click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

A Shabbat Miracle

A Shabbat Miracle

My father and I had nothing in common besides the long silences that would pass between us. Then a miracle happened.


My father and I have never shared much in our lives. In fact, almost nothing. We're so different that we marvel at the fact that we're related. Over the years we've agreed on one thing and one thing only: baseball. We can talk for hours about baseball, but only a few seconds on any other subject such as work, politics or (God forbid!) religion. That's the way it's always been and I always figured that, barring a miracle, that's the way it would always be.

Maybe it was a miracle that occurred five years ago one winter night.

My father never forgave me for two things: becoming a Republican and becoming an observant Jew.

My wife had just given birth to our first daughter and I wanted my parents, who are in their late 70's, to come to Los Angeles for the baby naming. But I knew this would be an issue. My father has never forgiven me for two things: becoming a Republican and becoming an observant Jew. And I'm not sure which one irks him more.

Still, I wanted him and my mom to be a part of our children's lives as much as possible. One thing I learned as I got a little older is that life is just too short for ridiculous things like family feuds, regardless of who "started it." So, somewhat reluctantly, they came.

Once they arrived at our home, my wife and I tried our best to make them feel comfortable in our "strange" religious world. That's when the first miracle occurred. For the first time my parents noticed that our house looked like most others they'd seen. The food we served tasted familiar too ― the chicken tasted like chicken and the bread tasted like bread. For the first time, they began to see us as people like them instead of some kind of misdirected religious nuts.

But the relationship between my father and me did not change. Still nothing in common. Still nothing to talk about. Long silences passed between us. Or worse ― my dad would lapse into one of his "golden oldies" ― lecturing me about what he thinks I should be doing with my life and what I'm currently doing wrong.

Then came Friday night.

I asked my father if he wanted to come to shul with me. I told him that this was a special night as I had learned how to lead the afternoon prayer service in Hebrew in honor of the birth of our daughter and would be leading it for the first time. He agreed to come.

Leading the service went well. I felt exuberant that I had learned something that had earlier seemed impossible, having never learned Hebrew growing up. More than that, I felt tremendous joy and deep emotion knowing that my father was here to see it. He kept flashing in my mind while I was up at the bima leading the service. I so wished that I could tell him how much he meant to me despite all our differences, despite all the water under the bridge. I wanted him to know that my becoming religious wasn't a failure on his part, but a tremendous success. I wanted him to know that after all is said and done he's my dad and I love him and am proud of him.

After the service ended and the handshaking was over, my father and I left the shul and began the walk home. A palpable silence ensued. A wave of sadness overtook me thinking how I would probably never get to tell him all of those things that flashed in my mind while up at the bima. At least not in this life. Just as I was about to bring up how the Giants were playing better than the Dodgers these days, my father turned to me and spoke.

"You did a fine job tonight, son. I'm proud of you."

I was stunned. "Thanks, Dad. I did make a couple of mistakes, though," I replied. "Yes you did," he continued, "but overall, it was a fine job. I had no idea you could read Hebrew that well!"

The silence between us was suddenly broken and in a way it had never been broken before. We started talking about all the things we never talk about. He asked about how I learned Hebrew so well and I told him I did it pretty much on my own. He said he wished he had learned it better in his life. The conversation soared from there. We talked and laughed as we walked home. At times it felt like we were father and son who had everything in common and other times it felt like we were just two good friends enjoying a walk and conversation on a Shabbat evening. It was like nothing that ever transpired between us before.

But, as the saying goes, all good things must come to an end and as we approached my street, I knew that this good thing would, unfortunately, be no different. Once again sadness overtook me.

Just as I was starting to lament the impending loss of this magical time, my father turned to me and said, "You know, Ross, I don't agree with everything you believe in, but I think in the long run what you're doing, how you're going to raise your child and how you're living is the right thing to do."

We stood, eyes locked on each other, saying all those things we've always wanted to say to one another.

He looked down at the sidewalk. I sensed a melancholy in him as well. Perhaps a reflection on time lost, opportunities missed. All of those arguments between us that were such a waste of precious time. I don't know. Then, he looked up and smiled at me. I smiled back. There we stood ― eyes locked on each other, smiling. Somehow, that was all it took to say all those things we both wanted to say to one another. For once, it felt like we understood each other.

The Jewish sages say that the more you look for God in your life, the more He will reveal himself to you. And the more you look for miracles, the more you will see them. I saw one of God's miracles that night on the way home from shul. And I saw God's hand in the miraculous meeting of the minds that my father and I had that night, even if for a brief few moments. And for that, I will be eternally grateful.

My father and I had never had a conversation like that before nor have we had one since. But that fact that we did at all proves to me that God exists, that He truly loves us and that He can make anything happen at any time if you reach out to Him.

May 15, 2004

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 27

(27) Anonymous, August 3, 2011 8:24 PM


that was so beautiful and inspiring leaving me welled up with tears!!

(26) Anonymous, December 21, 2004 12:00 AM

I wish I could have a conversation like that with my dad.


What a gift! What a truly miraculous gift!
I immediately identified with Ross because my own dad resents the fact that I have become observant of the laws of the Jewish faith. He is 90 now and living an expensive plane ride away from me. It's too late for me to have a heart-to-heart with him because he's recently undergone some serious surgery, and he may never be up to such a conversation. Over the years I have begged him to talk to me, to clear the air, and he has refused. So, I have resigned myself to doing the mitzvahs without ever hearing my dad say, "Good job" - ever. However,just before my dad went in for that very serious surgery I mentioned earlier, I gave my sister(who lives near Dad) a message to give him. She couldn't give it to him, as it turns out, but the next day I gave it to his nurse. This was the message:
"Thank you, Dad, for all the Torah you taught me. You are the reason I am a frum woman today. I love you, and I'm glad that you're my father."
The nurse, a non-Jew, was touched. When I asked her the next day what my father's reaction to the message was, she told me he had tears in his eyes.
I guess that's the closest I'll ever come to having a "miracle" conversation with my dad.

(25) Stewart Ratzker, December 20, 2004 12:00 AM

Ross's story was very sad

I enjoyed reading Ross's story about his relationship with his father and at the same time I found it rather sad relationships between father's and sons are offen not easy and yet it is always worth it to make the effort.

Clearly by Ross's story there was a lot that was not said or told in the tale. As hard as it is for a child when he becomes more observant than his parents it is equally hard on the parents.
If you believe in the Torah you have to find a way to practice honering you parent as you embrace Hashem and our laws. Its never easy but you always have to do what ever you can to brigde the gaps that you yourself create, as a child even if you are going the right thing.

One of the saddest thing about you story was that is seamed that you could have allow the opertunity to be missed and it was the fact that you father reached out to you that was your miricle. If you and your father are alive and healthy it is your reponciblity to reach out to him no matter how he reacts becuase in all reality his oppertunitys get fewer and fewer as time goes by, and you miss so much because of it. Well your miracle happened he reach out to you now its your turn good luck

(24) Henry Coston, December 19, 2004 12:00 AM

WOW, what truth!!!

Thank you for an amazing Article that has put to words many of my own emotions in my relationship with my father. Giving me hope and the desire to be more accepting of our relationship, even though not being the ideal,that moments such as these be treasured.

(23) Anonymous, December 19, 2004 12:00 AM

opposite situation - found interesting

Ross - I was forwarded your article today and felt compelled to respond. I was extremely fascinated by the similiar-yet-opposite situation I am in with my own parents. My parents are Baalei Teshuva and I am not observant. We clashed about 5 years ago on this topic where my dad could not handle that I am not an observant Jew like he is. He (along with my Mom) have not spoken to me since then. I have no issues with their religious observance and have expressed that many times; I just dont understand it nor feel there is any emotion involved in observant Judaism and live a different lifestyle than them. It hurts them to see their son living a non-religious lifestyle, but it hurts me more to be rejected by parents for not living the lifestyle they choose.

I was fascinated by your article as it seem to have evoke emotion (i always felt religious judaism was of the mind, and not the heart) and felt quite good about reading your article.

Interesting how I, in the opposite situation as yours, was able to relate on the same level.

Wishing you much luck and success in continuing a special bond with your dad.


See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment