Vayigash(Genesis 44:18-47:27)

The Secret of Jewish Survival

Throughout the ages, many have been amazed at the Jewish nation's survival. Faced with a history of suffering, sorrow, and persecution, Jews have met adversity with strong resilience and fortitude. What is our secret? How have we maintained our distinctness and unique traditions? What has been the key to thwarting assimilation into the cultures of the nations? We can find a solution in a thought from this week's portion.

Perhaps the most dramatic story in all of Torah takes place in our Parsha. After being sold by his brothers and having been away for 22 years from his family, Joseph reveals himself. The brothers had been unaware that the Emperor who has been tormenting them, accusing them of being spies, jailing Shimon, and potentially taking Benjamin as a slave, is actually Joseph.

When Joseph says the words, "I am Joseph!" (Genesis 45:3), the brothers are dumbfounded and speechless. Joseph comforts them with a long monologue and expresses his forgiveness. He also gives the brothers instructions to bring Jacob down to Egypt.

Towards the end of these instructions, Joseph gives the directive, "Do not become agitated on the way" (45:24). Rashi explains this cryptic statement: "Do not become involved in a matter of halacha, Jewish law, (so that you don't get lost) and the trip does not become a source of anger for you."

Imagine. The brothers have just faced the shock of their lives in meeting Joseph once again. Wouldn't the brothers be contemplating their fateful, incorrect decision to sell Joseph so many years ago? Yet, Joseph is concerned that they would concentrate on Torah study and lose their way back home! Joseph seems to assume that the brothers would naturally turn to Torah study during their travels.

While it is true that there is a Mitzvah to study Torah as you travel, (see the "Shema" Prayer, Deuteronomy 6:7, "You shall speak of them -- the Torah -- while you sit at home and while you walk on the way",) who would be able to study at a stressful time of soul searching?

In addition, now they had to go back and face their father, Jacob, to whom they lied about Joseph all of these years. How would they be able to have the presence of mind to study Torah at such a difficult time?

Very often in Jewish learning, the question is the answer. The more you think deeply about a question, the more you repeat the question in your mind, the more you begin to realize that the question itself leads directly to the answer. The same is true here.

How could the brothers learn Torah during such troublesome times? How could they not? We all have various methods of relaxation that we engage in when we are stressed out. Some of us watch or listen to a ball game, others may listen to music. Pious and learned Jews relax through the study of Torah. Even under tremendous pressure, it was only natural for the brothers to search for mental calm in Torah study.

This is especially true given that the Torah is God's instructions for Life and the brothers were searching for specific Divine guidance as to how to deal with their current travails. They would only find it in serious Torah study.

Torah study has united Jews throughout history and has saved us from assimilation. This is truly the secret of Jewish survival throughout the millennia. To paraphrase Rabbi Saadia Gaon of the 11th century, the Jewish nation is only a nation and can only be a nation as a result of the Torah. We are not a nation based on land, language, or culture. If ever there would be a time when Jews would stop caring about the wisdom in the Torah, we would cease to be a nation and would quickly disappear to assimilation.

Amazingly, the Torah itself provides for its own continuity. The world at large has only begun to value education and literacy for the masses relatively recently, around 200 years ago, with the system of free public education. Until then, education was viewed solely as a pursuit for the elite of society. Many religions had special interest in keeping the masses uneducated so as to avoid questioning in their faiths.

Jewish education for the masses, however, goes back to the Revelation at Sinai. 3000 years ago, God commanded us to study Torah every day of our lives. Of course, in order to study, every single Jew had to know how to read and write. So, basic mass education was guaranteed. Torah study and intellectual pursuit was and remains our lifeblood from our very inception as a nation.

We want educated Jews. We do not fear or discourage questioning and discussion of our faith and tradition.

We believe that a Jew can only be a good Jew if he or she is engaged in serious and consistent Torah study. It is only then that we, 'The People of the Book,' can live up to our name.

Published: Saturday, December 15, 2001

Aish.com relies on your support. Click here to support us.

Visitor Comments: 5

  • (5) Norma F , December 29, 2008

    In hard time like this time.

    Aish spiritual is a place where good people, all peoples, can --if they want to-- digg some oxygen [inspired by the Torah]. What if your today's spiritual letter "The Secret of Jewish Survival" comes out in war time like this time? Jews are still struggling for their survival. Today's war i.e. Hamas v/s Israel is another form of agression that put Jews under "The secret of Jewish survival": Alliance for the Nation. In hard time like this time of war, we pray for The Lord to kindly protect the people of Isarel and enlighten violent mindset i.e. Hamas/Gaza to listen to His voice of Love, Peace, creativity, Truth, Justice and Equality. Thank you Aish for your effort!

  • (4) Edwin Vogt , January 1, 2006

    Mark Twain once invited the question of the survival of the Jew and had not contemplated its answer.It lies always in the study of Torah!Nothing physical can change the results; it is the realm of the spiritual that the Jew is sustained! Even after the horrific experience of the Holocaust (Shoah) when the survivors were liberated, many looked heavenward in praise and blessing to G-d!

  • (3) Elke Schuckmann , December 9, 2002

    Torah is life

    I am very impressed by this lesson of learning. I start learning three years ago with the help of Rav Dr. Benjamin Z. Barslai in Bremen/Germany at the University of Bremen. My backround is to go back to my Jewish roots and to reconstruct was was gone lost.

  • (2) reuben , December 9, 2002

    this ingredient is the jewish people

    thank you for your beautiful gift.

  • (1) Anniteh Shatz (Zahne) , December 17, 2001

    All the right answers!

    When people comment on how intelligent the Jews are, we can answer it is because we study Torah every day. Everyone should do the same.

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field
Submit Comment

About the Author

Rabbi Boruch Leff

Rabbi Boruch Leff is a vice-principal at Torah Institute in Baltimore and is the author of the Kol Yaakov column at Aish.com.
Author of the SHABBOS STIMULUS PACKAGE.
His book, "Forever His Students" (Targum/Feldheim) contains practical and powerful contemporary insights, inspired by the teachings of Rabbi Yaakov Weinberg, of blessed memory.


The book has a brand new topical thematic arrangement designed to better your spiritual growth. It also includes some essays and many explanatory footnotes that do not appear at aish.com.

He has written two more books since: Shabbos in My Soul, which describes 70 ways to experience a meaningful Shabbat, and a second volume More Shabbos In My Soul.


Save 15%
when you order directly from the author:
Buy Now - $23
Includes Free Shipping in the Continental US


***or***
Outside of the Continental US including Canada - only $31 - shipping included
Due to new rates established by the USPostal Service.

Features at Aish.com

Most Popular

  • 1.How To Get Your Prayers Answered

    Do you feel like you're talking to a wall when you pray? Here are five key tools for getting your prayers answered.

  • 2.How To Build Trust in Marriage

    When there is no trust in your marriage, you are headed for an abusive relationship or you may be in one already.

  • 3.Six Habits of Happily Married Couples

    Success in marriage hinges on consistent performance of six key habits.

  • 4.Sometimes

    It's mundane. It's magical. It's motherhood.

  • 5.Beshert

    How to really find your soul mate.

  • 6.What Is Love?

    Many people believe love is a sensation that magically generates when Mr. or Ms. Right appears. No wonder so many people are single. An excerpt from "Head to Heart."

  • 7.Star of David

    From the Holocaust to the Israeli flag, what is the deeper meaning of this six-pointed Jewish symbol?

Sponsors