click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




The Debate over Jewish Achievement

The Debate over Jewish Achievement

As a non-Jew, I’m fascinated that a people which constitute less than 1% of the world’s population has made such enormous contributions to humanity.

by

Jews have been part of my life in kindergarten, at Harvard Business School, and throughout my professional career. It was from those experiences that I developed the notion that Jews are the world’s most disproportionate high achievers.

A decade ago I began intensive research to test out the hypothesis. Now, after writing The Golden Age of Jewish Achievement, speaking on the subject, being interviewed on radio and TV, and soliciting criticisms and arguments to disprove the statement, I have come to believe it is simply true.

As a non-Jew, I am fascinated by the fact that a people which constitute 2/10ths of 1 percent of the world’s population and 2 percent of the U.S. population, has made such enormous contributions to the betterment of humanity.

To cite some examples: In hi-tech entrepreneurship, Jewish names include: Intel (Grove and Vadasz), Google (Brin and Page), Oracle (Ellison), Microsoft (Balmer), Dell (Dell), Qualcom (Jacobs), Facebook (Zuckerberg and Sandberg).

In finance, the names are legion: Goldman Sachs, Rothschild, Warburg, Kohlberg, Kravis & Roberts, Wells Fargo, Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, and many more.

As World Chess champions, Jews have held the title 54% of the time since 1866.

In the 113th United States Congress (2013-2015), Jews were elected to 11 percent of U.S. Senate seats.

Jews account for three of the nine Supreme Court Justices.

More examples:

Distinction

Expected

Actual

Multiple

% of all

Nobel Prizes

1.8

181

101

23%

History’s Great Inventors (Encyclopedia Britannica)

.6

13.7

22

5%

Ivy League Students

2,380

24,000

10

21%

Ivy League Presidents

.2

4

20

50%

Pulitzer Prize Non-fiction

1

25.5

25

51%

Symphony Conductors

4.2

66

16

33%

Academy Award Directors

1.7

31

18

37%

Forbes 400 (2007)

8.3

126

15

31%

Business Week - Philanthropic 50

1

19

19

38%

Kennedy Center Honors

3.2

41

13

26%

Major Theories

My second book, The Debate over Jewish Achievement, traces major theories to explain this phenomenon. It uses the technique of a Chronology to expose the strengths and flaws of each one over time. In the end the debate over the factors behind the performance boil down to nature (genetics) and nurture (culture).

My research concludes that, yes, genetic heritage and linkages between most of the world’s Jews (the Mizrahim, Sephardim and Ashkenazim) date back thousands of years. But Judaism is not a "race," given that anyone can freely convert, and today you will find Chinese Jews, Ethiopian Jews, etc.

Rather, culture is the most important driving influence behind Jewish achievement. Among elements of that culture:

  • The huge premium Jews have placed on literacy and education for more than 2,000 years. Jews graduate from college at more than twice the national average. They attend the best schools, get better grades and go on to pursue productive careers.
  • Most Jews believe in progress. They are not passive, nor resigned. They think they have a duty to help improve things. They believe in free will and intend to exercise their minds and body to advance the ball in the directions they feel important.
  • Jews have long maintained very strong family values. They divorce less. They are mostly members of two-parent families. The mother is loving, strong, demanding, and supportive. The father is equally engaged. Most religious holiday events, even for secular Jews, are major family events, as is Shabbat (Friday night dinner). Loyalty to family and kin is highly valued.
  • Jewish lifestyle is generally healthy in terms of diet, and the approach to drugs and alcohol is moderate. Kosher conformance has served many purposes, but historically, one of them has been to mandate healthy eating habits.
  • Jews typically demonstrate high levels of self-discipline (deferred gratification). We see it in their diet, their commitment to formal education, their careers, and their drive to achieve.
  • They encourage and develop their verbal skills and the inclination to speak up, make an argument, debate, and disagree if they feel strongly. Generally, reticence has not been esteemed. The Talmud is a religious tract, but it is also essentially an ongoing academic debate over the evolution of Jewish Law in light of changing circumstances.
  • Jews stand up for what they believe in. They have “grit.” They champion causes important to them. Wallflowers they are not!
  • Ethical behavior has been inculcated in Jews by the Torah and Talmud. God demands it.
  • Rationality is also embodied in the Talmud and in the lives of most Jews. One must deal with the facts on the ground and adapt. The Diaspora made anything less than this approach unfeasible. For most of 2,000 years, Jews had to exist as a small minority among other cultures, coexisting with countless other peoples, tribes, and cultures with substantially different beliefs and native languages. Staying alive demanded rationality and adaptability.
  • Jews almost never adopt the mentality of victims deserving of an entitlement. God knows they have more right than most to have taken on that view, but they do not. They do not believe they are entitled. If anything, they help others who are downtrodden.
  • In the same vein, Jews feel a strong sense of duty to each other and to those less fortunate. Jews are among the most charitable and philanthropic of people.

There is nothing unique about any of these cultural attributes. In fact, most of them are consistent with the cultures of other high performing groups of people around the globe. Yet the combination and intensity makes for a uniquely Jewish experience, one that has undeniably produced more "good" far beyond expected norms.

It also demonstrates how more of us can achieve and contribute. We need not have Jewish genes to appreciate and learn from the Jews' stunning performance.

June 13, 2015

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 28

(20) Anonymous, June 27, 2015 8:28 PM

I agree

My parents were very successful people but what they stressed while I was growing up was that it was my job in life to be more successful than they were.!!!

(19) Helen Schwab (Chaiah), June 16, 2015 8:40 PM

Important missing piece:

In the Torah, G-d promised the Jews we would be persecuted but that we would survive b/c He wants us to survive, b/c He chose us to be His emissaries in the world, along with every righteous gentile. It seems to me that all the reasons given by the author are secondary to this.

(18) Inna Belopolsky, June 16, 2015 2:09 PM

Thank you

Mr. Pease, in this political climate, thank you for your courage, your effort and your work in pursuing and sharing your findings about the Jewish people, their general strengths and their contributions throughout history. Perhaps if more people operated out of knowledge instead of fear or ignorance, this world would be a better place for everyone.

(17) Phyllis Sette, June 16, 2015 2:10 AM

I am always proud to learn of one of my people in an impressive position.

I am proud to be Jewish.

(16) Beverly Margolis, June 16, 2015 12:34 AM

Incredible, but true

My sister (half sister) is an atheist. As a Jew, I cannot NOT believe in Hashem, The fact that I know that I am a Jew is all the proof that I need, nothing else.
When people ask me how I know there is a God I merely point to myself and say "I am a Jew, my parents were Jews, and my ancestors were Jews. You carry my genealogy with you to your church. You ought to try reading it sometime."
When a woman in Oklahoma told me that I couldn't be a Jew because I didn't have horns, I collapsed with laughter. She had never met one of us but had seen pictures of "Moses." I explained why they had pictures like that but I don't think she believed me.
How can any Jew not understand that the fact that we live for thousands of year without a country to call our own. The fact that Israel has managed to thwart the Arab's attacks and HOW they did it is, to me, more than enough evidence for our one and only God.
In this day and age it sometimes considered stupid to believe in a God. Yes, the universe is too big to even begin to complicated, but isn't it possible that Hashem created the perfect planet for life? So far, the best scientists have not been able to prove that life exists anywhere else.
Baruch Hashem!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub