click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Ha'azinu(Deuteronomy 32)

Status as a Symbol

The topics of repentance and Yom Kippur need not be all fire and brimstone. There is much about repentance that is positive, inspiring, and meaningful.

Maimonides writes:

"Each and every person has merits and transgressions. Whoever has more merits than sins is called a tzaddik - a righteous person. Whoever has more sins than merits is called a rasha - a wicked person. If someone has half and half, he is called a bainoni - a person in the middle. This applies to entire countries as well. If the merits of all of a country's inhabitants are more numerous than its sins, the land is called righteous, and if it has more sins than merits, it is called wicked. This applies to the entire world as well." (Laws of Repentance 3:1)

Rambam continues:

"A person who has more sins than merits will "miyad" (normally translated as "immediately," but we will discuss this point later) die as a result of his wickedness, as the verse states, "I have struck you ... because your sins were so many" (Yirmiyahu 30:14). Similarly, a country who has a majority of sins over merits will be destroyed "miyad" as it says (regarding Sodom), "The outcry against Sodom and Gemmorah is great" (Bereishit 18:20). The same is true regarding the entire world. If the whole world has more sins than merits, it is wiped out "miyad," as it states (regarding the Flood), "God saw that the evils of mankind had increased greatly" (Bereishit 6:5). (Laws of Repentance, 3:)2

There are a number of questions on the Rambam that we must ask:

  1. Why do we need both of these paragraphs? Don't they both say the same thing? The key is whether you have more merits than sins or vice versa and this gives you the status of righteous or wicked? Why the seeming repetition?

  2. The proof from Sodom appears to be a non-proof because if you continue in that verse it says: "I will descend and see if the outcry that has risen to Me has brought destruction and if not, I will know" (Bereishit 18:20). This indicates that Sodom was not wiped out immediately after it had more sins than merits. Rather, God was first evaluating if Sodom would be destroyed even though they had already earned the status of the wicked. What then do we make of this "proof"?

  3. We encounter the same problem regarding the verse of the Flood cited by Rambam. God does see "that the evils of mankind had increased greatly" (Bereishit 6:5) but He doesn't bring the Flood until much later, after Noach is commanded to build the ark which took 120 years (see Rashi 6:14) to build. How is this a proof that God punishes right after the world becomes laden with a majority of sins when it shows the opposite?

  4. There is the famous question asked by many: We know many wicked people that live long lives. If indeed the procedure is that God exacts punishment as soon as a person has more transgressions than merits, how could it be that these wicked people continue to live, year after year? And has there never been, since the time of the Flood or Sodom, a country (or even the whole world) that didn't have more sins than merits? Yet, we have not seen such countries become destroyed.

  5. Finally, Rambam himself writes further on (Laws of Repentance, 3:3) that God evaluates each individual's sins and merits every Rosh Hashanah and whoever is found to be a rasha - wicked - is "sealed for death," but he does not say that a rasha dies immediately. So how could he write differently here?

Due to all our questions, we must understand Rambam as follows. There are two points being made. In 3:1, Rambam is describing a person's status and reality of relationship with God. You are a tzaddik if you have mostly merits, with or without justice being carried out and with or without reward and punishment. You are defined as a rasha, a wicked person, whether God judges you with death and destruction or not.

In 3:2, Rambam describes the evaluation and judgment of those who have earned their individual descriptions in 3:1.

Judgment and the administering of justice do not happen on a constant basis. There are certain set times when God judges. One time of justice is after death, as Rambam describes later in Chapter 3. Another is on Rosh HaShanah. There are specific sins which bring about a judgment (see Talmud Brachot 55a with Rashi). Other times, God is drawn to judge and evaluate a person for reasons known only to Him. But just because a person is wicked by status does not mean he will be judged in the near future. And even if he is judged, he will die, as Rambam says, "miyad" which unlike popular opinion, does not mean immediately, but inevitably or necessarily. The death and destruction will occur when God has decided the proper time. But it does not happen immediately. First, a judgment must arise and then the punishment is determined but that punishment can take a long time to occur.

Concerning the Flood and Sodom, they had been called wicked for a period of time before God judged them and even then it was "an outcry" or specific injustice in Sodom (as with the Flood - see end of Parshat Bereishit for the story of the immoral relations between specific men and women that occurred then) that brought about its judgment. It took some time for the "miyad" and inevitability of the justice and destruction to present itself.

This may very well be the explanation as to why we haven't seen a nation become destroyed very often. God chooses not to sit in judgment against them, albeit they have the status of being wicked. As far as the entire world is concerned, God's promise to Noach (Bereishit 8:31) related this very idea. He made an oath that no matter how wicked the world would become in terms of status, He would never again sit in judgment over the entire world.

So, there are two concepts. There is justice, reward, and punishment and there is the status of being righteous or wicked. But what difference does the status make? We will see that it makes all the difference in the world.

Rambam writes:

"How great is repentance! It brings one close to God's Divine Presence... Yesterday, the sinner was hated by God, dirty, disgusting, abominable, distant, and today he is beloved, close, and a true friend of God's... Yesterday, he was separated from God... He would cry out and pray without being answered... He would perform commandments and they would be ripped up... But today, he is attached to God, he calls out and is answered immediately... He fulfills the commandments and they are accepted with great joy...and God desires his Mitzvot!" (Laws of Repentance 7:6-7)

Repentance not only saves one from punishment but it re-creates a strong bond between God and the one who is repentant. It transforms you from being called wicked, having your prayers ignored and your Mitzvoth deflected, to being called righteous and being a friend of God's. And who can ponder the amount of things one can accomplish if they are God's friend? The amount and power of Divine assistance one receives to accomplish all of one's goals would be immeasurable.

One need not only ponder reward and punishment when struggling with the approach of Yom Kippur and repentance. A main motivating factor should be the relationship and status one has in God's eyes. Does He view you as wicked or righteous? Are you beloved to Him or despised?

Nobody wants to be called wicked, especially by God. Repentance and the atonement of Yom Kippur restore our righteous status, as long as we do our part to repent sincerely.

September 9, 2002

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 2

(2) Yehudith Shraga, September 25, 2012 7:36 AM

"Miyad" sounds very much as From the Hand( of the Creator)

The article is intresting and has a very good message, but it seems that there is much more in the word- Miyad even without analysing the letters it consists of, it obviously sounds very much as"A person who has more sins than merits will "miyad" die=will die FROM THE HAND OF(THE CREATOR) as a result of his wickedness..." It also comes to teach us that we sometimes take on ourselves the right to judge who is worth and who isn't to live in this world, while Zohar haKadosh tells us that if we find a person the most unbearably disgasting and not worth living in our oppinion, we should always remind ourselves that as horrible as the person seems to us, if he is still alive it means that the Creator has His Plans for him, and it is a very important message for us to stay away from the "rightious" judgements of ours about others, we really have to mind our own correction and we may help others by organizing the groups for Torah study and letting people to be able to attend them, but we have to remember that the Divine Books of Life and Death have the Owner, and Ktivva=wrtting and Hatimma-signing and Bitzu'a-implementation are in the Hand( under the goverment) of the Creator, that is why it may be implemented in a moment( immediately) or after a period of time(but inevitably or necessarily), because Everything is in the Hands of the Heavens except of the Awe towards the Heavens. Gmar Ktiva veHatima Tova to all the People of Israel and to all the Creation, may we be written to the way of correction through the Torah and Mitzvot and not through the pain and suffering, Amen.

(1) Anonymous, September 15, 2007 10:11 PM

"It is not what your country can do for you but what you can do for your country." JFK

Hashem made a convenant with man never to flood the earth again by showing a rainbow. However, when I see the rainbow
it reminds me that Hashem has not stopped watching our deeds and we need to become mindful of what the impact is.
The sad story is people constantly test those who do believe to show that his existence is not going to stop them from harming others, or the earth.
So we stand at the foothill of our own destiny which lies in our hands. G-d has not betrayed man, man has betrayed G-d. And those who choose to do "good deeds" tzedukah and mitzvot no matter the faith will help heal I believe themselves and others.

After all you are doing a good deed by imparting yourself to others in educating them, I have learned a agreat deal when I taught 5th graders in Sunday School at the BCCJCG!

Thanks for letting me unload my thoughts.

Robin Forman

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment