click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

The Chanukah Question

The Chanukah Question

Is it a Jewish value to yield or to resist?


The El Al security official at the L.A. airport eyed my mother-in-law suspiciously. She couldn't imagine what the problem was. The security official looked hard at my mother-in-law, studied her passport, looked up again at her face, gazed down again at her passport, and finally called over his colleague.

"Look at this woman," he commanded. "Her passport says she is almost 90 years old. Can that be true?"

Like the El Al security official, I have always been perplexed by my mother-in-law, Evelyn.

Visiting Jerusalem at the age of 88, she made daily pilgrimages to the Western Wall, trekking up 135 steps. Even while celebrating her 90th birthday this week, she still walks with a bounce in her stride.

Even more mystifying is her universal popularity. Everyone she meets -- no matter how distant from her in age, geography, or background -- adores Evelyn. This includes: her young Persian neighbors; my religious friends; the Hispanic plumber and his wife; the single, 40-something daughter of her best friend; and a young Israeli mother in Austin, Texas, who met Evelyn five years ago and continues to call her every Friday to wish her "Good Shabbos."

One Sunday Evelyn didn't answer the phone when we expected her to be home. "I was at a graduation," she explained the next day. "It was the son of this big Italian family. I was the only non-relative invited."

What is the secret of my mother-in-law's universal popularity?


Recently, at a class on the mitzvah of lighting Shabbat candles, I discovered the answer.

Many Jewish women follow the custom of lighting one Shabbat candle for every member of her family, honoring not only Shabbat, but every member of the family.

Honoring other people is a core value in Judaism. Ethics of the Fathers, our 2,000-year-old guide to interpersonal relationships, proclaims: "Let the honor of your student be as dear to you as your own, the honor of your friend like the honor of your Rabbi, and the honor of your Rabbi as much as the honor of Heaven." As for marriage, the Talmud directs: "A man should love his wife as much as he loves himself, and honor her more than himself."


Take a step back and allow another's reality to prevail.


How does one actually honor other people? The key is to validate their reality. Usually our own reality is so intrinsic to us that we dismiss other people's reality as insignificant, flawed, or warped. To take a step back and allow another's reality to prevail permits the other to feel his/her own importance. This is the essence of giving honor.

And this is why everyone loves Evelyn: she honors them by validating their reality. When she is with the family of her eldest son Bob, who moved to San Francisco in the 60s and joined the counter-culture, she appreciates their life style, the quaintness of their Mill Valley home with its hot tub, and her daughter-in-law's talents in making pottery and jewelry. When she is with her second son Leib Yaacov in Jerusalem, she embraces our religious ways and admires our choices. When her youngest son Jamie, who heads a foundation for the arts, takes her to a formal dinner honoring Pavarotti, she enjoys the elegance of the event, hobnobs with the stars, and appreciates Jamie's kindness in bringing her. No wonder everyone adores her!

Such validation requires much yielding of one's own propensities and choices, and poses a challenge to the ego. It would require a physicist to validate the reality of his teenage son who gets bad grades in science and who spends his evenings strumming his guitar. It would require a wife who's an expert at multi-tasking to have patience for her husband who can't be left to both take care of the kids and remember to take the roast out of the oven on time.


Validating another's reality is the key to honoring others, which is the key to peace in the home and is the inner depth of the mitzvah of lighting Shabbat candles.

How different are the candles of Chanukah! Chanukah is the holiday of standing up boldly for your beliefs, of not yielding an inch.

Chanukah commemorates the historical victory of the Maccabees over the Greeks. The Jewish rebellion started in the year 167 B.C.E., after a century of Greek cultural hegemony and increasing assimilation. In the village of Modiin, Greek forces commanded the Jews to make offerings to a pagan god. One submissive Jew complied. This so enflamed the elderly priest Mattathias that he sprang up, killed the servile Jew, and led his five sons and handful of followers into the hills for a protracted guerilla war against the Greeks and their Hellenistic Jewish cohorts.

The message of Chanukah is: Hold onto your religious convictions, never submit to the assimilated majority, no matter how numerous or sophisticated they are, and fight for your ideals.

So which is the Jewish value: to yield or to resist?

The salient difference between the lights of Shabbat and the lights of Chanukah are their location. Shabbat candles are always lit inside the home. Chanukah candles should ideally be lit outside, by the entrance to the house. (This is how we still do it in Jerusalem.) Only when the Jews were exiled to the Diaspora did safety dictate moving the Chanukah lights inside, but even there they are to be kindled in a window where they can be seen from outside. The mitzvah of lighting the Chanukah candles is to publicize the miracle of the oil.

While the Shabbat candles illumine the private domain of the home, the Chanukah candles are a statement to the public domain.


Yield in the home, but stand up and fight in the public realm.


Similarly, the place for yielding is in the home, within the family. The place for standing up for one's convictions is the public realm.

Unfortunately, we often reverse the two: A Jewish college student who is afraid to stand up to his politically correct friends and defend Israel refuses to yield to his mother's entreaties to wear a tie to his grandparents' anniversary party. A Jewish woman who sits mutely during coffee break while her co-workers joke about "cheap Jews," finds her tongue and waxes eloquent in her self-defense when her husband asks her to put the kids to bed on time.

The place to stand up for your beliefs is the public realm. In the home, yield, yield, yield.

If you are chronically tardy, and your spouse likes to arrive everywhere 15 minutes early, yield. Ask yourself, "What is his/her reality?" and validate it.

If you are a spendthrift and your spouse is frugal, yield. Ask yourself, "What is his/her reality?" and validate it.

If your idea of a vacation is a five-star hotel, and your children want to vacation in the national parks, ask yourself, "What is their reality?" and validate it. Then decide what is best for the whole family.

But in the public realm, when Judaism, Jews, or Israel are under attack, stand up and fight! That's the lesson of Chanukah.

Happy 90th birthday, Mom!


Sara Yoheved Rigler’s all-encompassing online marriage program, “Choose Connection: How to Revive and Rejuvenate Your Marriage” is available to readers at a special price. Click here for more info:

August 5, 2012

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 39

(39) John, December 8, 2007 2:21 PM

love the article

I have experienced the union of yielding to others in my home. This type of thought has made my life fruitful. Thank You!

(38) yehuda, December 6, 2007 5:41 PM


in all due respect-that we should stand up for what we think can't always be true-if another jew -in public- especialy greater than ourselves differs in opinion and even if not greater than ourselves -we need to seriously consider their viewpoind and "validate " their viewpoint before we fight and destroy; in a similar vein if family members go against the religion we need to fight even at home-eg. the leveeyeem in the episode of egel.
freileche chanuka.

(37) leib, December 6, 2007 2:27 PM

what she says makes sense

yes, I would aggree, ut to me there is two ways to understand what youre saying either u could be saying always ask whats going on or you could be saying ignore people and dont get involved. either way i agree so you are a true mother of zion.

(36) Penny, December 5, 2007 8:36 PM

A woman that can touch lives with words

I really appreciated what this writer had to say. I wish I could run into more people like her when I am walking around the Old City.

(35) Lesley Levy Hubbard, December 4, 2007 9:10 PM

Sara says it all!

Sara tells it like it is. I will not just sit there and cringe while someone makes fun or jokes about Judiasm.
Sadly, some of the worst offenders are secular Jews who realy should have more sense than to spout off in public about what they don't like about being Jewish - especially when so many goyim who are already antisemitic can hear and disrespect us even more than they already do. After all, if we can't or won't defend outselves, who will?

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment