“Shall Jonathan Die?” A Letter to President Obama
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




“Shall Jonathan Die?” A Letter to President Obama

“Shall Jonathan Die?” A Letter to President Obama

I add my voice to the many who are calling on you to commute Jonathan Pollard’s sentence.

by

Honored President,

Divine providence, acting through the American people, has appointed you to the most exalted office in the world: President of the United States. You stand at the head of the most powerful nation in the world whose strength is measured not only by its political, economic and military might, but also by its spiritual power as the flag bearer of liberty and freedom.

At the eastern port of entry to the United States stands the Statue of Liberty, which symbolizes for all who enter her gates the longed-for national calling card, the yearning for freedom of all mankind.

In the chronicles of history, the brilliant personalities of George Washington, Abraham Lincoln and the visionary Martin Luther King, Jr. stand out. Their character and their fight for independence, liberty and equality light the way for your feet in forging another link in this illustrious chain.

My dear President, it is 28 years (nearly 10,000 days) that Jonathan Pollard has been incarcerated in an American prison. He was sentenced for a serious offense, passing classified information to a foreign country, albeit a friendly nation, the State of Israel.

Those who were responsible for this affair have admitted their guilt and expressed honest and deep remorse for this serious breach, even if it were done with the intention of protecting the security of Israel.

Despite the admissions and the remorse, Jonathan continues to remain in jail for a period of time unparalleled in its harshness – and for which there has been no precedent in American history. In addition to the fact that the man is serving a disproportionately severe sentence, it is well known that his health is failing and his life expectancy is diminishing.

In the book of Samuel I in the Bible, Chapter 14, the People of Israel cry out: “Shall Jonathan die?” This outcry which refers to Jonathan, the son of King Saul, screams from the chambers of my own heart with regard to Jonathan Pollard, that he should merit to leave prison alive, and perhaps even be blessed with the most basic right which has been denied him up until now, fatherhood.

Honored President, after the requests of the president of our country, Shimon Peres, and our prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu, and thousands of Israelis – as well as those of exalted American leaders such as secretaries of state, Henry Kissinger and George Shultz – I too add my voice to the many who are calling on you to hear and to respond positively to commute the sentence of Jonathan Pollard, who seeks only to live out the remainder of his life with his wife Esther in the State of Israel, which has granted him citizenship.

Your taking this action, Mr. President, shall be engraved upon the hearts of freedom-seekers throughout the world as a gesture worthy of being included in the chronicles of humanity.

With blessing,
Rabbi Yisrael Meir Lau

This letter originally appeared in The Jerusalem Post.


Prime Minister Netanyahu, President Peres, the leaders of every major political party in the Knesset, and U.S. government officials, legal professionals, and religious groups have all called for Pollard's release, as has the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations.

As part of the "Call for Clemency Campaign," people across the United States are encouraged to call President Obama and request the release of Jonathan Pollard, telling the White House that 28 years in prison is more than enough.

You can call the White House at 202-456-1414 or 202-456-1111, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. EDT, and ask for President Obama to commute Pollard's sentence. Thank you and hopefully every small effort will make a difference.

Published: March 17, 2013


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 22

(17) betty, May 13, 2013 7:02 PM

"Moles" in Washington

Many years ago there was a TV report on "moles" planted in sensitive positions in our government. They were caught and imprisoned and were released many years ago. They never served anything near what Mr. Pollard has endured. Yes, treason is treason and he

needed some punishment, but not a life sentence!

(16) Chuck, April 7, 2013 1:43 AM

Treason is treason

Well, the Rabbi's letter was most respectful, and inspiring.... But I fear that he badly misses the point. This is not about how well intentioned Pollard was, or about whether or not Israel is a US ally... It is all about a betrayal of trust. Just because Pollard betrayed his country on behalf of Israel does not make it excusable... Israel is not the 51st state, it is a foreign country. If Abu Hassam gave US secrets to Iran, confessed his treason and was sent to prison, I doubt that the Rabbi would be agitating on his behalf. Treason is, and will always be, treason. As US citizen, Pollard's first and only loyalty is and was to the US. He betrayed that loyalty... He remained an employee of the US government, taking a salary, even while he was betraying his country. He is where he belongs.

(15) Anonymous, April 6, 2013 9:43 PM

free Pollard

I've read your books, Mr. President, and books that explain your books, and I am asking to set aside your feelings about various ethnic groups, your history, your background, and think of one person...just Mr. Pollard, and isn't it time he was released from prison...no one in his position has EVER been incarcerated for such an unjust period of time. Please, Mr. President...some compassion is needed.

(14) Bev Kurtin, March 24, 2013 11:23 PM

Let our people go.

To POTUS: What better time than at Passover to free Mr. Pollard? He deserves to be free...NOW. I voted for you both times because I feel that you know right from wrong; I ask you to do the right thing.

(13) dobberpapa, March 24, 2013 1:13 PM

supporting the warm letter from Meir Lau

Besides of the human cruelty agnst Jonathan Pollard, I suppose the damage to the US by *not* freeing him is far higher than suggested by his spywork, so even US-enemies could oppose Jonathans's release.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!