click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Praying After the Death of My Son

Praying After the Death of My Son

An open letter to Sheryl Sandberg.


Dear Sheryl,

Your new book Option B has opened the conversation for thousands about the way to respond to tragedy and heartache after the loss of a loved one. In a matter of a few weeks you have created a space on Facebook for thousands who have endured the pain of loss and have provided countless individuals with support and a place to feel embraced. You have taken a topic that is often considered taboo and have brought it to the forefront of public discourse.

On-line and in interviews you have been asked the question, “What gives a person the strength to go on? How can we build resilience to cope with the loss of a husband, a wife, a parent, a brother, a sister, a son or daughter?”

My four-year-old son passed away suddenly. On that Wednesday afternoon my wife had brought my son Elisha to the store and bought him a skateboard that he had been asking for. They came home. Together with my other children they were all playing in the living room. Elisha stopped breathing and passed out.

The doctors are not sure what happened. They tried to revive him but they could not. We buried Elisha in Israel. We flew over and placed his small body wrapped in simple white linen in the holy soil of the land on a rainy and cold night in February. A son who I had played with and carried in my arms a day earlier I had now placed in the ground.

We flew back directly following the burial and arrived for the morning service in our home where we would sit shiva. As I was praying I noticed that on the bottom of my pants legs there were mud stains from the wet dirt around the grave at the burial.

I looked up from staring at my pants and continued to pray. On that excruciating morning, I remember coming upon words in the prayer book that I said thousands of times before. But now these words would have a whole new meaning.

In the Amida prayer, the main prayer Jews recite three times a day, we affirm that God is the God who brings back those who have passed away to life again.

Jews believe that we will physically be reunited with our loved ones again here on this earth.

One of the greatest Jewish thinkers of all time, Moses Maimonides, known in Hebrew as the Rambam, counted this belief to be a critical principle of faith. To live a full Jewish life, from Maimonides’ perspective, means to incorporate this article of faith within one’s belief system. There is more to anticipate beyond what we know of this world. We will physically be reunited with our loved ones again here on this earth. This belief is not referring to a heavenly reunification. We believe that there will be a ‘real life’ existence again.

The experience of loss is heartbreaking and frightening. It is traumatic. Judaism offers multiple approaches that attempt to deal with the devastation of death. There is no answer that alleviates the pain when a precious life has been taken from us.

This unique spiritual perspective, namely that we will one day reunite with our loved ones - and the outright rejection that our lives are simply snuffed without any future - may help ground us and provide a modicum of comfort. As we begin to reconstruct our lives, this singular brick of faith may best be utilized as a foundation stone as we begin to forge ahead and endeavor to rebuild and restore our shattered lives.

My nine-year-old son has asked me more than once if he will ever see his brother again. Without hesitation I answer him, yes. I say to him that we believe that those that have left this world will one day be brought back to us. This answer brings him solace and comfort.

When our children learn this genuine Jewish belief, it conveys to them that the crucial message that our lives matter; they matter to such a degree that our lives continue to endure even beyond this world. We as Jewish parents have always instilled in our children optimism and have taught them to never give up and anticipate a brighter day that will surely come.

On those dark and desolate nights when we sit alone in our heartache, we may choose to reach out for this precious gem of faith. May it find the right place in our hearts. May we hear it whispering to us, Don’t despair, remain strong, don’t surrender, always remain hopeful.

Sheryl, you have done a remarkable mitzvah. You have taken your pain and have used your experience to help lessen the pain of others who have endured similar suffering.

All of us who are on this road know that the road to resilience is a painful one. It is an uneven road with many jagged rocks and sharp edges. As we travel on this demanding journey, in our spiritual inner world, we are the beneficiaries of an enduring promise, a promise made to each of us: Our loved ones are not lost forever. Our loved ones will be with us again. The world will be made right.

Aaron Goldscheider
Director, In Our Hearts

May 6, 2017

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 9

(9) Anonymous, May 28, 2017 2:50 AM

I could not agree more. I lost my father suddently 3 months ago and although it is very hard to come to grips with this new reality the thing that really keeps me staying positive is the fact that i KNOW (don't just believe) that we will be reunited and see each other what we daven for should be very soon. It has left me thinking a lot about how depressing it must be for those who unfortunately have not seen the truth and do not believe in olam haba and techiyas hameisim. What exactly are you working towards and for if all we have is our short time in this world? Are the relationships with our loved ones really limited to just the few years that we share in this world together? I truly do feel bad for those who have not had the privilege to discover the beauty and sensitivty of yiddishkeit.

(8) Meyer, May 15, 2017 2:21 PM


Dear Rabbi Goldcsheider and Family:
Your precious Elisha reflected the family's tremendous love that he felt. Elisha "left" suddenly. So that NO ONE in the family would say, what if: the ambulance would have come sooner, we knew CPR, etc.

(7) Anonymous, May 14, 2017 10:37 PM

Comments on Sandberg's book

Ms. Sandberg's story and journey is one that displays resilience but somehow I cannot identify with her situation. If I had her personal financial success, I would have shared my story with no thought of selling it. Must we put a price tag to everything we do in life? Many people out there have had multiple losses - death of a loved one, financial bankruptcy loss of social position and old age security. They are the silent ones who truly suffer on so many levels yet they go on living- these are the untold stories I want to hear.

(6) Rena Rotenberg, May 14, 2017 2:29 PM

death of a child

Yesterday, was the yahrzeit of my daughter, Naomi Tova, who died many years ago, a victim of a Jewish genetic disease, familial dysautonomia; in speaking about her and her very short life, I tell all who listen and hear my words, that if they know someone who has lost a child, mention is to be made of the child/name. Even if the person hearing this cries, knowing that someone remembers the child, acknowledges that the child existed.
I hope, for these bereaved parents (we are an enormous group) that they talk about Elisha with others, siblings, etc. It is somehow comforting for the bereaved family.

(5) Nancy Silverberg, May 12, 2017 1:55 AM

My heart pours out to you and your family

I am so sad reading this and my heart puts out to you and your family ! May little Elisha Rest In Peace in the beautiful land of Israel , may Hashem bless you and your family and bring peace to your hearts .

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment