click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Haman's Voice Within

Haman's Voice Within

According to Haman, Brooks Conrad is a total failure, and so are you.


It wasn’t supposed to end this way. Brooks Conrad had worked way too hard for way too long to go down in history for something like this.

The Atlanta Braves were hosting the San Francisco Giants for Game Three of the 2010 National League Divisional Playoff series. With two outs in the 9th inning, the score tied and the winning run in scoring position, the San Francisco Giants’ Buster Posey hit a routine grounder directly to the Braves’ second baseman Brooks Conrad.

Braves’ fans held their breath. The rookie second baseman had already committed two costly errors that night. It was impossible to imagine that one player could so single-handedly ruin an entire season – until the ball bounced under his glove and through his legs, allowing the winning run to score. “It’s completely embarrassing. I feel absolutely terrible right now,” he said after the game. “I wish I could just dig a hole and go to sleep in there.”

So did Braves’ fans.

It was quite the unfortunate end to what otherwise would have been considered a fairytale rookie season. “Clutch Conrad,” as his teammates lovingly dubbed him, was not your everyday rookie: He was 30 years old on Opening Day.

Brooks spent nine years chasing his dream in the minor leagues, watching teammate after teammate get the call before him. Most players give up at a certain point, recognizing with each passing year the significantly decreasing chances of making it to the Big Leagues. But Brooks Conrad is a fighter. He plays with tremendous heart and passion.

And when he finally got his shot, he made the most of it. He led the Braves both in batting average with runners in scoring position, and in what’s known as “close-and-late situations” (at bats in the last three innings of a close game). He hit seven home runs in the 7th inning or later and was tied for the League lead for pinch-hit RBIs. He was involved in some of the most memorable Braves’ victories, including five game winning home runs, two of them pinch-hit grand slams. His teammates and fans loved the excitement and intensity he brought to every game.

But as Spring Training for the next season commences and Brooks Conrad steps out onto the practice fields of Champion Stadium in Orlando, Florida, the question remains: What will define the past season? Will it be the horrific conclusion, the glaring and embarrassing public failures in the national spotlight, or the realization of a decade of work, successfully contributing to a Major League team?

Related Article: Jews Don't Bow

Worth Nothing

Haman came from a humble background. The Medrash records that he was once so poverty stricken that he sold himself as a slave to Mordechai. But he rose through the ranks and eventually made it all the way to the top, appointed as Second in Command of the entire Persian Empire. Upon the king’s command, the entire land would bow before him wherever he would go.

Everyone that is, except for Mordechai. This one Jew refused to bow. And that angered Haman to no end; he simply could not tolerate it. Haman's plan to eradicate the entire Jewish nation was accepted by the king. But before the big day arrived, he was invited to a special party with the king and queen. And as he walked out of the palace following the party — feeling on top of the world — he ran into his nemesis Mordechai, upright as ever, refusing to bow.

One can only imagine the anger and frustration Haman must have experienced, simultaneously feeling so powerful, yet so invalidated by this Jew’s refusal to bow down. How dare you?! he must have been screaming to himself.

Yet the words that actually came out of his mouth at that moment are simply astounding: “All of this is worth nothing to me so long as I see Mordechai the Jew sitting at the king’s gate!” (Esther 5:13)


It’s the tunnel vision that allows a single failure to overshadow numerous accomplishments,

Haman had it all - power, prestige, honor, wealth and children. He had personal parties with the king and queen. The entire empire bowed before him. And all of that was worth nothing? Haman forged a far more destructive path than simple anger or frustration when things do not go right. He negated the things that he did have because of the things he didn’t have.

We all have a voice of Haman within us. It’s the voice that desires to minimize and ignore real and valid accomplishments because we didn’t achieve our ultimate goal. It’s the attitude that says hard earned victories weren’t worth the effort because we fell short at the end. It’s the tunnel vision that allows a single failure to overshadow numerous accomplishments, or a single offensive incident to throw away years of friendship. “All of this was worth nothing.”

It’s the voice that tells us Brooks Conrad should be thrown out of Atlanta for his miserable playoff performance, despite his invaluable contributions along the way.

Haman speaks that way. The Torah doesn’t.

Life is full of ups and downs, successes and failures. We commit to not yell at our kids, to refrain from speaking gossip during a specific hour during the day, to eat right. Everything is great for a week, and then we fail. Those are the Haman moments. The Haman voice within us says to forget it, to give up, that the whole thing wasn’t worth it anyway. It’s the voice that focuses on the failure, on what we don’t have, rather than on the success that led up to that moment.

The only tragedy of the Brooks Conrad story would be if it concluded with his decision to throw in the towel and hang up his cleats. A decade of hard work and achievement cannot be defined or overshadowed by one bad night.

In fact, our failures can be utilized to accomplish the exact opposite of the Haman voice: Take the time to look back, reflect, and celebrate the success you had until that point…and then start again.

March 7, 2011

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 5

(4) Anonymous, March 16, 2011 4:15 PM

Very encouraging

This is a wonderful, inspiring message that can be applied to our daily efforts to improve ourselves.

(3) Anonymous, March 15, 2011 5:15 PM

superbly written with insight and sensitivity, while focusing on positive which builds instead of negativity which destroys the human spirit.

(2) ruth housman, March 14, 2011 7:52 PM

The lessons of Purim

The lessons of Purim are many, and we have our good guys and our very clearly defined bad guys. It's a story of good triumphing over evil minded Haman. it's also a story that is deeply plumbing identity, as we celebrate it here, in the wearing of masks, in the endeavor to play the parts, even the evil bad guy. What is identity? Who are we? Do we change roles as we negotiate life? We certainly do present different faces to each other, depending on who we are contacting, and why, and we do deeply know, who we can talk to about our innermost thoughts, and who we cannot confide. We know who will make fun of us, and who will deeply listen. We wear many hats in this life, and we have an ongoing spiritual quest, Who are we? Where did we come from? Where are we going? An echo of the questions posed by a Gauguin in his most famous painting. To examine Purim is to see the purity of Esther, yes, the PURE, that echo of pure in the name itself, as we pronounce it. And to look at this story, its massive permutations and combinations is to see within, the obvious HAND of G_d. Why is it we're not looking into the events that do inform all of our lives, as did Rabbi Blech on reflection in the article on Aish. How quickly we move on and forget the insights on our own pages. why is this? Why aren't we looking at synchronicity, and saying, I see a story that only the Divine could have constructed, involving both the bad, and the good, and an obvious learning curve within, that is entirely about tikkun olam? Maybe this would catapult a different way of viewing the story of the Middle East and ALL the players in this story, and how we are moved, and being moved? For me the logic is inescapable.

MABSH"Y, March 16, 2011 4:48 PM

Ruth, you are on to something

Ms. Housman, I've never thought about it that way -- but you are right. That's the mindset of the Arab League -- "we have 21 countries, 355 million people, a gross domestic product of 2.75 trillion dollars, more than 700 billion barrels of oil reserve, heads of state in our thrall, and all of it means nothing when we see Israel in our midst.

(1) Robert and Jan, March 13, 2011 4:21 PM

You are the best!

Rabbi Y, You continue to make us so proud! Love fro m Eretz Yisrael

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment