Farewell to Pope Benedict
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Farewell to Pope Benedict

Farewell to Pope Benedict

Despite some disappointments, he moved the strained Christian-Jewish relations one step closer.

by

I met Pope Benedict at the infamous death camp of Auschwitz-Birkenau.

It was right after he had assumed his position as head of the Catholic Church and his very first trip as Pope was to Poland. After stopping in Wadowice, birthplace of his predecessor, Pope John Paul II, Pope Benedict went on to the concentration camp complex 37 miles west of Cracow that epitomized the very worst of Nazi Germany’s genocidal plans for the Jewish people.

It was an historic moment. The newly installed Pope, after all, was a German who at the age of 14 joined the Hitler Youth, as was required of young Germans of the time. What were we to make of his past affiliation? It was a troubling thought that preoccupied Jews throughout the world. Having serendipitously become involved with Pope John Paul II a short while before in an effort to secure the return of precious Jewish items from the Vatican, I was filled with trepidation.

The previous Pope had proved to be more of a friend than we could have possibly imagined. When he made his famous pilgrimage to Jerusalem in March 2000, he wrote a very special note which he inserted into the Western Wall. He acknowledged the special role of Jews as God’s messengers and apologized for generations of bigotry and appalling behavior:

We are deeply saddened by the behavior of those who in the course of history have caused these children of yours to suffer, and, asking your forgiveness, we wish to commit ourselves to genuine brotherhood with the people of the Covenant.

Pope John Paul II had been, as the expression goes, “good for the Jews.” What could we expect from Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger, the ninth German Pope in history?

The decision to stage the first major event of his papacy at the site of history’s most horrific example of anti-Semitism was unmistakably important, and I was lucky enough to have been present for the occasion.

A solemn Pope Benedict, his hands clasped in prayer, entered the camp gates on foot, 20 meters in front of his cardinals, in a driving rain storm. Church bells rang in the southern town of Oswiecim, the Polish name for Auschwitz. After placing a bowl containing a lighted candle at the camp's execution wall, where the Nazis summarily shot thousands of inmates, he moved along a line of 32 camp survivors waiting to meet him. Poland's Chief Rabbi Michael Schudrich recited the Kaddish, while musicians played a haunting Jewish lament.

At the site where Nazis exterminated more than a million people, most of them Jews, the Pope began his address by telling the assembled, "In a place like this, words fail. To speak in this place of horror, in this place where unprecedented mass crimes were committed against God and man, is almost impossible – and it is particularly difficult for a Christian, for a pope from Germany.”

"I could not fail to come here. I had to come," he said. "It is a duty before the truth and the just, due of all who suffered here, a duty before God, for me to come here as the successor of Pope John Paul II and as a son of the German people."

Then an utterly amazing thing happened. Not everyone there understood its biblical significance. But for those who did, it magnificently captured the spiritual meaning of the moment.

Until then we all stood in torrential rain. An aide held an umbrella over the Pope. The fortunate ones among us found some cover. But precisely when the Pope concluded his remarks the rain ceased. A magnificent rainbow appeared in the sky with its arc pointing almost directly to the six memorial markers commemorating the 6 million Jews who had perished.

It was in the time of Noah after the flood and the first cataclysmic time of destruction that God designated the rainbow as an eternal sign to mankind. Its message was God’s promise that a similar devastation would never again be repeated.

What could have been more relevant than a rainbow for those of us who wept at the site of 20th century’s most heinous evil! “Never again” was the divine assurance we perceived from the totally unexpected sign in the sky.

Transference of Power

In the aftermath of the ceremony, hordes of reporters gathered round me to get a rabbinic response to the Pope’s remarks. It soon became apparent though, that they were uninterested in hearing how moved I was by a German Pope’s condemnation of Nazi atrocities. They would have loved to be able to get a headline like, “Jewish leader appalled by Pope’s failure to sufficiently mourn Jewish victims of the Holocaust.”

“Weren’t you disappointed that the Pope didn’t…” was the question raised in variously worded queries goading me to say something negative. But this first encounter with the newly elected Pope was, to my mind, greatly reassuring.

Since that time I have carefully followed Pope Benedict’s relationship with the Jews. He made sure to visit numerous synagogues, has received many delegations from the Jewish community, and pledged repeatedly to uphold the Second Vatican Council’s 1965 teachings about Jews and Judaism that had opened the door to today’s positive relations between the two communities.

Despite some disappointments, some admittedly serious, I concur on the whole with Israeli Chief Rabbi Yona Metzger. After the pope announced he would resign, a spokesman quoted Metzger as saying, “During his period [as Pope] there were the best relations ever between the Church and the Chief Rabbinate and we hope this trend will continue. I think he deserves a lot of credit for advancing inter-religious links the world over between Judaism, Christianity and Islam.”

I do not know what is in the Pope’s heart of hearts. There are those who refuse to consider the possibility that any Christian, especially its highest spiritual leader, could sincerely harbor any goodwill toward our people. History would indeed justify our hesitation. But Pope John Paul II gave hope that as we come closer to the end of days, ancient wounds might find the opportunity for at least a measure of healing. And I believe it would be a mistake for us not to acknowledge the positive efforts of Pope Benedict during the years of his papacy, even as we fully recognize the many differences between our faiths.

Pope Benedict stunned the world with his announcement of imminent retirement. I believe his final message to the world is as important to us as it is to his followers. Unable to properly fulfill his duties due to physical constraints, he has chosen to transfer his position of power and honor to someone more capable. That is certainly an idea worthy of imitation by many.

As to the selection of a new Pope, it is not within the Jewish purview to involve ourselves in such a process. But we hope the Church finds a papal leadership that will continue its path of atonement for the many centuries of its anti-Semitic history, and will do its part to help heal the world.

Published: February 13, 2013


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 44

(26) Gabreilla Daniely, March 1, 2013 4:24 PM

a great insight

I'm quite disappointed that so few people like this article!!

(25) Meg H, February 26, 2013 1:44 AM

As a Catholic, I have a sterner assessment

If informed Jews say that Benedict has helped the cause of Jewish-Christian understanding and cooperation, then I believe it and am glad to hear it. In my turn as a Roman Catholic, however, I must say that Benedict failed to advance the church in the signal matter of its moral answerability to the Jewish people. His visit to Auschwitz illustrated this. I was deeply disturbed by Benedict's remarks. The use of "the silence of God" as one of his themes was to my mind scandalous. Consider the following words: "We cannot peer into God's mysterious plan . . . . [but] we must continue to cry out humbly yet insistently to God: 'Rouse Yourself! Do not forget mankind, your creature!'" The question for Catholics is not why God was silent. It is why we were silent. It is not why God failed to rouse Himself. It is why we refused to rouse ourselves. Would God have seemed so silent to Jews if Christians en masse had resisted Hitler and all his works as it was their responsibility to do? A pope enters a synagogue in a spirit of friendship. A pope leaves a penitent note at the Western Wall. A pope stands within the gates of Auschwitz and states that what went on there was wrong. These politenesses aren't acts of justice or moral integrity. They are the expressions of romantic self-involvement, however earnest their intent. Remorse and reform there may be, but there is no atonement for murder. Until we have a pope who can get that through his head and promulgate it, the Roman Catholic Church will have said nothing of actual import to Jews.

(24) Anonymous, February 25, 2013 9:59 AM

A few words on "lost" Temple objects

I don't understand the myths that people are spreading here about lost Temple objects. Any academic will know that this is complete nonsense. The Temple objects were brought to Rome in 70, but since these objects had no significance to the pagan Romans, it is more than likely that they would have melted down the golden objects to finance their very costly wars and buildings such as the Colosseum. Christianity was only made legal in 313. The Roman Empire collapsed in the next 100 years & was sacked several times. How would the Temple objects survived any of this? Let's face it: The temple objects are lost and destroyed. It is true, however, that the Vatican owns a huge collection of Jewish books and manuscripts, but these are not "hidden". The Vatican has given some important ones on loan to Israel, and there is a catalogue of Jewish Manuscripts in the Vatican Library. Google it. Nothing secret there. Should these items be returned to us? If they were stolen, yes. I don't like the Vatican, but it is not helpful to create false hope concerning the Temple objects, because they don't exist anymore and because it only creates rifts among the nations. so please inform yourself about this issue, have some common sense and stop spreading this nonsense.

(23) SS, February 22, 2013 5:03 PM

Bottom Line: We get sympathy for the Holocaust, but nothing else

Pope Benedict gave us the standard treatement from governments and religious figures world-wide, except for most Moslem religious figures. It is acceptable to give us sympathy for the holocaust, but not acceptable to approve of the existence of the Jewish State. So, the US government spends millions for Holocaust museums, but lies about its obligations in negotiating peace treaties with Israel and its neighbors. The US government, for instance, went back on its pledge to patrol the Sinai, after Morsi took office in Egypt and terroreist began to rule the roost in Sinai. This is just the latest of countless lies the US has told Israel during its treaty and peace negotiations with its neighbors. Likewise, the Pope lost no time during his Papacy to go to the Middle East and vouch for Palestinian claims on the state of Israel. This is for the Palestinians that desecrated the Church in Bethlehem with their terrorist takeover. And the same Palestinians who terrorized the Christian citizens of Bethlehem with demands of a cut of their business profits and other indignities. So, the Pope was very good at grand, sympathetic gestures, but he continued the party line of acting against the existence of Israel.

(22) Willm, February 21, 2013 4:57 AM

Christians that harbor goodwill towards the Jews.....

In your AISH article on Pope Benedict, it is written "that any Christian, especially its highest spiritual leader, could sincerely harbor any goodwill toward our people". I can confirm that today there are many christians that recognise "their older brother" as we call you, and that seek for the best of Israël. May Hashem bless you!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub