Appel's Parsha Page Parshat Bo: Taking Gold and Silver from Egyptians
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Bo(Exodus 10:1-13:16)

Taking Gold and Silver from Egyptians

In the aftermath of World War II, Germany offered to pay reparations to victims of the Nazi regime. This offer was met by an incredibly heated debate in Israel. In fact, the controversy was so great that there was actually speculation in the Israeli media that acceptance of the reparations would cause a civil war.

When Prime Minister Ben Gurion ultimately agreed to accept the reparations, riots took place and there was a march on the Knesset which resulted in the Knesset building being stoned. Though peace and order was eventually restored, it is clear that for many Israelis at the time it was despicable to think that any "blood money" should be accepted.

A similar phenomenon is found in this week's Torah portion, Bo. The Jewish people are being led out of Egypt to freedom, but before their departure, God tells Moses to encourage each Jew to take from his Egyptian neighbor vessels of silver and vessels of gold. (see Exodus 11:2)

There are two puzzling issues raised by this verse. First, since the Jews would be traveling into the desert, why did they need gold and silver? Second, why did the Jews have to be "encouraged" to take these vessels?

In answer to the first question, Rashi explains that a promise had been made centuries earlier to the patriarch Abraham: After his descendants would suffer many years of bondage in Egypt, they would be freed, and in the process, they would despoil the Nile Kingdom of much of its wealth.

A fascinating Midrash describes why this despoiling of Egypt was fair and proper. Thousands of years later, the Egyptians came before Alexander the Great and registered a claim against the Jewish people, demanding that they should be compensated for all the wealth that the Israelites had seized from their forefathers a millennium earlier. In response to this claim, Gevia ben Psesia, acting as the Jews' defense attorney, noted that the Israelites had not received any wages for all the centuries they toiled as slaves in Egypt. Thus, justice demanded that the Jewish people be granted a form of reparations - i.e. compensation for the exploitation they had undergone at the hands of the ancient Egyptians.

But this brings us to the second question: If the Jews had legitimate claims to Egyptian wealth, then why did Moses have to encourage them to take it?

One explanation is that the Israelites were so anxious to escape the misery of Egypt, that they didn't want to stay around in order to enrich themselves. When a person is in great pain, his focus is exclusively on ending that suffering - and not on the acquisition of wealth.

Furthermore, the Israelites feared that such an action could provoke their former masters into pursuing them, as they made their way out of the Nile Kingdom.

Oznaim L'Torah, a modern commentator, offers a very different explanation. As victims of two centuries of unspeakable horrors, the Jews simply abhorred having contact with anything connected to Egypt.

Additionally, they did not want their seizure of Egypt's wealth to be seen as some type of "quid pro" for all the suffering they had endured. Thus Moses had to encourage them to take this property - in order to fulfill the Almighty's promise to Abraham.

This reluctance to take any money from the hands of their murderous exploiters is an issue that was tragically duplicated by the Jews in Europe some three millennia later.

Published: January 11, 2000

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 4

(4) Anonymous, November 8, 2009 1:12 AM

great. fanastic in helping me with my parsha

thank you

(3) carol friedman, January 13, 2005 12:00 AM

Very good point about the Jews in Egypt not wanting to take the booty. As compared to the Jews at the time of the Holocaust. I enjoyed that insight

(2) Anonymous, January 16, 2002 12:00 AM

Jewels of silver, jewels of gold

It took a lot of gold and silver for the
tabernacle in the wilderness also.
It was a great work of art and craftsmanship.

(1) , January 16, 2002 12:00 AM

A great lesson for us!

Jews in Egypt are giving us a great lesson. Their salary was indeed due to them but the Egyptians kept it. The Egyptian’s fortune was therefore not properly acquired. The Jews took it ONLY upon command. Without this g-odly command the “needy” Jews would not have touched it. A lesson for us: A Jewish institution should not accept money not properly acquired nor a Jewish person accept gift from companies not ethically run … and a fortiori with blood on their hands. If Mercedes gives you for FREE the super car of the year what about paying $49,999 for it! Personally, I buy ONLY American cars and if I could walk I would!

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub