(1) Sandy 7/25/2001
Why can't one still be Jewish and believe in Jesus?
I would like to know who made the law that as Jews you cannot believe in Jesus? Unfortunately, there has been a lot of persecution in Jesus name Is that HIS fault or the fault of man?

Aish.com replies: We have an article on exactly this question at http://aish.com/societyWork/philosophy/Why_Dont_Jews_Believe_In_Jesus$.asp


(2) Nathan Hevenstone 2/27/2007 4:59:00 PM
Christians and Jews can Coexist, but not like this...
It is quite possible for Jews and Christians (and even Muslims) to coexist, because regardless of our beliefs, our roots are all the same.

However, we cannot coexist if organizations like the Jews for Jesus are running around. Believing Jesus is the Messiah goes against they very foundation of Judaism and the original Messianic Prophecy. Jesus shot down the Torah and many of its commandments. How can any Jew believe in a man who turned his back on his own religion, at least, according to the Gospels?

I honestly wish Christians would stop fighting Jews and vice-versa. We have to find a way to bridge the gap. It is quote possible, but the efforts of organizations/cults like the Jews for Jesus are only making that gap considerably wider, and it needs to stop.

Thank you, Rabbi Shraga, for this article. I have begun to read this site constantly, and enjoy it's articles immensely.


Oh, and I am aware that this comment is coming in quite a long time after the writing and posting of this article. I only discovered this article a few days ago, though I have been interested in the reasoning behind the creation of the Jews for Jesus cult for quite some time, in as much as being able to learn to know how to combat their statements.




(3) David Elias 11/16/2005
Challenge to Christians
This year was the first time that I ever took the time to look at WHY ?
Why do the jews believe that the Messiah has not come? (From their point of veiw) I had always looked at it from the christian point of veiw and now after looking at it from the Jewish side, I can see without a doubt that the Jews were right all along. Also, knowing what I know about G_d and how the Jewish people want to follow hashem with their utmost, "How could millions of jews for thousands of years be wrong? and I right? after they were the people who were given the Torah and studied it in their own language for thousands of years before?
My deepest appologies to the Jewish people for being so blind, biased and ignorant of their belief.
I now have a sincere desire to convert to Judaism from christianity.
I want to follow hashem to my utmost and only with the help of the Jewish people am I going to be able to do this.
Shalom !

(4) Anonymous 12/2/2004
Former Jew for Jesus ("Completed Jew", Messianic Jew)
In the Orlando area back in the 80's I spent one year among the Pentacostals and the Messianic Jews. It is without a doubt a mind controlling cult.


(5) leo 12/1/2003
If I may:
in regard to the christains that post thier heartfelt empathy for us jews:
please give it a rest.
i find these comments absolutely repulsive and utterly stupid.
the only regret about killed jews is that "there goes another potential convert, too bad."
how has christianty understood what J.C. meant when he said "i will not return until you call my name"?- it's always been a call to convert jews. "do not go to the gentile, only to the lord's flock, the house of israel." "the jew first, then the gentile" etc..
the fact that the JfJ. would molest our heritage to promote lies is even more disgusting. for how many years has the christian faith had no use for a torah scroll. and now, suddenly, its in style.
the mutilation of our holy passover seder is also neausiating. i dont even have the words to express myself. what an underhanded, deceiveing, group of liars! (see II Cor.)
HOW DO THEY EVEN KNOW WHAT TEFILIN ARE!!?? and if theyr'e supposed to listen to the rabbi's, why dont they listen about disregarding J.C.?
the bottom line is that the religions are diametrically opposed. and although jews do not harbor bad feelings for gentiles, i believe that "making freinds" would only be disastrous.
also: "the people who oppressed you weren't real christians"- i thought it says "a good tree doesn't bear bad fruit!"

thanks for letting me vent.

p.s. "why can't a jew beleive in J.C.?"
see EXO. 20:2-4, and Maimonidies 13 PRINCIPALS of faith


(6) pedro lugo 1/22/2003
Jesus is God John 1-1
Roman catholicism is not christianity. Please.


(7) Anonymous 1/14/2003

Shalom Aleichem, my name is Anán i am Jewish Puerto Rican, i am from the sephardim jews. I find this organization of ''jews for jesus'' interesting because, lots of these people say i love jesus and i love him because this is the Mashiaj of yisrael, all right, but let's say that these jesus was the messiah of yisrael if this is the messiah of israel how come most of this people don't live by the Torah? how come because is the old testament, because jesus abrogated it the law? so a jewish messiah abrogates its own law, interesting. I don't mean to offend anybody in here i really don't the only thing i want to say here is that if you have a truth and live by that truth there is Have to have a change in you! I only want every messianic jew that is seeing this message and think, if this is the jewish messiah how could he abrogated the law??? i only live you with this. the real jew is the only that lives by Torah and observes the torah the right way with its right interpretation believing that the word of the prophets are truth that is the real jew. Thank you for your time and like i said i don't mean to offend anybody, if anybody would want to contact me this is my e-mail js_marine15@yahoo.com. Shalom aleichem


(8) Max Shapiro 12/5/2002
Mailing by Jews for Jesus
Today I received a mailing from Jews for Jesus...something about an offer of a free book written by a woman Holocaust survivor who joined Jews for Jesus. I sent the mailer back threatening to burn down their headquarters if they bothered me again, and used the most salacious language I could summon.
"Haven't Jews suffered enough without you people trying to destroy us by converting us?" I wrote (expletives deleted). I hope this isn't a stepped-up effort on the part of these bastards to convert Jews, and I applaud people like you who are trying to stop them.
Max Shapiro


(9) Wayne Schlievert 11/14/2002
If GOD, bless HIS name wants more Christian Jews, HE will have them ,without mans interference.
As a Christian Noahide, I cannot understand why other Christians would even want to convert Jews.
Jews are set aside/chosen by GOD, praise HIS name.
They are to teach the rest of GOD's creation what we need to know.
I personally am absorbed in research thru this p.c. media. It's a real eye opener and my faith in my Messiah remains undisturbed.
Maybe, they, (JfJ) need to review their own scripture once more. The answers are there.
Why not try Muslims or Buddists for Jesus. Those without a connection.


(10) Pam Schuffert 10/3/2002
Why should we fight other's rights to advertize their faith?
"The Jews for Jesus organization has spent millions of dollars in print and radio advertising, and has run a campaign of banner ads in New York City subways and on major web sites. If you see one of these ads, you should write a letter of protest to the host organization."

In a nation known for promoting religious freedom of worship and liberty to share one's religious faith with others and to practice it freely, I find this comment to be shocking. Should Jews, with a history of persecution for their faith in nation after nation, but who can now experience freedom of worship in America, be therefore seeking to oppress OTHERS' right to religious expression and sharing of their beliefs with others??? This goes entirely against 1st Amendment Constitutional rights and the spirit of religious freedom without oppression.

I am amazed that you would write something like this, and would be interested in your justification of seeking to repress other's religious beliefs while demanding full liberty for yourself.-Pam Schuffert, journalist



(11) David Cohen 9/14/2002
Jews for Jesus Targets St. Louis, 2002
The so-called "Jews for Jesus" showed just how insensitive and uncaring they are when dealing with real Jews by targeting American cities with Jewish populations exceeding 25,000 during the 5763/2002 High Holidays. Just today, the day before Kol Nidre, I received a mailer from this organization imploring us to hear the stories on videotape of HOLOCAUST SURVIVORS who have accepted Jesus. That they would target us during our most sacred seasons is the epitomy of chutzpah and sliminess. Sol'n liegen in DRERD!


(12) Herve 7/30/2002
What verses are taken out of context
Could you tell me what verses of the scriptures that these people take out of context? I would imagine that it would help me to be able to circumvent their logic as I come upon them.


(13) Narasimha 7/19/2002
Missionary Deceit Widespread
Interesting article.
The use of deceit by Christian missionaries is common in India, as well. This tact goes back to the early days of Christianity when missionaries arrived in South India. I recently heard the Archbishop of Madras in Tamil Nadu State speak with pride about this fact. To this day, Christian missionaries go to India, adopt native clothing, and style their prayers and rituals after local custom. They take advantage of what is a natural respect and veneration amongst the common people for holy persons. When they cannot use this form of deceit, they "purchase" souls. They offer social and medical services in return for conversion. Even Mahatma Gandhi, who respected Christianity, condemned this practice.
Ultimately the only protection against this deceit and fraud is education - make your people knowledgable and their faith so intrinsic to their lives that the spurious claims of missionaries have no effect.


(14) Ron 6/21/2002
"Supporter Dismayed by Assumptions"
I am an avid supporter of Israel, and have a great love in my heart for the Jewish people. When I was 15 years old, I traveled in Israel for a month. For many years after I longed to go back to Israel and join the IDF. I have traveled extensively, and have worked for NGO’s (religious and otherwise) in N. Ireland, Kosovo/a and Russia.

Almost eight out of every ten books I read is on Israel, the Holocaust, or other Jewish History. My best friend, from Childhood on, is a Jew. I have a large Star of David tattooed on the middle of my back, which I got when I was 18. The tattoo has exposed me to anti-Semitic persecution on more than one occasion. I wish I was Jewish. I would trade my strait blond hair and blue eyes, for dark curly hair and brown eyes any day.

All of that to say… I strongly align myself with the Jewish people, yet I am dismayed by the opinions I read in reading Rabbi Shraga Simmons article titled “Jews For Jesus” and many of the comments that followed.

Rabbi Simmons wrote, “some missionaries got the idea to try a backdoor tactic. They invented "Jews for Jesus," which uses a whole lexicon of Jewish-sounding buzz words in order to make Jesus more palatable to Jews.”

The Rabbi assumes that no Jew could actually come to a sincere belief in Jesus as the Messiah and yet still want to maintain their history and culture. Why not?

Rabbi Simmons also seems to assumes that this is some deceptive tactic by a dirty Christian, rather then a grass roots movement of Jews who do believe in Jesus and who do a better job of holding on to early Christian (i.e. Jewish) practices. I would expect these assumptions from a newspaper in Saudi Arabia claiming that “it has never been proved that Jews do not use the blood of Christian babies at Passover, not from an enlightened NY Rabbi, or a modern Jewish news service.

I am glad to have found your website, and will continue to visit regularly.

Shalom,
Ron Stivers

~Still waiting for the IRC to recognize the Red Star of David~



(15) Guy 6/21/2002
Joan Rivers ?
To hold high Joan Rivers as an Apostle for the Jewish faith is in itself comedic ! Her disdain for free speach is obvious yet she spues some of the most ignorant and foul rhetoric heard today on our nations airwaves. Seems to me you should choose other worthy models of human decency if trying to illustrate your argument.


(16) Anonymous 6/20/2002
Jews for Jesus
I want to thank Rabbi Shraga Simmons for his article on Jews for Jesus. I agree with his concern that this is a cult. I am a Catholic Christian Kosher Coordinator who visits Jewish sites to learn more for my personal and work benefit. Last year we took in a foreign exchange student and met a "Jews for Jesus" follower who had a Jewish student staying with her. She took this child to her services every week and agressively tried to convert him. I believe that the parents had no idea and feel this is very wrong. "Honor your Father and Mother" means to me that we have a responsibility to honor the wishes of the parents of a child in our care. Our foreign student was required by us to go to services every week, but her parents decided what church and I provided transportation to make sure she followed her faith, not mine while she lived in our home. I believe to use deception to convert someone is a serious sin and I saw deception in the efforts of the Jews for Jesus follower that I met.


(17) Anonymous 5/20/2002
On real jewish faith
I find "the jews for jesus" an irrational way of thinking. Either you are a jew or you are not, any "adds on" to the jewish tradition is invalid, as invalid are the efforts of the Christians to undermind more than 3 thousand years of history.
Some years ago I found out that my ancestors were jewish in Mexico, their last names was Berman. My wife, a jew, was the one who discovered this and asked me to find out about it. Although I haven't found concrete evidence about my jewishness, I have converted to judaism because I feel it in my soul and blood. Those who are certain to have been born jews should be consider themselves lucky and proud of it and forget about fanatic manipulations of any sort, and dedicate themselves to revisit jewish history and read more torah in order to immerse themselves into the jewish reality. We are jews!!!

Lazarus


(18) David 5/17/2002
"Jews for Jesus" by by Rabbi Shraga Simmons
I couldn't agree more with Rabbi Simmons. When I worked for the Boston-based paper back around 1994, "The Jewish Advocate", there was an ad we placed (huge ad) unwittingly for this underhanded organization. (It advertised a television show about a day in the life of a Rabbi. Little did any of the Jewish newspapers know it was about a Rabbi who converts to Christianity.

Organizations who cannot be upfront and honest deserve cautious scrutiny by others.

Mind you, I am a Christian myself (actually a "Mormon" - so we are not recognized as Christian by other christian churches), so I don't fully appreciate the perspective of the Jewish people when confronted by "Jews for Jesus". But I know of organizations out there who try to fragment the Mormon people, such as the so-called "Christians Concerned for Mormons, Inc." who's aim it is to undermine the faith and values of the Mormon community. I suppose that whatever one believes, there is going to be somebody out there convinced you will go to hell if you don't accept what THEY believe instead.

Thank you for this article. It was well-written, and truer words have never been committed to "ink". - David Honaker, Phoenix, Arizona (USA)


(19) Sharona 5/17/2002
Without contempt for Christians
It is without total comtempt for christians that I support fully Rabbi Simmons and the others who are dedicated to educating and counseling our jewish youth who are confused and trying to find their own way. It is overwhelmingly alarming at the great differences between the Christian and Jewish faith while at the same time so similar. While my husband never was able to grasp his jewish education nor the meaning and grew up disallusioned, I was adamantly taught evangelical christianity but found an end with no answer to my questions in that circle of religion. I sought my answers and begged for guidance and was able to steer myself out of a mirage of confusion. I have always believed that I begged for wisdom and because of my persistence was shown the truth. Now that I know better and realize I was on the wrong path for me, it is with great satisfaction but as well great work on my part to pursue this truth and show my appreciation for this great "revelation of truth and wisdom". As well I have a responsibility to the "ONE" for all of my actions and which direction I take from this point. It is with great sorrow as I have tried so many times to help some of my christian friends understand, that the emotion of that religion is the appealing factor. If only I knew how to get beyond the emotions without destroying a christian friend's entire inner spiritual set of faith and value beliefs. The Rabbi that is willing to learn this will be the one able to clear the way for the Moshiach. As it is my understanding that when the Moshiach comes, all will know and honor him as the one who has retored order and peace to the world.


(20) Anonymous 5/15/2002
Thank you for the ammunition.
As a deeply committed Jew, and the first generation, post-Holocaust survivors of both of my parents you have now given me the means to counter the propaganda of my sister. More than six months ago she was, unfortunately taken in by this rhetoric and continues to practice Messianic Judaism.
May Hashem see fit to bring her back to his love and care speedily and
May He bless you all for your work.


(21) Anonymous 5/8/2002
Alleged Heavenly Deception
Jews for Jesus is a Protestant evangelical/fundamentalist group that receives most of its very generous funding from Southern Baptist and Assemblies of "god" denominations.
These Christians don't believe that Catholics are Christians, In fact, any purported Christian who doesn't accept their theology is suspect as unsaved.
Jews for Jesus believes in the existence of a Satanic devil deity, which belief is avoda zara, contrary to Torah.
Paul their Apostle justifies deceptive tactics in I. Corinthians 9:20. ("To the Jews, I came as a Jew. I was all things to all men in order that I save some of them.")
Jews for Jesus follows John 14:6 (uber alles) strictly, i.e. the exclusivity of its Protestant theology as a pathway into "heaven" post mortem.
I understand that the Halakhic way to counter such missionaries is to inform them about the Sefer Toldoth Yeshu. After reading it, Santa and the Easter bunny will never seem the same.

Shalom,
Gerry
Wednesday, 5/08/02 common era
Mountain View, CA
USA


(22) Anonymous 4/23/2002
Love and support for the Jewish people
I don't know much about the JFJ people but I am a Christian who understands that the Jewish people have suffered greatly throughout history at the hands of "Christians". I am so sorry for your suffering but I want you to know that there are many, many of us who love the Jewish people and Israel dearly with no strings attached. You are God's chosen ones and you are kept in my heart always!
With much love and respect,
An American Christian


(23) E 4/21/2002
Hi
I remember a Rabbi who said "Jesus was a very righteous man". Anyway, I think that what he was talking about was really hardly understood, if he is the messias then nobody listened....even christians.

I am living in the state of utah, usa. Here i am living an interesting dilemma: Since this is the state of mormons, traditional christians seem to be as jews among traditional christians.....This is an e-mail also to warn you of this phantom named mormonism: They are practically copying Jewish law from Jew law, they are trying to teach everysingle thing Jew religion has....an more than that...they are mixing all with media, egyptian beliefhs and more irritating they call themselves "The new people of the covenant", they are the new jews....The worst of all is that this religion is expanding very quickly, what has happened to Israel?. While Israel sleeps or fight for survivance, there are groups trying to steal its heritage, isn't it time to be reorginized?. Isn't it time for a prophet?. At least a great sage?. I cant believe there is not a new maimonides or someone able to re group all Jews....


(24) Anonymous 4/17/2002
Jews for Jesus Response
I live in the Dallas, Texas area. "Christian" Messianic Judaism is alive and growing in my area. Most of the growth is being propagated by Apostate Jews who are leaders in the Christian Messianic Movement. If you think this type of Judaism is still where it was for the past 20 years, let me tell you it is not. It has developed into a completely Jewish expression. They have synagogue settings with a complete a Traditional service out of the siddur "in Hebrew" and they are keeping correct Kashrut and observing all religious life cycle and holiday events from a halakah point of reference, ect. They are calling this the Hashevanu Movement; a new part of the Christian Messianic Movement.
Underneath this Jewish display they still belief Jesus is the Messiah, that he is God incarnate, and that God is a Trinity of Persons. The foundation of their belief is totally Pagan.
I believe every synagogue in America should teach young Jewish children "exactly and clearly how sin is atoned for, who God and his nature is, and what a Messiah is from a Jewish position before their Bar/Bat Mitzvah; hopefully before they are nine years old. (Momanides 13 principles on their level) They should then be taught what sin atonement, God, and a Messiah is in the religion of Christianity and why it is a false biblical belief. Children should know this because they are living in a Christian country and they will be faced with Christianity's belief system and evangelists on a daily basis as young adults and adults.
They need to have a perfect "understanding" of Jewish perfect faith. With this in place they may be able to bring Apostate Jews back to Judaism when confronted with an Apostate Jew or Gentile Christian trying to convince them to convert to Christianity. The Jewish community can not "just assume" the children are completely informed about Judaism and have obtained complete understanding about what they have been informed with. Thank you for letting me tell you what I think.
Signed: Very Concerned


(25) David 3/10/2002
Deception is not a valid part of Judaism or Christianity
Dear rabbi



How I agree with those parts of your report that condemn the deceptive, proselytising methods of certain christian evangelists. Some christians have used these methods to bring people to the christian faith for two thousand years and they are wrong.

Conversion at the point of the sword (or pen if the pen is really mightier than the sword!) has been used by most if not all religions - may I mention the tactics used by the Maccabees which brought us Herod the Great amongst their converts?



In the context of my being a christian pastor I may not be an acceptable commentator, but as I really care about Israel and the Jewish people, and am deeply grieved that my heritage towards you has been persecution and deception I want to be a part of building bridges to try and redress the balance.



It seems to me that we need to build some bridges of understanding about each other without proselytising. There are problems of course because the more passionate we are about our faith the more we suspect the motives of the friendly hand outreached to say hello.



However, the dangers are great if we do not talk and make friends. I would hate that many Jews came to think that all Christians are only interested in Jews so we can deceive them into becoming Christians.
<
Yours in friendship

David Squibb


(26) DOV 2/12/2002
EXELENT ARTICLE
I PRINTED YOUR ARTICLE TO GIVE TO MY HALF BROTHER ,WIFE AND CHILDREN.THEY ARE (MESS}IANIC JEWS,MY TAKE CONVERT TO BEING A GENTILE.I AM A PROUD JEW ISRAELI/AMERICAN CITEnZEN.
I LOVE YOUR WEBSITE,I AM AN AVID READER OF YOUR ARTICLES.
REGARDS
DOV B E


(27) john 2/1/2002
do they think we are stupid?
jews for jesus needs to change their name to former jews for jesus,so real jews would not get confused with their deceptive name ,and they should also change the name jesus to something else ,since jews get confused by that too.Are we that stupid?


(28) D 1/8/2002
jews for judaism
i agree this jews for jesus is absurd and contradictory.

im a proud jew for judaism


(29) Michael 1/6/2002
A nudnik by any other name still nudzhes you
My complaint is that Christianity seems to make people dead from the neck up.
Every Jew knows that Jesus is not G-d.
If Jesus was Jewish he knew that too.
Personally, I think the Chassidim are the real Messianic Jews, and that when the Messiah comes the divine kingdom will be a reality on earth. Since I don't see the world as a paradise, I don't believe the Messiah has come yet -but, I'm still waiting.
These guys have made their poor parents ashamed of them. For that I am ashamed.


(30) Louis A. 1/4/2002
Jews to take over evangelizing earth very soon when Elijah comes.
As a Christian Zionist I believe we are at the Time of Jacob's trouble and the Jew people, and especially Rabbi's have to start preparing to take over the job of evangelizing the whole earth because G-d is going to thrust it upon Judaism very soon. The Book of Revelations clearly shows Jesus condemning Christianity for having failed in their mission, and the job is returned to the Jew! In the same Book of revelations it is clearly stated 144,000 Jews, 12,000 of each tribe will spread what I call the Gospel according to Torah.

I do not believe in preaching Jesus to Jews, but i preach for all Christians to support Israel and the Jews....I have very few christian friends!!! Much of Christianity has fallen for the big lie that it has replaced Judaism and that is leading us up to the 4th reich and the ultimate holocaust. Most Christians are totally unaware of our Jewish heritage and I try to win friends for Israel by explaining how Even Jesus said he had not come to do away with the law but to fulfill it. I feel it is time for Rabbi's that feel we are in the last days to come out vocally world wide and preach their message. I know many Christians would pay attention to the Rabbis because in their hearts they know it is time and ministers and the catholic churches are only concerned with themselves.

Because of the times...will you join me in praying for the return of ELIJAH?
YOURS TRULY, Louis Romo in Stockton, California


(31) Anonymous 12/23/2001

we must eradicate these missonaries that are called jews for j----. they are the lowest forms of life trying to manipulate the lost soles or forgotten jews. they are are using deceptfull approaches to lure our people in Israel


(32) Jeff 12/9/2001
Thanks
It is because I am a Christian that I have a G-d placed love for the nation of Israel and Jews. Jews accept and like me, to my knowledge. I don't hit any of my friends over the head with my Bible, including Jews. I would place my self in harms way to protect a Jew or anyone friend or not. My old self was very much the opposite!


(33) Ed 11/15/2001

This is an excellent article. The subject needs wider exposure. Credit Joan Rivers for taking a strong stand.
Other well known Jewish entertainers,etc could be solicited to add their voices.


(34) Gershom 11/12/2001
Been there -- done that.
I spent several years as the lay leader for a military synagogue where a local group of the messianic Jews made numerous attempts to infiltrate our synagogue.
Being a Ger -- (then learning later I had Jewish roots) & former pentecostal member of churches and groups -- put me in a unique postion to recognize the rhetoric and slight of tounge they use to gain access. So for the most part I was able to keep them out of our synagogue by approaching them, and confronting them with the knowledge that I knew who they were and what they wanted. IF they chose to stay for service -- they were to make no attempts at discussion of their belief. Or, they would be escorted out.
They quickly, left.
So may I suggest strongly based on my former association, and knowledge of how they work -- that every effort be made to advertise in major and local news papers across the nation -- frequently -- some of the excellent books that can be obtained that refute their claims.
Such as the current work a remake of "The Disputation", "Faith Strengthened", and a little more philosophical work called "Jewish and Christian Ethics". All clearly give some excellent points of refutation to the missionary outreach by the various church groups.
I now live in Israel and am finding many secular who are also being influenced by the "700 Club" type shows. I use these books as reference materiel.
May Hashem prevent the Yatzer Hara of deciet -- from fooling our people.


(35) Lisa 11/4/2001
I Fell For It
I fell for the tactics, but not from Jews for Jesus but from the Baptist Church itself. The pastor there told me all the same things mentioned above that come from JFJ missionaries. It worked, and for 6 years I was a practicing Christian, becoming baptised and the whole nine yards. Finally, by this year I allowed those uncomfortable feelings I had all along to take over the desire to "fit in" (I live in a Bible thumping area of central California). I have since returned to practicing Judaism, and my husband has remained a Christian. We will figure it out, but other Jews must not fall for the tactics used by the JFJ's as well as by the churches. We must remember that being Jewish gives us the connection with G-d so many Christians go through Jesus to get. When the Messiah comes, we'll ALL know it. Until then, we must love G-d and follow His mitvot.


(36) Henry 10/21/2001
A true analysis.
Once again I comment on what I have read and in the first portion of this message the truth is evident to me first hand in the section begining with: for example. By infiltrating Judaic thoughts and using terms associated with Judaism, in an effort to confuse people, the unsuspecting truly feel a sense of Jewishness whereby if Christian/Catholic terms, i.e. cross, baptism, were used there might be some questions raised as to why those terms are used since they are in conflict with Judaic terms. Once you use different terminology, you can hide the actual message. I recall a Christian writer who wrote that satan uses a lake of truth to hide a pint of poison. It is the sublime messages that Messianics use to bring people into a sense of comfort and therefore the people believe they are on the right track.That the Jewish element of ritual, and so forth is only a natural path to follow. And, a Messianic synagouge I am familiar with proclaims that it is a gathering of Jews AND Gentiles who profess that Jesus is indeed the Jewish Messiah.The Jewish rituals are indispersed with preaching from the New Testament. Obviously a conflict.
Shalom,
Henry Murray


(37) isabel 9/25/2001
jesus the mesias?
i dont think god wants fanatics, one day all human kind will see the savior of this world, for now we should double our praying time, instead of wasting time, lets talk to nonebelievers about GOD.


(38) Anonymous 9/12/2001

I am not a Jew but I fully agree with the atricle. The best words I ever read about Jesus were written by Jews - Buber, Fluesser, Russian-Jewish journalist Michael Heifetz (his last book "Trial on Jewsus: Jewish versions" is great). The type of propaganda used by Jews for Jesus is primitive protestantism that makes one allergic after first minute of reading. This organisation from time to time distibutes their leaflets in Moscow - the content is primitive and tasteless. A sort of primitive brain-washing similar to the "chewing gum" of American protestant preachers.I don't think their activies can do any good either to Jews, or to Jesus.


(39) Anonymous 9/1/2001
Jews for Jesus
I'm sorry you feel this way.


(40) Anonymous 8/28/2001
Fortify
Unfortunately, all religions have their subversive elements. Its part of the nature of religion and politics not subvert, convert, control any and all opponents by what ever means. Anyone who wishes to ward off conversion to anything must fully understand psychology and that takes study. Simple "say no to..." doesnt work. The value of Judaism must be so high that everything else seems second rate.


(41) Anonymous 8/28/2001
i don't understand.
you state that jews for jesus are trying to trick jews into converting. but i don't see much evidence for this in your article. what is wrong with using jewish words and customs in their services when jews for jesus have grown up jewish and still consider themselves jewish? why would anyone expect them to not incorporate jewish tradition? just because you don't support their beliefs does not mean that they are "tricking" jews into their way of thinking. i don't see adequate support for that claim in your article.

Aish.com comments: Jews being Jewish is fine. Jews being Christian and cloaking it in Jewish practice and calling it Jewish is not. Call it what it is - Christianity. And Christianity is not Judaism, regardless of "Jewish trappings".


(42) Anonymous 8/20/2001
Christian weakness bolstered by snagging Jews
For centuries Christian populations have watched the Jews among them retain their faith in the midst of challenge, persecution and death. And for centuries, the Christians have envied Jews our accomplishments in education, the arts and sciences, business, and almost every other endeavor we undertake. Our sense of peoplehood has been perceived as a threat to those among whom we reside. This whole "Jews for Jesus" thing is the inverse of the old maxim, "If you can't beat them, join them", except in this case, they succeed by having us join them, thereby bolstering their own flagging faith. It's dirty and underhanded, but it's our own fault for not educating our own and instilling the pride we've earned by outlasting every persecutor we've had for the last 4000 years.


(43) Patricia 7/29/2001
Truth vs Fiction
If the Gospel of Jesus is Truth it will survive. If it is false it will fall. Time is the test for every religion. It is our responsibility to know the truth and how better to do that than to search the Bible for our answers. It is important that we ask what G-d has to say about it rather than to ask what is man's analysis.
May you and I be blessed with wisdom as we search for the Truth.
pt


(44) Alan 7/10/2001
How sad for the Christians
The concept for this subversion sounds like something out of the dark ages; their need to trick good Jews into converting and their continuous missionary zeal are merely expressions of personal weakness and lack of self-confidence.


(45) Aaron 7/5/2001
Even as a Christian I disapprove of such tactics.
I am a Christian (although almost all my major beliefs differ from orthodox Christianity). I am interested in aish.com because I strongly believe that the Jews have had and will have a major part to play in the world.

Even as a Christian I am disgusted by the kind of tactics recorded here. This is exactly what the Roman Catholic church tried to do by merging paganism and Christianity.