click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Swastikas in New York

Swastikas in New York

Jewish students face ongoing anti-Semitism and no one is doing anything about it.


My great grandparents were born in New York. At the end of a high school Holocaust memorial assembly, students were asked to file out quietly in the following order: those who had parents who were Holocaust survivors, those who had grandparents who were survivors, and finally those who had great grandparents who were survivors. I remained sitting with three other students in the empty auditorium. We looked at each other across rows of empty seats, and I felt shock ripple through me. I didn’t know that most of my classmates' grandparents were survivors.

On the stage the American flag rippled in the dim spotlights alongside the Israeli flag, and I thought about the refuge that this country has been for so many Jews. My grandmother used to tell the Santa Claus who offered us candy canes at the mall: "No thank you. We're Jewish so we celebrate Hanukkah. But happy holidays!" I'll never forget the way her green eyes lit up with her fiery pride for Judaism. As her granddaughter, I grew up believing that being Jewish was a gift, and that anti-Semitism was an archaic form of ignorance that lay far away in mid-century Europe.

Unfortunately last week’s headline in the New York Times, "Swastikas, Slurs and Torment in Town's Schools" shows that virulent hatred still simmers right here. In the Pine Bush Central School District in New York State, located 90 minutes north of New York City, going to school has been a nightmare for Jewish students. Swastikas have been found on walls, desks, lockers, textbooks, computer screens, a playground slide and, in an especially horrifying incident, scrawled onto a Jewish student's face. Three Jewish families are suing the district and its administrators in federal court for flagrant anti-Semitism and the apathy of school officials.

In 2011, when a parent complained about the harassment of her daughter, the school superintendent, Philip G. Steinberg, wrote in an email: "I have said I will meet with your daughter and I will, but your expectations for changing inbred prejudice may be a bit unrealistic." The affected students’ grades have been dropping, and many of them have felt depressed and socially isolated. The swastikas that were carved onto school property were often accompanied by messages such as: "Die Jew." One of the students said that he stopped reporting swastikas to teachers because no one was doing anything about them.

The school superintendent said that he found the situation especially challenging because there were so many students accused of anti-Semitic behavior. When a NYT reporter visited the town and asked its citizens if they were aware of the swastikas and incidents, one man said: "We don't want them (Jews) in our town. They can't drive, for number one, and they already have Sullivan County. Who really wants them here? They don't belong here."

The families say that their discussions with school officials were fruitless, and that they were not informed that other families had raised similar issues. A father once asked an assistant principal why his son was disciplined for defending himself against a student who had grabbed him after teasing him about the Holocaust. The school official answered: "We have a zero-tolerance policy for fighting." The Jewish students have had coins thrown at them, been told to retrieve money from garbage cans and have been shoved and beaten.

The parents who have lodged complaints have been asked by the superintendent why they are still living in a community with such a level of hatred for Jews. One frustrated mother answered: "In a better economy that might be nice (to leave), but I can't sell my house and move from here right now. Something needs to be taken care of at the school level."

Years ago, I heard Rav Noah Weinberg ztz"l repeat a powerful statement made by Rav Elazar Shach ztz"l: "If one man can kill six million Jews, then one man can save six million Jews." If one or two or even 30 ignorant people can shove and put down our fellow Jews right here in New York, then one or two or even 30 of us can uplift and support them. At the gates of Auschwitz, Rav Noah stood with a group of Jewish educators and said: "We're not serious. The Nazis were serious. They didn't stop improving their methods until they were operating at full efficiency. Just as the Nazis were motivated to destroy the Jewish people, we have to be motivated to build the Jewish people."

The worst thing that we can do when we hear about a horrific story like this is nothing. The Jewish families in this rural town should not feel like they are on their own. They're not. I think of the light in my grandmother's eyes. I think of the empty seats at that Holocaust assembly so long ago. And I know, now more than ever, what a gift it is not only to be Jewish but to be proud of who we are. The courage and strength of these families in Pine Bush is an example for all of us. Let's stand by their side.

Please write a comment of support below. They will be forwarded to the Jewish families in the Pine Bush case.

November 11, 2013

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 265

(233) Gitel, July 25, 2017 4:16 PM

Contact The Major News Media

Dear Brothers and Sisters of Pine Bush,
We all need to contact NBC,CBS,,ABC ask if this is ''news worthy''. If some random whale is washed up from the ocean that's ALWAYS news worthy.
It appears that Jews in this day and age are an entity that doesn't exist and therefore are not valued by the major media.
The State of Israel regained our dignity!.
Now it is time for your fellow brothers and sisters here in The USA to help restore The Pine Bush Jewish communities dignity !
Everyone of us needs to contact ::NBC,CBS and ABC !!!

(232) Anonymous, June 19, 2017 5:11 AM

Stay strong!

Stay strong. Our prayers are with you.

(231) Liz Weishaar, June 16, 2017 2:47 PM

I stand with you

You are fighting for what's right and you are setting an excellent example for your children, for your community, and for everyone who hears your story. I wish I were there to help you and your families work against this abuse. I'm far away, but my prayers are with you as you struggle through this painful time.

(230) Lauren Rivka Goldman, January 2, 2017 10:22 AM

Speaking out against anti-Semitism.

I am 71 and grew up in Los Angeles, where there was a whispered anti-Semitism (nothing overt) in the town of my youth. When I moved to the Fairfax neighborhood, in my mid-20s, I came in contact with a number of Holocaust survivors, some with tattoos on their arms. Those who lived in Germany, during the rise of Nazism, told how they adapted to the growing anti-Semitism until the Nuremberg Laws made their future in Germany very clear. Shortly thereafter, escape became impossible. Thanks to the Internet, the world's shifting back to anti-Semitism is becoming clear much sooner than it did in the 1930s. I currently live in San Francisco, and the level of anti-Semitic speech is increasing, so I try to call it out when I hear it. People say things with impunity, against Jews, that would get them challenged if spoken against other groups. As I have heard some of those who survived WWII say, "We have seen this before." Sadly, this is true.

(229) Julius, December 12, 2013 12:50 PM

Come to Des Moines, Iowa

Go ahead, leave that city. Step out on faith, and come to Des Moines (Dee Moin) Iowa. The economy is great and housing is cheap. Let that city suffer the fate of Detroit.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment