click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

The Day My Brother Died

The Day My Brother Died

Ten years after her brother was killed in an auto accident, a young woman reflects back on what she learned.

by Deborah

It happened in South Africa. Haley's Comet was in the sky, and our whole family (five of us) plus an aunt and two cousins went camping to a park in the north to get the best view. We were all in a mini van.

The holiday was glorious, and my brother, who was 11, said to my mom at the end, "I've had such a good time. I've never been so happy."

On the way home, we were traveling across soft sand dunes, singing, having a wonderful time. My mom was driving. Eventually I fell asleep.

Suddenly the van started swerving, a tire blew, and my mom lost control. The van flipped over and rolled. There were no seat belts in the van, so we all tumbled over one another.

Someone said, "Is everyone okay?" And we began to step out.

I was the first to see my brother. The van had impacted his head. He had died immediately. My mother became hysterical.

We didn't know what to do. We were in the middle of nowhere. My dad suggested we try and lift the van, but it was a fruitless suggestion. I was so disturbed. Was he really dead?

From somewhere came another van, and we all got in. Someone stayed behind to stay with my brother. The hardest thing was getting in the van and leaving him. We were silent. I knew he was dead. I felt sick, cold, disbelief. My mom had to be sedated. None of the rest of us were hurt except for my cousin, who broke his collarbone.


I began to have flashbacks and horrible feelings of guilt. When my brother was alive, I used to hang out with the girl cousins and shut him out. We thought we were so cool. We just tolerated him. Any time I was mean or bossy to him came back.

Friends flew us back home in their airplane. There was an icy feeling as we entered the house. Everything felt cold. The shiva was a blur. I remember covering the mirrors, lots of people, lots of food. I was in a cold daze for a day or so -- weird, detached.

After two days, friends of my parents took us for two hours to their home to play with their kids. I didn't like their kids, and I didn't want to be there. When I got home, I hid in my mom's room. She found me crying hysterically.

We all slept in the same room for nights. I remember waking up to my mom crying. It was hard seeing my parents completely upset. It was an intangible feeling -- my pillars were no longer there. They were suffering, and who could take care of them?

My parents were completely upset; my pillars were no longer there.

The shiva process is good because it forces you to be personally involved. The family is involved in the reality, and the support is there. It makes you confront it all -- you're sitting, not distracted. That's why you're there. I see the value in it now, but at the time it was hard.

I remember someone saying at the shiva, "You must be strong for your mom." Yes, I must be, but I'm not feeling strong for myself.

I felt sorry for my dad. People kept telling him to be a man and be strong for his wife.

Other stupid things people said:

- "Check your mezuzot"
- "At least you have two other kids."

People kept telling my mom to eat. Leave her alone! I learned that when you’re around mourners, if you don't know what to say, say nothing. But I can empathize. You would think that I would know better what to say now, but I don't.


I was angry with God. I didn't doubt my belief or question my Jewishness, but I just couldn't understand why something so horrible could happen.

My parents joined a bereavement group, which really helped them. They had groups for siblings, but I said, "No!"

The hardest part was not being able to talk to my parents. There was so much pain in their eyes. If they would bring him up, I would cringe because even though I wanted to keep his memory alive, I wanted my connection to be private. As I get older, I can talk about it to my parents more.

The most meaningful thing was when friends would say: I miss him, too.

Afterward, some of my parent's friends pretended he never existed, and that was wrong. The most meaningful thing to my mom was when friends would say, "I miss him, too."

He was a bright and wonderful person, intelligent, with special energy -- the most like my mom. It is beyond belief what she had to go through. After all, she was driving when it happened. There were times she didn't want to get out of bed, but she had a family who needed her.

At the unveiling of the tombstone, I felt very connected to him. Actually I felt that way right after he died. I would talk to him, sense his presence. There were many times later that I felt he was watching over me. I feel looked after, protected. Things have fallen into place in my life so smoothly that it's not even logical.

At different times I've had different understandings of what is spiritual. I believe sometimes that souls can connect.

Because he is buried in South Africa, I don't get to visit his grave often. But I remember going there after a few years and thinking of the sense of lost potential. "He'd be 22 now," I thought, even though I knew he wasn't meant to live beyond 11. But it feels like a loss. Reality is weird. Time and defense mechanisms can blur and protect, but when you're standing at a grave, it's very, very real.

I have a strong sense that there is a greater plan, that it couldn't have been prevented. But why him? Why someone with such potential to the world and to those around him? It's hard to fathom. You just don't know -- can't understand.


The whole experience changed my life. I know I'm a completely different person than I would otherwise have been. I don't focus on trivial things. My teenage years were more serious, and I have chosen to work as an occupational therapist with people who are dying. I think it's because losing my brother made dying less scary. It's hard to explain. I'm also a better sister to my other brother.

I think because I had to think about death so young that I am less scared of dying. People don't face it until they're older. It became so real to me so young that it's part of the cycle. It's normal to die.

I had to attend a funeral of a patient I had gotten close to. It was not a Jewish funeral, so there was an open casket. I looked at her body, and it wasn't her. She looked empty -- like a vessel. Her spirit was who she was. The separation of body and soul are so strong.

It made me understand why we don't bring flowers to a gravesite. We don't try and beautify it because we are not visiting the person. We leave a stone to say we were there. It's a beautiful thing. When I'm actually doing that I feel connected to the soul.

I always believed in life after death and another world. I didn't know what Judaism believed. I knew very little about my own religion. Most Jews seem the same way. We know about every "ism" except Judaism.

On the Jewish holidays at the Yizkor service, I feel really good. It's a special time. I like taking time to fully concentrate. Even in my youth when I was anti?Judaism, it still felt right to do it.

I feel farthest away from him when I'm living my life superficially.

I feel close to him at different times. My brother looks a lot like him, so I sense that part of the brother I lost lives on in the brother I have. I also feel close when I light a Yartzeit memorial candle. And when things are hard or I'm confused, I feel his presence. I get that "guardian angel" feeling.

I feel farthest away from him when I'm living my life superficially, coasting, getting caught up in things that aren't meaningful.

My brother loved cricket and had memorized statistics and scores of hundreds of games, even though he didn't play himself. So my parents established an award that is given at his school for kids who aren't necessarily athletic but make an effort.

I remember the feeling of terror that my other brother wouldn't reach the age of Bar Mitzvah. He did, but the celebration was bittersweet. It was hard for my mom. But we didn't ignore our loss and spoke about him throughout the day.

When people ask how many siblings I have, I always say, "One." After all, at what point in a relationship or friendship do you bring it up? Anybody who is close to me knows. It's a big part of who I am, and people have been so good about it.


Excerpted from "Remember My Soul," by Lori Palatnik, Leviathan Press



July 7, 2001

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 133

(115) Charlene Kez, May 29, 2017 1:38 AM

This resonates with me.

Everything in this story happened to me too. Though he was 12 and died of a sudden illness. i always think 'He'd be 18 now" and sadly its 6 years after and it hurts almost as much as it was back then. Like i feel guilty cos i used to shove him away. Now i wish I;d done better, I knew he loved me though, he told me a coulpe of times. I have a younger brother now who is 2 and when i look at him, it gives me a painful kind of hope and now I've been trying to be a much better sister to him. Like you said, I hate it when people want to act like he never existed, it just makes me so mad and angry. When people ask how many siblings i've got it just makes me sad by default. Cos we were two before then just me and then years laater another little brother, but in all of this, I've developed a very tough skin/heart cos i had to be strong for my parents. It's a terrible feeling watching your parents cry and you can't do nothing to soothe their pain/agony. To me, life lost it's value and at the same time made me value every moment of life whiile the whole dying process no longer frightening me. I look at dead bodies/people and I feel little or nothing. I mourn him by wearing black on his birth day and death day every year, most people say i haven't moved on but i don't care. They can never understand what he meant to me. Today's his birthday and i found this site while surfing around for people with similar experiences. Thank you for this!

(114) Anonymous, December 29, 2015 2:35 AM

what happened?

My brother was nodding off after dinner but this time he looked a little sick, he went home to rest. The next day he was confused acting and my sister made him go to hospital where they admitted him immediately and was scheduled for surgery the next morning to relieve pressure, he had blood on the brain. After 35 minutes of surgery he wasn't waking up, his brain was swelling, a second procedure was done. The next day, after a brain scan, we were told that he was brain dead. He was going to retire in one month after 35 years on the job. It was totally unexpected and we are in shock to lose him, my elderly father is blaming the hospital but I'm wondering if brain swelling is a possibility, why weren't preparations made, I've heard that part of the skull can be sawed away to give brain place to swell, or this procedure just for the effluent?

(113) Aleena, November 9, 2015 8:36 PM

I can relate to each and every word youve written. I also lost my yonger brother 19 months ago. Im 23 and today he would have been 18.
Its like youve written my heart out. The fact that i still dont feel like discussing him even with my family..not only because its difficult because i like to keep my connection with him private. People say I should talk about it...but i just feel talking about him is not needed to prove i miss him prove that im also deeply affected. Im often misunderstood for dealing okay with it becsuse i dont talk about it but only I know how his memmories keep playing in fornt of me in the form of recurruing episodes only making my heart sink deeper and deeper. I just hope he keeps visiting me in my dreams so that at least i can always feel our connection alive.
What youve written about your mom is exactly how my mom has been taking it.

I really feel no other posts out there have gotten to me like this one. I hope youre doing well.

(112) Jon, August 13, 2015 12:24 AM

I just lost my brother and I feel so lost and so empty. I hate that people keep telling me that it will get easier over time! Dose that even happen? I mean how am I supposed to move on from somebody that I grew up with hand in hand! He was 32 old years old and had seizures almost his whole life. He has gotten lucky to not get seriously hurt so many times and on July 21st 2015 his condistion took him from us all in an instant. My daughter and I went to my moms house to go swimming after a morning at the park teaching my daughter how to rollerblade. It was such a good start to a horrific day! When we got there my brother told us to wait so he could clean out the pool for us.. Before I knew it I was pulling him from the pool lifeless. My brother was gone and I knew the second that I found him that he wasn't comming back to us. I was only 20 feet away from him and I was too late to save his life! How do you move on from such a thing? Dose time really heal all wounds? Signed, Mr. Lost and confused

(111) Anonymous, June 25, 2015 7:26 AM

He is around you how special

Hi I lost my brother and have had no one really to tell how I feel and I feel like you do, just remember that you both loved each other very much and he is around you. I tell myself and have had many real like dreams him telling me to be strong now if I cant be strong for him, keep remembering those great memories and tuck them in your heart and be strong please and move on with him in your heart that is what he would want not matte what happened to him he would be protecting you. how special is that, that's love please try and be happy and move forward for you and him

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment