click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




The Future of European Jewry

The Future of European Jewry

Those who deny Jews or Israel their freedom will lose, or fail to gain, their own.

by

For the Jews of Europe, these are the best of times and the worst of times. Take British Jewry as an example.

In the past 20 years we have built more Jewish day schools than ever before in our 355-year history. Culturally, a community deemed moribund a generation ago boasts a cultural center, a community center in the making, Jewish Book Weeks, arts, music and film festivals, and an adult-education event – Limmud – that has inspired offshoots in 50 other centers throughout the Jewish world.

Jews have achieved prominence in every field. Both parliamentary speakers, in the Commons and the Lords, are Jewish. We have had, in recent years, two Jewish lord chief justices, Jewish heads of Oxford and Cambridge, a Jewish editor of The Times and Jewish leaders of both the Conservative and Labour parties. Not only are Jews respected, but so is Judaism. The Jewish moral voice has become a significant part of the national conversation.

These are astonishing achievements. But they are clouded by the disturbing phenomenon of a new anti-Semitism spreading like a virus across Europe. This cries out for explanation. After all, after the Holocaust, if there was one thing on which people of goodwill throughout the world agreed, it was: Never again.

The entire post-war culture of the West – of the world – was tilted in that direction. Out of the determination that there should never be another Holocaust came the United Nations’ Declaration of Human Rights, the concept of a “crime against humanity,” the idea that racism is a vice, the movement for interfaith dialogue, and the historic shift in Christianity known as Vatican II, Nostra Aetate.

The new anti-Semitism is only secondarily aimed at Jews as individuals. Its real target is Jews as a nation – in Israel.

How, then, did anti-Semitism return to the very nations that pledged never to repeat it? The cynical answer is that it never died, it merely went underground. There is a shred of truth to this, but very small. As a line of reasoning, it is deeply misleading. For the new anti-Semitism is only secondarily aimed at Jews as individuals. Its real target is Jews as a nation – in Israel.

What has happened in our time is an extraordinarily subtle phenomenon that can only be understood by traveling back two centuries to the age of Enlightenment and the French Revolution. For centuries, Europe had been disfigured by crude, theologically driven Christian anti- Judaism. Jews were accused of poisoning wells, spreading the plague, desecrating the host and killing Christian children.

Jews were not the only victims of the Church; witches and heretics were burned as well. Then, following the Reformation, Christians started killing their fellow Christians in Europe’s great wars of religion.

That was when thoughtful people said, “Enough.” This led to the rise of science, the age of reason, the doctrine of toleration and eventually the emancipation of hitherto disenfranchised minorities, including the Jews. It was the most enlightened age in European history, and it was at this precise time, in Paris, Berlin and Vienna – the most sophisticated centers of all – that a new form of hate was born: racial anti-Semitism. As the deadliest virus the West has ever known, it led otherwise ordinary, decent human beings to do, or remain passive witnesses to, unspeakable acts.

That was not a simple phenomenon. The anti-Semitism of the 19th century was not the crude anti-Judaism of the Church. Similarly, the new anti-Semitism of the 21st century is not the racist anti-Semitism of the 19th and 20th.

It is not directed against individual Jews, but against Jews as a nation. It is not spread by conventional means, but by the new technologies of communication – websites, email, blogs and social networks – that are almost impossible to monitor and control.

Its most brilliant, even demonic, stroke has been to adopt as its most powerful weapons the very defenses created against the old anti-Semitism. It accuses Israel of the five cardinal post-Holocaust sins: racism, apartheid, crimes against humanity, ethnic cleansing and attempted genocide.

It is subtle, sophisticated and devastatingly effective.

It is designed to mislead, and it works. Israelis and American Jews see it as a threat to European Jewry, which it is, but only secondarily. The real target is Israel. It is an attack on Israel where it is most vulnerable, namely among the opinion-forming classes of Europe. If Israel is delegitimized in their eyes, that leaves only America, and the shrewd judgment of Israel’s enemies is that, when it comes to supporting Israel, in the long run America will not go it alone.

This is a chess game more long-term and coldly calculated than people realize. It aims at the destruction of the Jewish state. To counter it requires a coordinated global Jewish response beyond anything thus far envisaged. Nor is it a battle that can be fought by Jews alone. Without allies, Jews and Israel will lose.

This means reframing the argument. Anti-Semitism is always a symptom of something more pervasive, an unresolved tension within a culture that starts by targeting Jews but never stops with them. It was not Jews alone who died at the hands of medieval Christianity, Czarist Russia, Nazi Germany or Stalinist Russia: it was freedom itself.

The same will be true in the 21st century. Those who deny Jews or Israel their freedom will lose, or fail to gain, their own.

The writer has been the chief rabbi of the United Kingdom and Commonwealth since 1991, and a member of the House of Lords since 2009. He will discuss the future of European Jewry alongside a panel of experts later this month at the third Israeli Presidential Conference: “Facing Tomorrow 2011 in Jerusalem.”

Published: June 18, 2011


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 15

(12) Tsivya, July 1, 2011 2:48 PM

Everything is from HaShem

On one level, every explanation about anti-Semitism is is true. On another level, since everything is from HaShem, every attack on Jews is a message from HaShem to draw closer to Him and to cease baseless hatred. Some of our sages are of the opinion that each nation personifies a certain mido and when chlal Yisrael transgresses, the nation with that chate becomes stronger and attacks us. When HaShem chastizes us through the nations some people, like for instance, the Aish Kodesh, grow and become closer to HaShem. But more ordinary people respond with a lessening of faith and say that G*d doesn't exist or G*d doesn't care about us. This is a difficult paradox and I offer it to you as a question.

(11) Grace Fishenfeld, June 23, 2011 1:40 AM

Procedures

It is important to recognize that Faith is not enough. We recognize that our strength has come through trust in a just future. We also understand that Jews stand alone in a hostile world. We are aware of the antagonism against our people. This situation reoccurs in different forms, each generation. Post World War II recognition of the horrors of the Holocaust have diminished. Vatican II, that changed Catholic relationships with Jews is fading and the subject of The Jews, as the Rabbi states, has taken a new form of anti-Semitism. The view of The Jew has become inseparable with the state of Israel. False claims have been made against Israel. Haters accept falsehoods about the nature of Israel's Politics. I They want to delegitimatize Israel's existence. Faith is not enough when one views the political implications. . History has taught us that although we must stand tall, we must also have friends. That does not mean that we invite the fox into the hen house, as we did long ago when a Jewish King invited Rome to help solve a political matter. We need to spread important historic information about the nature of Jewish ethics, its contribution to word thought and if that is too lofty, to recognize that democracy is practiced in Israel, in a area of the world where that concept has not taken hold. We need friends who question the view of those who do not see that Israel must defend its borders and it is done through Israel's ethical rules of war. Life is valued by Jews. Israel does not sacrifice the life of children strapped with bombs, saying they will have glorious lives after death. Israelis fight defensively and do not seek power. Truth, must reach the ears of people who believe reporting of Israeli crimes of genocide and ethnic cleansing. Jewish people must respect each other in support of Israel, Orthodox, Conservative, Reformed, Reconstructonist, Secular. Politics, Faith and Education are the tools to oppose underground anti-Semitism.

(10) Avraham Turetsky, June 21, 2011 10:18 PM

politics, not scholarship: "Without allies, Jews and Israel will lose?"

I agree that among many things the State of Israel needs is better PR agency, but to say that "Without alies, Jews and Israel will lose?" is to deny the miraculous survival of our nation until now and the Divine promise of survival we were given. As for the ultimate success, the Torah assures it to us if we, as a nation, follow the Torah. So, our survival is unconditional and our redemption is contingent upon national allegiance to Torah - but neither is contingent upon courting allies. The Tanach, the Talmud and the subsequent Jewish history is replete with instances of how making alliances had disastrous consequences for us (from Gibeonites, to failing to destroy Canaanites, to joining forces with Idumeans, then Syrian-Greeks, and so on). Moreover, I cannot think of or even imagine a single Torah source that says that the key to our survival or success lies in pursuing allies. So I am very puzzled by Lord Sacks's statement. I must conclude that he's speaking as a politician not as a reliable exponent of our tradition. That's not to say it's not sometimes pragmatic to seek strategic alliances - but it's important to know at what price. Statements like "Without allies, Jews and Israel will lose?", on the other hand, imply that making alliances is the key and the essence of the solution - a view which is evidenced by neither the Torah nor Jewish history, as explained above.

(9) Lee Dimin, June 21, 2011 7:58 AM

Jews in Europe

At the rate this world is attempting to destroy one another, it will be surprising if within the not too distant future there is anything living on planet earth. Mankind has been desrtroying the planet since its arrival, for itself and all other life. Pollution grows, along with its profits and this will eventually end life oin planet Earth. Not even the gentle Apes will be able to rescue it.

(8) Anonymous, June 20, 2011 7:21 AM

I am still shocked that this is an article written by a chief Rabbi

Sorry, but I think we have the right to say that with leaders who believe in what the chief rabbi wrote, who needs enemy's? You have made us so small, in our own eyes... just like the spies from this weeks parasha. I can not understand how aish could have ths article on its exceptional outstanding site. I apologize for any disrespect but certain things must be commented on.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!