click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Knockin' on Heaven's Door

Knockin' on Heaven's Door

My travels with Bob Dylan


When I was transitioning from childhood to adulthood in the late Sixties, Bob Dylan's songs were a lifeline. So much of my time was spent living in the box. I ate, breathed, and slept S.A.T. scores and college applications. I lived in a highly competitive world where I was expected to accomplish great things. And there were those Bob Dylan lyrics talking about the coming times when "the last would be first," about white doves that sleep in the sand, about a Tambourine Man and other things that resonated with a place in me I was beginning to locate -- called my "inner world."

There weren't too many people who seemed to care about the existence of an inner world, but I didn't give up trying to find them. In my sophomore year of college, I noticed a lot about the inner world in the poems of the French Symbolists, especially in Rimbaud who also happened to be one of Dylan's favorites.

After graduating from college, I worked at a good job in television for two years. Then suddenly, I dropped out and moved to Maine. A number of factors contributed to my unorthodox decision: my father's death, a love of nature, attraction to solitude, and burning questions about life that were not getting answered. I had always been afraid of really blowin' in the wind, but now I felt the need to untether myself.

Dylan seemed to operate from the inside out, instead of the outside in.

Like his Sixties' songs, the Dylan songs of the early Seventies were good company next to my wood burning stove on a Maine winter's night. They spoke about keeping to your true North and what happens when you don't, aligning with your vision and your dreams, and about being real with yourself and your feelings. I wasn't always enthralled with those songs, especially when he sang about women. Certain songs even made me angry. I was no card-carrying Dylan fan.

So how did he help to get me here, living a religious life in Jerusalem, the last place I would have ever imagined myself being?

Dylan seemed to operate from the inside out, instead of the outside in. He had an artistic integrity that made him follow his inspiration wherever it took him. It didn't mean that he never admitted to getting confused, which he did quite often in his lyrics. But he saw the confusion and the clarity and the hope and the despair as all part of some very big picture, and he accepted it all and tried to squeeze all of it into his songs.

Dylan knew how to go knockin' on Heaven's door, and in general, there was a certain God-consciousness in the underpinnings of his songs that were full of Biblical imagery. By the early Eighties, I didn't even notice Dylan's stint with Christianity because I had already made the decision to go for broke in search of my Jewish soul.

It didn't take long for him to drop that Christian phase. There's even a 1983 photo of him at the Wall wearing tefillin. My friend remembers how Dylan drove to Far Rockaway with his limousine and body guards to speak with Rabbi Shlomo Freifeld, obm, and was interested enough to request another meeting.

By then I had more than enough to feed my inner world by singing Shlomo Carlebach songs and traditional zemirot around a Shabbos table in the Old City of Jerusalem.


My first few years of marriage were spent in Denver. During one of our long conversations, Bob Dylan's name came up, and my husband acknowledged that he had also been significantly influenced by Dylan.

My husband had been certain that his rabbi, Rabbi Shloime Twerski, obm, would be one of the few Jewish figures who could speak Dylan's language and open the door for him to Judaism. He was so certain that when he was in California, he went over to Malibu where Dylan lived and tried to find him.

He parked his car down the block and walked over to what he thought was the approximate location of Dylan's house according to the information he had. The house was high up on a bluff, and there was an older woman standing in a flower bed halfway down the hill. He figured it must be Bob Dylan's mother.

"I just wanted Bob Dylan to meet my rabbi. I think it could change his life."

She was wearing a bandanna and pedal pushers. As he approached, she noticed him and the tzitzis and kipah he was wearing. My husband figured it was best to go straight to the point about why he had appeared, unannounced and uninvited.

"I'm looking for Bob Dylan. Is this his house?"

"No, Bob lives up the road. I'm not at liberty to show you where, but why are you looking for him?"

My husband realized he had gone on a wild goose chase. He felt a stab of disappointment and wasn't interested in making conversation, but the lady seemed so nice that he felt she deserved an explanation.

"It's because of my rabbi, Rabbi Shloime Twerski. I just wanted Bob Dylan to meet him. I think it could change his life."

The lady's eyes opened wide when she heard the name "Twerski." Turns out she was Jewish -- the wife of a famous movie producer – grew up in Milwaukee, and knew the rabbi's father.

"Oh my God! The Milwaukee Twerskis! My father used to take me to the rebbe! Everyone in Milwaukee knew him. Everyone respected him. No judge, Jewish or not, would decide on a case until they talked to the rebbe. And no lawyer would take a case until they talked to him. The Milwaukee Twerskis…"

She shook her head as if the words couldn't do justice to her memories. "Young man," she said, "I really want to help. You know what -- here take this piece of paper and write down a message for Bob, and I'll see to it that he gets it."

That was as close as my husband ever got to Dylan. Nine months after we were married the rabbi passed away. It would have to take someone or something else to wake Dylan up to his Jewish soul.


Dylan's songs, a kaleidoscope of observations and impressions about life, showed me how the world around me was communicating and I should listen to her music.

For example, this morning while walking to the corner store, I saw a Burial Society van pull up to the sidewalk and pick up a group of little girls with their schoolbags. How incongruous -- even bizarre – I thought, that the same van would be used to transport the dead.

Then the words "Chevra Kadisha," whose literal translation is "Holy Brotherhood," emblazoned in white letters on the dark van, started to unhinge from their usual association with the Burial Society. I realized that the band of little girls climbing in were another type of chevra kadisha, a sweet holy sisterhood of innocent souls on their way to school.

No earthshaking epiphany, but it was a sign that my heart was awake. Like Dylan, I was trying to listen to the precious music.

Bob, wherever you are, thanks for the lifeline, and for being part of the Master Composer's great orchestration.

June 14, 2008

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 21

(21) es58, February 5, 2013 5:55 PM

Ed Sullivan show story

There was a special about the Ed Sullivan show where they said: They asked the Stones to change their lyrics to "let's spend some time together", and they did. They asked the Doors not to sing a certain phrase from light my fire, they agreed, but did it anyway, live. They asked Dylan what he wanted to sing. he said John Birch, they came back and asked him to select any other song. He refused, and never did the show.

(20) Leora Rosen, June 23, 2008 10:57 PM

Dylan.... and Manis Friedman! :-)

Bob Dylan's blurb for "Doesn't Anyone Blush Anymore," which my "spiritual" but not Jewishly-educated mom gave me when I was a teenager (and obsessed with Dylan), was the only thing that could ever have made me read such a book. As anyone who has read it knows, it was impossible not to be permanently affected by this book... by its peerless portrayal of Judaism's beauty and idealism about relationships... the commenters here who write off Dylan as some druggie are not really doing anyone a favor.

(19) Carsten, June 19, 2008 10:44 PM

Still an inspiration - and an icon

I am at the same sorry and curious to read the anonymous entry at the top.

Total deceiver of a generation? Hmm ... I'm not sure, that I understand which direction is supposed to have taken. Has Bob Dylan been deceiving anyone, when clearly following his own road, artistically and otherwise? Only too many people have been busy iconizing him, and somehow demanding of him to live up to the expectations of other people.

I had the great fortune of winning 2 tickets to Bob Dylan's recent concert in Odense, Denmark. I went there with a Jewish friend of mine, and for him, it was his first Bob Dylan concert.

For me it was a great pleasure to watch Bob up close, seing his little dancing dancing steps, watching his own excitement and amusement, when he passionately delves into the lyrics and into the piano chords, which have nowadays replaced the acoustic and electric guitars.

After the concert, I asked my friend, what he thought of the concert, and he said, that his honest opinion was, that he had never been that bored before.

At first, I felt a bit disappointed about having taken him there, but then I came to think, that Bob Dylan was not there to satisfy as much of the audience as possible. He was there to perform the songs, that HE felt was the right ones to perform that particular evening. He was there to give a status of the moment as HE sees it. You can care about it, be inspired by it or go by almost totally unaffected.

In my view, the greatest quality about Bob Dylan is in fact, that he is still able to do exactly that: inspire, matter ... make you take a stand.

(18) Anonymous, June 18, 2008 11:59 AM

The answer, my friend ...........................

Sparing you my personal biographical notes, let me just say this:

I'm thankful to Bob Dylan as an influence, but no longer hold him as an icon. To me he's a combination of a total deceiver of a generation, a product of a lot of media hype (much of which was based upon his own design), a total master of words, an incredible talent, and just another Jewish soul. He should live and be well, as should all the rest of us!

With that, I offer you a template based upon one of his great works, only with the real answer:

How (many, much) (ask a profound question) ?
How (many, much) (ask another profound question) ?
How (many, much) (ask even another profound question)?
The answer my friend is (choose one: Baruch HaShem/ B'ezras HaShem/d'var HaShem)
The answer is (repeat choice from above line)

Repeat 2 more verses with different questions and the same answer. The questions may be different, but the answer's always the same.

(17) jerry, June 18, 2008 11:41 AM

I remember that night

I was learning at Shor Yoshuv at that time. Reb Shlomo, OBM, always had Bochrim at his house. But that night the word was out no one was to come. He was speaking with Bob Dylan that night. It says a lot about Reb Shlomo
that he would speak with anyone and that his Yeshiva was open to anyone sincerely looking for Yiddishkeit. You should have seen the mix of people learning and shteiging there. Anyone that learned at the Yeshiva in those days or spent a Shabbos or Yom Tov there was very fortunate. Such experiences are so rare. Do we appreciate them?

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment