click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

A Sukkah Invades Afghanistan

A Sukkah Invades Afghanistan

Could a Navy rabbi bring joy to a war zone?


Days after a deadly Taliban attack on a US military base in Afghanistan, a Navy rabbi arrived on a special mission. He was going to build something never before seen at this base.

"I had been preparing for this mission for months in advance of the target date," explained Rabbi Neal Kreisler, a Navy Lieutenant Commander sent from San Diego to lead High Holiday services. "It was obvious that we would need a sukkah.”

The first obstacle Rabbi Kreisler faced was getting a sukkah to Afghanistan. While the military could not purchase this religious item, it did agree to transport it. Next, Rabbi Kreisler turned to Yeshivas Pirchei Shoshanim, an endorser of rabbinic military chaplains, to locate a sukkah before the rapidly approaching shipping deadline. Founder Rabbi Fischel Todd of Lakewood emailed his contacts for help.

It was an urgent request.

"One visit to the sukkah can change a person's life, especially in a war zone," said Rabbi Todd.

Ari Werth, a community leader in New York, immediately recognized the spiritual opportunity. "In giving tzedaka, my priority is giving people the opportunity to perform mitzvot, commandments, who wouldn't have access to them otherwise," he said. "You can't get more unique than providing a sukkah in Afghanistan for Jewish Marines."

Werth sponsored the ten by ten foot sukkah, which was gifted by Pirchei Shoshanim to the US Marines. Sieger Sukkah in Los Angeles was able to provide a package deal for the cause and the sukkah kit boxes were airlifted to Afghanistan by the US Air Force.

Rabbi Kreisler spent Rosh Hashanah leading services at Kandahar Air Field. Taliban rocket attacks interrupted the service and forced everyone to finish praying in a bunker.

After surviving that experience, Rabbi Kreisler headed to Camp Leatherneck, where a devastating surprise Taliban attack had just taken place, destroying $200 million worth of aircraft attack jets and taking the lives of two American servicemen. Providing spiritual strength during Sukkot was more important now than ever before.

All was going according to plan until Rabbi Kreisler began assembling the sukkah. A missing box of parts brought everything to a standstill.

"We were in a pickle and a kosher one at that," quipped Rabbi Kreisler. He turned to the Seabees, the construction battalion of the Navy, who kicked into action and crafted the necessary replacement parts.

"Sure enough, as the Seabees were building the walls a Marine walks by and asks incredulously 'Is this a succah?' He was Jewish and came back to eat in the succah during the holiday week. There is no way to calculate the meaningful spiritual impact something like this can have on an individual.”

Approximately ten Jewish servicemen used the sukkah and many non-Jews, including the commanding general, came by to ask about its religious significance. The servicemen also enjoyed kosher wine and the lulav and etrog from the Aleph Institute.

"The Jewish sailors and Marines were so happy," reported Rabbi Kreisler. "This is a combat zone. You never know what will happen out here. But when you walked into that sukkah, you walked into a place of light and joy.”

The sukkah is now property of the Marines and will be deployed each year at a base somewhere around the world.

Ari Werth plans to help provide community sukkahs in other needed locations for next Sukkot and is looking for additional sponsors.

“The sukkah is a powerful way to attract Jews of all backgrounds to connect spiritually,” said Werth. “Every year we should raise the public profile of Sukkot a bit more and spread the joy of Judaism.”

October 21, 2012

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 5

(5) Yehudit, October 24, 2012 1:41 AM

The Joy of Sukkot!

Yasher Koach, Rabbi Kreisler!!! You performed a real mitzvah, to put it mildly, by arranging for and then erecting a real sukkah in a war zone. I'm sure you made the Jewish soldiers soooo happy!

(4) Judith, October 22, 2012 7:19 PM


Yashar Koach to Rabbi Kreisler, Ari Werth, Ronnie Sieger and all the people who helped make Sukkot in Afghanistan happen this year. A special warm thank you to his wife and boys, who spent the Chag without him, so others could have a Yom Tov.

(3) Bob Wallach, October 21, 2012 9:31 PM


Not many Jewish Marines or Spcl. Ops. But G-D knows us all as his chosen people on the Battlefield. We are brothers there, Maccabees ALL , no matter the faith we speak to him through, in the war for freedom. SEMPER FI Chaplain. (LT.) Kreisler

(2) Monica Pollans, October 21, 2012 8:59 PM

Great story ... thanks

That was a great story. My son was in the Navy and served in Iraq and most recently off the coast of Libya aboard a destroyer. I don't think he got much in the way of anything Jewish back then so it's good to see that other Jewish personnel are now having that opportunity.

(1) TMay, October 21, 2012 8:51 PM


So how much does an army Sukkah cost, and has anyone started a fund? As a woman who lacks construction experience I looked into what would be the simplest way of creating a Sukkah without needing a hammer and nails and I thought that the tents that the Native Americans used would be the easiest to assemble. The material would not have to go all the way around and would stop 3/4 of the way up so that one could see the stars.

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment