click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

UCLA Thought Police

UCLA Thought Police

We need to stand up against attempts to bully and intimidate pro-Israel students on campus.


Student government elections were recently held at UCLA. One would think that the main issues being discussed would focus on tuition rates, student group funding and safety issues on campus, but at UCLA the elections were dominated by a different topic: Israel.

During the elections, anti-Israel students and organizations publicly attacked candidates for participating on the Hasbara Fellowships program to Israel, as well as other programs to Israel organized by pro-Israel and/or Jewish organizations. Hasbara Fellowships brings hundreds of students to Israel each year, giving them an in-depth, first-hand view of the political, strategic, cultural and societal issues in Israel. Students gain the knowledge to return to their campuses as educators about Israel, organizing programs and other initiatives to provide the campus with a more accurate portrayal of the Israeli people, as opposed to the misleading and exaggerated view often communicated by Israel’s detractors.

So what does this have to do with UCLA elections? Acording to anti-Israel students and organizations on campus, any candidate who has participated on Hasbara Fellowships or other named educational programs to Israel, is unfit to represent the UCLA student body. They demanded that all candidates sign a pledge to avoid participating in these programs in the future.

Last week pro-Israel student leaders from Bruins for Israel responded strongly to these efforts. UCLA Chancellor Gene Block and University of California System President Janet Napolitano also issued strong condemnations.

Pressuring candidates to sign this pledge was clearly an attempt to bully and intimidate other students for their political beliefs. It is telling that these groups only targeted pro-Israel and Jewish organizations. This demonstrates that they have no interest in advocating for transparency in student government or any other issue pertaining to the well-being of the general student body. The fact that they only targeted organizations and students that disagree with their political positions clarifies what their true intentions are – to intimidate and bully those that disagree with them.

Additionally, it is offensive that they are publicly stating that intelligent UCLA students lack the ability to think for themselves. Just because one attends an educational program does not mean the individual loses their ability to think critically and act independently. All academic institutions and environments should encourage their students to participate on educational programs and opportunities, not bully and intimidate them into avoiding these opportunities.

Finally, it is laughable that these organizations make accusations against Hasbara Fellowships and other programs for their content and viewpoints. Israel and the world is facing a dangerous ideology of extremist Radical Islam. Radical Islam has caused terrorism and violence across the globe including today in Nigeria, as well as in New York, London, Madrid, Tel Aviv and beyond. It is crucial to educate our program participants and others about this global threat. The fact that these UCLA students and organizations object to this perspective and libel anyone who does speak out about these issues says a lot about what they support and believe in.

It is imperative that students on campuses be supported in their quest to gain a deeper understanding of what is happening in Israel and in the world in general, and any efforts to intimidate students from participating in these opportunities should be revealed for what they truly are – partisan bullying.

BIO: Rabbi Elliot Mathias is the Founder and Executive Director of Hasbara Fellowships, a leading pro-Israel advocacy organization that educates, trains and supports students across North America. Over 3,000 students have participated on Hasbara’s advocacy training program in Israel.

May 20, 2014

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 10

(9) David, May 23, 2014 3:46 PM

Thought Police

Elliot Mathias:

You said: "Additionally, it is offensive that they are publicly stating that intelligent UCLA students lack the ability to think for themselves."

Suppose someone proposed a course or discussion group on a topic that you found offensive, such as "Did the Holocaust really happen?", "Should circumcision of infants be outlawed?", "Should Illegal immigrants be deported?" or "Is homosexual marriage evil?".

Would you still argue that intelligent UCLA students should be allowed to freely discuss the topic and form their own conclusions?

nina, August 9, 2015 9:31 AM

yes,of course!

Why wouldn't you be able to debate these topic? You are at a university, you are there to learn! And it is not the topic that is offensive, it is possibly someone's opinion on it, so debate them! Also baiting questions should be rephrased by the moderator, e.g. 'Is homosexual marriage wrong?" , and 'Should illegal immmigrants be deported?' instead of "Should illegal immigrants be deported or shot?'

(8) Judith Dowla, May 22, 2014 7:58 PM

Respect and Civility

Elliot, thank you for your article on the upswing and downswing at UCLA on trips to Israel. Takes me back to a public school I attended that opened in prayer every day. A student approached the teacher and said we are not allowed to do your prayers. And then asked if they could go to the library. The teacher responded with, 'no you cannot go to the library. You shall remain silent while the rest of the students and others are praying. And so they did do that exactly. That was not the end of it for their parents got upset and went through the school district and got to leave the classrooms that had prayer and were monitored by another teacher in a room away from the rest of those praying.Turned out just perfectly. So be it.

(7) StanleyT, May 22, 2014 5:40 PM

They're running scared

Clearly, these organizations cannot tolerate anyone who actually knows the truth about Israel. They think they can stop educated students from educating fellow students. They're losing the BDS war and now they're losing the free-speech war too. Thank heavens UCLA is actually standing up to them, for once.

(6) Anonymous, May 22, 2014 5:06 PM

We need to prioritize choosing people of high character for positions of authority and influence. That is more important than their qualifications. A person of integrity can choose to listen to the knowledgeable around them, and learn skills needed. But the most knowledgeable or other wise qualified person for an important job can not be counted on to do the right (morally right) thing, no matter how much they know. It's sad, but people of truly good character, in high positions, seem increasingly difficult to find. All I can say is, I hope the people reading this will all try to put character above most all else. And do the morally right thing. We only grow our character when we go beyond our comfort zone. May we each remember to speak up or do something when we see our help is needed.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment