessions to gather in fetid pools, as James W. von Brunn (a prolific Web author) knew and exploited. The Internet has helped to create communities of malice.

The anti-Semitic community is varied in background and ideology. It includes both Internet Nazis and campus leftists carrying signs that read, "Jews = Nazis." The Rev. Jeremiah Wright recently blamed "them Jews" for blocking his access to President Obama. A conservative Web site recently included a forum on Holocaust denial (before it was exposed and removed). One posting read: "The same blinded people that believe that the Germans intentionally killed Jews -- also believe the myth of the Anne Frank Diary."

Marginalized Western anti-Semites and Holocaust deniers have gained influence in unexpected places. In 2002, Libya's dictator Moammar Gaddafi awarded his (less than coveted) Gaddafi International Human Rights prize to Roger Garaudy, a French Holocaust skeptic. Ahmadinejad's 2006 conference of deniers featured David Duke as a keynote speaker.

For some Americans, anti-Semitic conspiracy theories are akin to a shameful hobby -- like collecting old racist knickknacks or Nazi memorabilia. But these ideas are not harmless, because they can inspire an angry, obsessed bigot who sets out on a June morning to kill Jews -- and murders an African American man who had a wife and young son.

The durability of anti-Semitism is a horrifying marvel of history. Sara Bloomfield, the director of the Holocaust Museum, observes: "Anti-Semitism has existed with and without Christianity. With and without the right wing. With and without the left wing. With and without democracy. With and without economic problems. With and without globalization. With and without a Jewish homeland."

Anti-Semitism has always been a reliable measure of a nation's moral and social health.

Why the Jews? It is a question that must often have been asked during pogroms and in ghettos and in prison camps. There are many answers, none of them adequate. Anti-Semitism in the West has undeniable theological roots -- the distortion of a faith, founded by a Jewish teacher, to justify the persecution of Jews. Anti-Semitism has been fed by government incitement and by blood libels that never seem to die. It found resonance in various forms of nationalism and nativism, in the bent science of eugenics, and eventually in totalitarian ideology.

David Berger, the editor of "History and Hate," writes, "We shall never fully understand anti-Semitism. Deep-rooted, complex, endlessly persistent, constantly changing yet remaining the same, it is a phenomenon that stands at the intersection of history, sociology, economics, political science, religion and psychology."

But we do know that anti-Semitism has always been a kind of test -- a reliable measure of a nation's moral and social health. When the rights of Jews are violated, all human rights are insecure. When Jews and Jewish institutions are targeted, all minorities have reason for fear. And by this standard, America has cause for introspection.

The museum that von Brunn assaulted is the best answer to his hatred -- the aging survivors who still volunteer, photographs revealing the vanished lives of the dead, the happy pictures drawn by murdered children. Not far from where von Brunn entered the museum, there is a black wall inscribed with a quotation: "All men are created equal . . . they are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights . . . among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness."

This is what anti-Semitism ultimately must deny, and this is the reason anti-Semitism must always and everywhere be confronted.

This article originally appeared in the Washington Post.

June 13, 2009

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 40

(40) julie, June 21, 2009 2:49 PM

teachers pet

when I was in 4th grade I had a very old, mean lady for a teacher. I was quiet and well behaved so she loved me. She would tell the class how bad they were and how much they should try to be like me. It was awful. I could not make friends not matter how hard I tried and even when I told her that I wished her to stop making an example of me she only marginalized her praise, which did me no help. I could imagine that this is how monotheists may feel. They obviously like the messages of Judaism, they make them their own, but they feel hatred for the teachers pet. The only way we can combat this is to be as outgoing and inclusive as possible. Creating community centers with child care for working mothers and summer day camps for middle school and high school kids in communities where there are no Jews is the best way to say we care and we like you. The more afraid we are the more people will hate us.

(39) Steve, June 21, 2009 11:24 AM

Anti-Semitic conservatives?

Mr. Gerson wrote: "A conservative Web site recently included a forum on Holocaust denial (before it was exposed and removed). One posting read: "The same blinded people that believe that the Germans intentionally killed Jews -- also believe the myth of the Anne Frank Diary." I wish Mr. Gerson had included the name of the "conservative" web site. I am a political conservative. I believe anti-Semitism is antithetical to conservatism. Loons like Patrick Buchanan and David Duke are neither conservatives, nor do they fit in the conservative movement. Conservatives are some of Israel's supporters, unlike these loons and those on the left who support Barack Obama. Please, name this so-called "conservative" web site. How about Llewellyn Harrison Rockwell's web site? What is it? Please Mr. Gerson?

(38) Anonymous, June 21, 2009 6:00 AM

One of the major reasons why anti-Semitism is so rooted in Europe, goes back centuries, to the times when the Pope/Church forbade Jews to own land and forced them to be money lenders, while at the same time forbidding Christians to engage in money lending. This is where the old stereotype of a "stingy Jew" comes from.

(37) Jeff Knight, June 20, 2009 2:54 PM


Amen!!! Unfortunately some people will deny the truth even it stares starkly into their faces. We must never ever forget, even when our voice appears to be the only one...

(36) dan rose, June 19, 2009 3:42 PM

A common dislike is a powerful bonding element

Dislike and hate are a powerful bonding factors.It was essential for early Christians to bond by hating Jews, while adoring their Messiah. Later the Jews in their ghettos bonded by fearing and disliking the goyim. Their rabbi taught to loath the goyim, goyishe secular education, goyishe looks goyishe behaviour etc... Many Jews and Gentiles have outgrown their medieval way of thinking and tolerate each other. A significant vocal minority on both sides still find in hate and dislike a major unifying force.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment