click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Be'halot'cha(Numbers 8-12)

Joining up with the Jewish people

A few years ago, Vitaly, a Russian Jew living in Minsk, faced the difficult decision of whether or not to undergo a circumcision. After expressing his fear to some American friends, they tried to reassure him by saying that after a couple of days the pain would subside.

Vitaly looked at them askance - because it wasn't the physical pain that had given him pause. Rather, he said, becoming circumcised was putting his life at risk. "You see," he explained, "it was a circumcision that identified my grandfather as being Jewish - and the Nazis shot him on the spot. Given the uncertain circumstances in Russia today, I may well be putting my life at risk if I undergo a circumcision."

Vitaly's friends were shaken by his reply, and asked him why did he not simply leave Russia? Vitaly replied, "Because of my attachment to family and friends."

Vitaly's willingness to risk physical danger in order to remain with family and friends has been echoed countless times in Jewish history. As well, this idea is illustrated in this week's Torah portion, Be'halot'cha.

A major figure in the Parsha is Yitro, the father-in-law of Moses. Prior to his association with Moses, Yitro had served as High Priest for the nation of Midian. Then Yitro heard about the many miracles God had performed for the Israelites in coming out of Egypt. So he journeyed with the Israelite encampment, became an advisor to Moses, and reached such a position of prominence that the Torah portion which recounts the giving of the Torah ­-Parshat Yitro - is named after him.

Yet despite all of these factors, there came a time when Yitro decided to return home. "I want to go to my land, to my birthplace," he told Moses (Numbers 10:30). This decision appears shocking, given that Yitro knew the truth of the Living God and had seen many miracles. How could Yitro abandon the Israelite camp and return home?!

Most commentaries explain that Yitro only wanted to take a physical - not a moral - leave of the Jewish People. Yitro had converted to Judaism and his intention was to return home and convert his family and fellow Midianites to Judaism before returning to the Israelite encampment. Buttressing this view is some later scriptural evidence that Yitro's offspring did in fact become Jewish and actually became prominent leaders among the Israelites.

Some commentaries, however, say that Yitro intended to permanently leave the Israelites. These sources offer three different reasons for Yitro's motives:

The first says that just as love of family and friends will convince people nowadays to stay in situations of danger, so too Yitro's love of family drew him back to the spiritual danger of life in Midian. (We saw this illustrated earlier with Vitaly, the Russian Jew.)

A second view says it was Yitro's desire for wealth and honor that motivated him to return home. In the Israelite camp, his importance would always be overshadowed by Moses, his son-in-law. The tangible riches that he possessed at home were more attractive than the ill-defined prospects he might receive with the Israelites.

A third view takes an entirely different perspective. This view says that given the Israelites constant complaining in the desert - and the revolts against Moses - Yitro questioned the value of staying with the Israelites. Just how much patience could the Almighty have with such a people? Yitro desired to distance himself from this swarming beehive.

Perhaps this final lesson is most applicable today, when Jews are too-often arguing with each other - both in Israel and elsewhere. By doing so, aren't we showing young Jews the negative side of Judaism and pushing them away? If this is Judaism, they say, then I don't want any part of it!

Let us learn a lesson from Yitro, and undertake to realize that peace amongst Jews is a vital condition for the health and preservation of our people.

January 12, 2000

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 7

(4) Betzy, June 7, 2011 1:20 AM


My father lived through WWII. My father did not get his circumcision until he was able to come to the USA, and shortly after he arrived in his late teens he had the procedure done. He said his parents did not have it done to him due to the Nazi's awful way of pulling down little boys pants to see if they had the circumcision done or not.

(3) Hank Himmelbaum, May 27, 2010 12:30 PM

Acceptance of all Jews in Israel

Even in our precious Israel, there are Jew who are not recognized as Jews because some other Jew said they weren't Jewish enough. We need to learn to accept all Jews. I was once told that I am not a Jew, because I didn't rap Teffilin. I was insulted by this person, but I identified with being Jewish and I asked him to leave my space. We Jews need to be more accepting of all who identify themselves as Jews. I know I am growing spiritually and one day I may wrap Teffiln as a daily practice.

Anonymous, June 12, 2011 4:21 AM

Relationship with G_d

I think no one has a right to tell anyone what thier relationship with G_d is! No body knows where I am with the almighty. I believe I am not to judge anyone or myself. My job is to try to work on Torah the best I can with the tools given to me by G_d! Maybe I don't have the most advanced tools , but the tools I have make me appreciate the little details that make my relationship with G_d personal!

Steve, June 6, 2012 12:45 PM

Excellent All inspiring Holy.

(2) A, June 8, 2009 7:34 PM

was there any need for him to stay with Moshe?

Just as the people who converted in the times of Abraham & Sarah, and the converts who left Egypt during the exodus, I also questioned what happened with those who were with Yitro? was it even necessary for them to convert explicitly to Judaism? Would it not be enough to be a Noachide? in my Torah learning it was mentioned that before the exodus, Yitro's people also abandoned him for converting and he no longer had a following nor wealth to speak of, in Midian, the midianites were die-hard pagans, from our teachings, maybe he regained followers after the exodus from Egypt, I deduce that Yitro was just plain Righteous - and we may never know just why he returned. Moshe's Egyptian mother, Basya was also righteous, but left at Pesach and stayed with the Jews. Yitro's other gift, that earned him prominence, was of setting up a system of hierarchy to serve and judge from groups of 1000's down to groups of 10's - literally an amazing support system for life, not just for problem solving or difficult issues, but for constant everyday issues to give us an opportunity to question and grow through our own daily choices, now a days it's done by having different Rabbis for different issues, as a baal t'shuva never having been near Rabbis this is my toughest challenge in Judaism, 'getting a Rabbi and developing' this relationship. I think Yitro left us the most important legacy of all, that would keep us all so humble in our daily interactions and personal growth through Torah. I think there's more to Yitro than meets the eye. Once he put all this in place for Moshe, and probably didn't want to leave his daughter and grandsons anymore than any granpa would, he probably went back not just because he was homesick, but he too had work to do 'back home'. He wasn't going to abandon ship!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment