click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Trumah(Exodus 25:1-27:19)

Supporting the Supporter

"Take for me an offering." (Exodus 25:2)

The donations requested of the Israelites for the construction of the Mishkan (tabernacle) are described as being "taken" rather than "given." What does that mean? Moreover, God is the Master of the Universe and all that it contains. Did He need contributions and materials from human beings to construct His Mishkan??

The purpose of the contributions was to enable the Jews to participate in the construction of the Mishkan. Thus the giving was in fact a receiving - "Take for me an offering."

The heads of the tribes responded to the call for contributions for the Mishkan by declaring that they would donate what was still needed after the rest of the Jewish people gave all that they could. In the end, all that was left to bring were the precious stones for the Ephod and the Choshen (breastplate of the High Priest), the oil and the spices for the incense, and the Menorah. The leaders were censured for conducting themselves in this manner and the letter yud was removed their title (see Exodus 32:27). Since they were prepared to contribute whatever was necessary, no matter how great, and did in fact contribute valuable items to the Mishkan, the question remains, however, why were they censured?

The leaders misunderstood the purpose of the giving. There was no "deficit to be made up." God has no deficit. The giving was an opportunity for self-development, the purification of one's soul through attachment to a holy undertaking. Approaching the Mitzvah as if God needs our contributions was ludicrous.

The Talmud (Baba Basra 10a) relates that the wicked Turnus Rufus once asked Rabbi Akiva, "If your God loves the poor so much, why then doesn't He provide for them?" Rabbi Akiva responded that God could easily provide personally for the poor, but He chose to give us the merit of giving tzedakah (charity) to save us from Gehinnom (netherworld).

For this reason, says the Midrash (Ruth Rabba 5:9), the poor person does more for the rich person than the rich person does for the poor person. When Naomi asked Ruth who had provided Ruth with the food she brought home that day, Ruth answered, "The man I did for today was named Boaz." Boaz provided her with what God could have provided Himself, but she provided him with a Mitzvah - a chance to be God-like by giving to another.

In this light, we can understand the words of Maimonides in his commentary to Avos (3:19), "All is judged according to the number of deeds." Maimonides explains that it is better to give one dollar of charity 100 times, than 100 dollars one time. The more times a person acts in a way that is meritorious and God-like, the more he conditions himself to the performance of Mitzvot and purifies his soul. Tzedakah is not performed for the poor person's sake, but rather to enable the giver to emulate God and merit Olam Haba.

So, too, with respect to the support of Torah institutions, as the Chafetz Chaim explains the verse in Proverbs (3:18), "It is a tree of life for those who grasp it, and its supporters are praiseworthy." The word lehachazik means both to support and to cling or to grasp. God could provide for the Torah institutions without any human help, but He chooses to funnel His support through human agents. Those agents must realize that their "support" for Torah is in fact support for themselves. When they recognize that, they will cling to their support for Torah institutions as one clings to a log in a raging river. For them, then, their support is a tree of life. Those who think that they are in fact supporting the Torah will also be rewarded - as God does not deny reward for any good deed - but for them Torah is not a tree of life.

The Chafetz Chaim himself was once approached by a wealthy benefactor who offered to underwrite the entire operating expenses of his Yeshiva in Radin, Poland. He politely refused. "I cannot permit you to monopolize the merit for supporting my Yeshiva and thereby deprive others of an opportunity to do so," he told the man.

The staves, with which the Holy Ark was carried, represent the supporters of Torah. They are an intrinsic part of the Torah community, inseparable from the Torah scholars, just as the staves could not be removed from the Ark. But those who carried the Ark were miraculously lifted off the ground and literally carried by the Ark itself. Their apparent support was in reality that which supported them.

After his marriage, Rabbi Eliezer Gordon, the founder of the Telshe Yeshiva, was supported by his father-in-law, Rabbi Avraham Yitzchak Neviezer, so that he could devote himself fully to Torah learning and develop into a Gadol (Sage). As his family began to grow, and he was offered various rabbinical positions, Reb Eliezer sought to relieve his father-in-law of this financial burden. He asked his permission to accept a rabbinical position and begin to support himself. Despite difficult financial times, Reb Avraham Yitzchak refused to permit him to do so. When Reb Avraham Yitzchak's wife asked him how long he intended to support their daughter and son-in-law's family, he responded, "My dear wife, who knows who is supporting whom..." Finally the prestigious rabbinical position in Eisheshok was offered to Reb Eliezer, and his father-in-law could no longer detain him. The day after the Gordon family left for Eisheshok, Reb Avraham Yitzchak died. It then became clear who had been supporting whom.

In this light, we can appreciate the significance of the deletion of the letter yud from the title of the leaders. With a yud, the word nesi'im (leaders) denotes "those who carry" Without the yud, the vowels can be rearranged to read nis'aim - those who are carried. The yud was removed to instruct them that, though they viewed themselves as making up the shortfall, they were in reality being carried by the merit of the Mitzvah.

The Sages tell us that we will be redeemed through the merit of tzedakah. May we recognize the great opportunity offered us when we are called upon to support Torah institutions and the poor, and thereby merit redemption.

February 21, 2004

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 8

(8) Yehudith Shraga, February 12, 2013 1:53 AM

The life isn't Purim, you know!

Torah speaks about Zevulun and Isaskhar agreement, as well as leaving Pe'ah of wheat, olives and grapes for poor and some other means to support the people in need, BUT giving Tzedakah ISN'T A BLIND PROCESS AT ALL, because the money the rich person owns isn't his, but is givin to him by the Creator, and so he is responcible of how he uses them including the Tzedakah. First, one should make sure, that his money are used for Torah support and not for the support who lives at the expence of importance of Torah study, second, "the poor" is the person who works day and night and still have no money enough to support himself and his family, and not those who think that to work is below their "Exceptional Origin", and that they and their families MUST BE PAID THEIR LIVING. There are a lot of problems around this point nowdays, and what was right for Galut is not right for the people who live in their own country, and for the supporter to be sure he is doing the right thing, a lot of investigation should be done on the "poor" or "Torah Institution" he/she is going to support, because as our Sages teach us, each who asks for the Tzedakah should be given it, but on PURIM only, so for the rest of the days of the year we have to THINK who we support and what make them poor.

(7) jerry solomon, January 31, 2011 3:56 PM

Good to disagree

I support FAIR SHARE. When there are freeloaders & moochers, I find nothing in scripture demanding that I pull their load. I am blessed by being able to support my Shul and do so, but resent those who step backwards.

(6) Carla, February 21, 2010 5:01 AM

Thank you

Thank you very much for the thorough and concise explanation. I am elated and very very thankful for the wisdom that has been imparted to me today. Please continue to do what you are doing enlightening others about this important wisdom. Thank you....

(5) Ronda, September 10, 2005 12:00 AM

Very enlightening

I am thankful to have come across this website and your insights. Thank you for contributing your time and wisdom so that others will receive blessings and personal development.

(4) richard, February 11, 2005 12:00 AM

very good

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment