click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Jews Flood Toronto Courtroom to Defend a Young Man’s Life

Jews Flood Toronto Courtroom to Defend a Young Man’s Life

The doctors wanted to unplug Shalom Ounanounou. The Jewish community sprung into action.

by

Hundreds of Torontonian Jews from all types of backgrounds flooded the Canada Life Building on November 1, 2017, filling the long corridor and jamming into the largest courtroom. We came for one purpose: to support a Jewish life.

Yochai Shalom Nethanel Ounanounou, 25, suffered from a severe asthma attack that lead to cardiac arrest on September 27. The ambulance did not reach him in time and he slipped into a coma. At Toronto’s Humber River Hospital he was connected to respirators and remained unresponsive. In the weeks that followed, he was never alone. His family members kept him company by his bedside.

The doctors pronounced him brain dead and issued a death certificate since the provincial medical community defined ‘death’ as the cessation of brain functions. The doctors wanted to unplug him on Yom Kippur, saying that the hospital can offer no further treatment, but family and their rabbis fought to keep him on the respirator.

Shalom Ounanounou

“Under Jewish law, and in accordance with Shalom’s beliefs, Shalom is alive and the application of the brain death criteria expressly violate Shalom’s religious beliefs and thus discriminate against him based on his religion,” read a statement by Max Ouanounou, the patient’s father. “Shalom seeks an accommodation as a matter of human rights and constitutional law that allows his Jewish beliefs to be considered and accommodated in determining when death occurs.”

A hearing was issued to resolve this opposition. The day before it took place, a letter circulated through social media to the Jewish community pleading for Jews to come and support Shalom.

I took the hour-long trek to downtown Toronto with several other women. We pulled up to see busloads of yeshiva boys streaming into the building. We followed them and collided with the crowd as soon as we exited the elevator.

Throngs outside the courtroom

Hundreds of people abandoned their regular schedules and came to this hearing. Everyone there felt the power each individual could make. No one said, “I’m only one person. It won’t matter whether I come or not.” In a court case fighting for religious freedom, we demonstrated the uniting power of religion.

Standing in that cramped corridor, I was surrounded by throngs of people who shared the same goal to save Shalom’s life. Beyond the fear and tension of the situation, we unanimously felt uplifted and inspired. How could the judge deny the will of hundreds of supporters crammed in the hallway?

The hearing began late, but many people stayed until the end, two hours later. They, like me, were not leaving until we hear the resolution.

We won.

The judge, Mr. Justice Hainley, ruled that Shalom should not be removed from life support, at least until the case is fully resolved, and the doctors cannot withhold any treatment that can improve his condition. Mr. Hainley made it clear that every medical personnel in that ward must be aware of this ruling, giving liability to the head doctors so no one can unplug the patient ‘accidentally.’

After the hearing, Charles Wagner, the lawyer that represents the League for Human Rights of Bnai Brith Canada and the Vaad Harabonim of Toronto, said this is only the beginning. Shalom may be on life support for now, but there will be a long case ahead to fight for this law that could take years. He expects the case to reach Supreme Court.

Some supporters drove straight to the hospital to celebrate the good news. Singers Yaakov Shwekey and Shlomo Simcha and musician Yanky Katina played music for Shalom and his family by his bedside. We left the government building, elated by the verdict and the incredible comradery of our nation.

Please pray for Yochai Shalom Nethanel ben Rivka.

November 5, 2017

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 8

(7) SION, November 10, 2017 11:30 PM

i wish him full recovery very soon
REFUAH SHELEMA

(6) David Ryan, November 7, 2017 2:37 AM

As an ICU physician I agree with Dr.Ezekiel; long experience has proven his remarks to be incontrovertibly true. This is a tragic outcome for one of our brothers. However, his soul is trying to leave his body and we are detaining it.

(5) Zvi Israel, November 6, 2017 11:31 AM

Ramifications

Anyone supporting this should be aware that they can never receive a transplanted organ, ever
Our poskim are divided on whether brain death represents halachic death, and this should not be painted as a black and white issue
The lives of many have been saved by transplanting vital organs from individual who were declared brain dead

(4) Virginia McCorkle, November 5, 2017 9:13 PM

New medical research on pvs--VERY important!

Please make sure that the young man's family & physicians are aware of newest research into awareness & persistent vegetative states: a study involving stimulation of the vagus nerve at a level in the body resulted in not only an awakening from the pvs, but also a restoration of the patient's ability to converse/feel in ways not thought possible.

I'm sorry I cannot find the reference/citation, but it's been in the news within the last few months, on nytimes, bbc, or theguardian.com I feel sure the family & its lawyers can use this article to at the very least explore other options for Shalom, & support his being maintained until such time as it's determined for change.

Sincerely,
Virginia McCorkle

(3) Anonymous, November 5, 2017 2:30 PM

You can keep a person alive on machines indefinitely

But it's not natural. What happened is a tragedy, but it was God's will. I knew a woman who choked and was declared brain dead. She had severe Alzheimer's. Her family kept her alive on respirators and she had 24 hr. care by nurses for almost eight years, with constant medical intervention. She never regained consciousness.Baruch Dayan Emet.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub