It was a magical day, that day last winter at the beach. Just after a storm, the leaden gray skies were giving way to bright blue, the sun was beginning to warm the sand, and the waves were frosted with foam. On a whim, I had decided to take a few hours off and go down to the ocean with my 4-year-old son, Joey. The middle child, his soft, contemplative personality is often overpowered by his extroverted older brother and his precocious younger sister, so I was happy to be able to spend some time alone with him. While his brother would have been running into the water and throwing rocks, and his sister would have been busily discussing what sort of dress she wanted, Joey was content to sit quietly with me, watch the birds, and eat his Cheerios.
When a particularly brazen seagull stole an errant morsel, Joey, in his typical way, tilted his head and watched, with a puzzled half-smile on his face. Hesitantly, he threw a Cheerio and giggled as another bird swooped down. A few more Cheerios, a few more birds. A little more confident now, Joey stood up. No longer the introvert, surrounded by seagulls, he was the king amongst his adoring audience. As he threw out the Cheerios he would laugh as the birds stumbled all over each other to get them.
There we were, the Cheerio King and I, dancing and laughing on the desolate beach, amidst the seagulls and the cereal. I can't recall ever feeling so free.
When the bag was finished, he looked down and said sadly, "Bye everyone." And then, perhaps struck by the shimmering water, the scent of the ocean, or just the silliness of the situation, he put up his hands and started to dance, slowly. Silhouetted against the deep blue ocean and the marshmallow clouds, my very reserved son danced faster and faster, his head thrown back with laughter. Entranced by the radiant smile that had taken over his normally serious face, I, too, got up and started to sway. And there we were, the Cheerio King and I, dancing and laughing on the desolate beach to the sound of the crashing surf, amidst the seagulls and the cereal. I can't recall ever feeling so free.
I've been thinking a lot about the meaning of freedom lately.
In the ten years that I have been practicing medicine, I have noticed a curious trend. A large number of patients come in with specific complaints that I can not attribute to any medical illness -- chest pain, abdominal pain, sleep disturbance, low back pain -- all real physical symptoms that exhaustive work-ups do not find the source of. At first, I assumed it was my inexperience, but as test after test came back negative, I began to wonder if something else was happening. As I started listening to my patients less about the type of their pain, and more about the quality of their lives, a troubling fact began to emerge: stress and anxiety are rampant, and they manifest as almost any medical symptom.
I did not recognize the magnitude of the problem until I opened a practice in the middle of Beverly Hills.
A few months ago, a middle aged woman came to my office distraught that her hair was falling out in clumps. A high-level manager for the government, in her conservative suit she appeared competent and no-nonsense, not prone to histrionics, and indeed when I examined her head, there were patches of scalp showing. She denied symptoms of anemia, thyroid or dermatologic disease -- all common causes of hair loss, and a thorough workup, including scalp biopsy, revealed nothing.
When I asked her about stress she appeared indignant, as if I was implying this was all in her head, but she did state that her new boss was trying to sabotage her. Not at all convinced when I said anxiety could be the culprit and discussed stress reduction techniques, she left my office annoyed, no doubt to find a better diagnostician. It was only when she called me while relaxing on her vacation in Maui a few weeks later, and the hair loss had stopped, that she was convinced.
More recently, a young woman came to see me for the first time. Blond, thin, and fashionably dressed, she epitomized the Southern California stereotype. With an actor's magnetism, she had engaged the old people in the waiting room and was glowingly chatting. When her name was called, she stood up dramatically, flashed them a sparkling smile, and was led into my office. She had barely shut the door and turned around and the facade was gone.
Her eyes filled with tears, she mumbled, "I'm so sorry," and slumped into the chair. "I can't handle it, I can't keep it together. I'm a failure," she sniffled.
After a few deep breaths, she relayed her very familiar story. She had come to Los Angeles from the Midwest to "make it" in the film industry. Two years of auditions had yielded only rejection.
"…and now I'm having heart problems -- sometimes it beats so fast I can't breathe. I get shaky and my hands get numb." She looked up, her bright face now ashen. "Please help me, I'm so scared. I think I'm going to die."
Because occasionally young people do have arrhythmias that cause similar episodes and can lead to sudden death, I attached her to a 24° heart monitor. Not surprisingly, her palpitations corresponded not to any underlying cardiac condition, but rather to periods of emotional stress. She was having classic panic attacks.
A couple of weeks ago a banker in his early 40's came to see me. Perfectly coiffed, dressed in an expensive suit, he exuded power and prestige. He was concerned, he said, because he was having episodes of chest pain radiating down his left arm associated with shortness of breath and sweating. During the time he was telling me this, his cell phone rang twice, his beeper went off and his Blackberry buzzed. He had reason to be concerned; even I was so convinced he was having angina that I called a cardiologist friend and arranged for him to go directly to the hospital for tests. I was shocked that all the tests were negative -- this was not a heart problem.
What astounds me most is not that anxiety can masquerade as such a myriad of symptoms, but how common and insidious it is.
He came for follow-up a few days later and I told him this could all be due to stress. "Yeah," he began, "I was trying to hold it all together… so many clients, the mortgage, the kids…" At that point his cell phone rang and with clenched jaw, he answered. The frazzled look in his eyes told me what he was too busy to.
After hearing story after story like these, what astounds me most is not that anxiety can masquerade as such a myriad of symptoms, but how common and insidious it is. Daily, patients come in with similar weary tales.
As an internist, my main objective is to rule out physical causes of their symptoms, beyond that, all I can do is just listen. Frequently I refer to therapists, occasionally, when symptoms warrant, I prescribe anti-anxiety medicine.
What I have learned by listening to their stories is how complex the nature of freedom is. In a sun-drenched city, where there are over 9000 different drink combinations available at Starbucks, day after day, I see seemingly successful, productive people so imprisoned by stress and anxiety that their bodies are beginning to rebel. They do not have to wear veils, can choose their own president, and indeed customize a cup of coffee, but they are so miserable they can barely function.
So many choices, but is this freedom?
And if freedom is not about choices, what is it about?
These are a few questions I have been pondering lately.
I think back to that glorious winter's day at the beach with my little Cheerio King. Maybe it is less about answering every phone call and more about turning the phone off, and taking the time, every once in a while, to dance barefoot in the soft sand. I am beginning to think maybe it is not so complicated after all. Maybe freedom is simple, as simple as a bag of Cheerios and the warm sunlight.
(33) TMay, November 28, 2010 4:06 AM
Sabbath
The creator of the human being gave an instruction manual and in it it says a human being has to turn off one day a week on the sabbath and to turn off the cell phones, and the bosses' infinite demands, and the bad news. I also recommend to everyone that they get a dog or cat or more. I don't think the human being was designed to take what TV dishes out, the bad news of the planet 24/7 with channels emphasizing lack of unity, and our enemy plotting to take us around every turn, and catastrophes from hurricanes, to floods, to earthquakes, to forest fires, to drought and famine. Turn off the TV. Look at the story of Jacob. He thought he lost one son out of 12 and suffered during his life about it. Did he have non -stop TV always coming up with a story of someone's kidnapped child? No. Would he have lived to a ripe old age if he had been subjected to that? I doubt it. Also the watchword of Judaism is "Shema" for listen, not watch.
nina, September 15, 2015 8:48 AM
this is excellent!
I only read this now, you make some wonderful points!
(32) sonia, November 27, 2010 9:04 PM
It's the story of my life
I work as a clinical chemist in an emegency medicine home service. I see every day what you tell. I see kids that reflect their parent's fears, and get sick. I see anxious mothers, and grandmothers, and a world that tries to pop a pill to cure everything-including the lack of a life purpose. I'd love to read Dr. Yaris more often, she is so down to earth...
(31) Nathan, November 22, 2010 5:27 PM
Some stress can't be avoided
You speak of bankers, actors, executives. There are people who are unemployed, or getting minimum wage, yet have a family to support, perhaps a mortgage as well. It's nice to talk about tuning out and relaxing, but often stress comes from one's situation, not one's state of mind.
(30) Rochel, November 22, 2010 5:31 AM
Agree, and there is a solution --
Dr. Sarnos addresses this "epidemic" in his books, The Divided Mind, The Mindbody Prescription: Healing the Mind, Healing the Body, Healing Back Pain - The Mind-Body Connection. Basically he states that there are emotional or psychological issues that manifest as physical ailments, and that they CAN be dealt with AND "cured". I've met a number of people, and have heard of others who have followed his method and have helped themselves and are "ailment free" - whether it was knee pain, mono, IBS, or other pain. It needs to be acknowledged, and can be dealt with. It's really a miracle that we can be pro-active and helped and be pain free and be able to lead rich (pain free) lives! Thank you for at least acknowledging this phenomena.
(29) SusanE, November 21, 2010 11:56 PM
So Lovely to Read. Glad it is brought back for Today.
Thoroughly enjoyed learning from your article, the story is beautiful and the advice is spot on. I wasn't on Aish.com in 2004, so am very happy it's been discovered again. - I Twittered a link to the article tonight. Everyone can learn and benefit from your insights. Thank you for the beautiful story..
(28) Dr Ionah Estevez - Breton, November 21, 2010 11:15 PM
Bio-psycho-social approach is a good option
Hi. I am a Family Physician and I think Dr Yaris´ writing is very meaningful and I hope she can read this comment. Family Medicine studies medical problems with an integrative & bio-psycho- social approach. Like in Jewish thought, we consider human beings as the product of biological, psychic and socio-cultural elements. Under such consideration, every illnes can be studied taking into account all such types of causes to start with. I wish G-d may grant Dr Yaris the opportunity to know a little more about Family Medicine and about psycho-neuro-inmunology. It will surely be interesting for her.
(27) raizel, November 21, 2010 10:45 PM
delicious...
I live for those moments with my kids like you had with your son. And so poetically described. I was wishing I was there...
(26) Anonymous, November 21, 2010 8:57 PM
Anxiety, a choice...?
Dear "anonymous" and others, I don't know anyone who chooses to be anxious or sad... What in heavens name gives you and others this idea...? Perhaps because the struggle isn't as great for yourself...? YOUR ATTITUTE lends to yet more anxiety and stress for those of those who suffer. Get it..? Perhaps those who think like you should read up on anxiety disorders and on WHAT NOT TO SAY TO THOSE WHO ARE SUFFERING. I sincerely hope that you are never in "that" position. "Never judge someone until you have walked a mile in their EXACT shoes" P.S- why do you not display your name...?
(25) Anonymous, November 21, 2010 8:08 PM
freedom depends on trust
when you & your son were at the beach, experiencing the precious, beautiful moment you shared w/us, he trusted entirely that his every need would be met, that he was safe, that everything in that moment was as good as it could be, & that all was well; it was safe for him to feel the full wonder of that moment, to not have anymore cheerios & to express his glee by dancing, singing w/joy! it's contagious--& you followed suit. sadly, most of us have forgotten how to be children. many of us never really knew; & of these, how many are able, willing and/or open to grasping that G!d is the Source of everything--all the work, all the security/safety, all the meeting of needs [each & everyone of them]--& that when we're able, open & willing to surrender our lives to G!d's service, all of our needs are wondrously met, and we can, truly, be free because we trust! we learn to trust by learning to love--really love--ourselves & others, & to see that the Universe is a place of love. we must un-learn all the fear, all the anxiety, & all the myriad mis-perceptions, mis-conceptions, and mis-understandings about life, about relationships and why we're experiencing things. if you're willing to believe that each pain or ache, all symptoms/dis-ease is a message from G!d, a message which once received, can lead to healing or restoration of an inner harmony/balance, then life becomes different. similarly, when i'm willing to frame whatever happens as doing so for a reason, & that good can/will come from it provided i do my part, then life gets much better. it's about love, faith & trust; not fear. by letting go of fear & letting our lives be guided by love/faith, trusting Divine Guidance, we can be free! as free as your son--it's entirely possible. ask your rabbi!
(24) drbill, November 21, 2010 7:49 PM
The Shabbos cure?
I've been treating these same people with their psychosomatic disorders for thirty years. We both know that these "imprisoned" people for the most part are unable to find adequate alternative employment, although surely some are just too rigid to be adaptable and seek it. We need a nationwide study to show physical medicine and psychiatry that one true day of rest weekly is better than all the Valium prescribed. Should the study prove only that it helps but is not enough alone; then "Cheerio's moments" are a diversion to a profound socio-economic epoch, existing long before our current epochal economic woes. I believe in the power of Shabbos (in any religion) but we still need a large study to show if today we need also to seek further understanding of increasingly unlivable lives.
(23) ruth housman, November 21, 2010 6:22 PM
Cheerios are Heart Friendly!
This is a beautiful article and I so love the way you lead into this with your son, the Cheerios, the birds, and his dancing on the beach. Truly the King of Cheery itself. The "O's" in life have to do with living our lives, surely, taking time to walk the beaches, to "smell the roses", and yes, stress is taking its toll. I love that you make this analogy to freedoms and how we take away from our freedoms by being so stressed, in work choices, in attitude choices, that leave little room for sunshine in our lives. We all need to breathe, and breath itself, is ruah!
(22) Anonymous, November 21, 2010 5:08 PM
stress.....it's part of life....
" Shalvat Hanefesh " (peace of mind), is the goal to strive and work toward. There's love, contentment, lonliness and all of life's challenges but if one strives to have peace of mind, one would learn to tone down rather than work up life's difficulties and stresses.
(21) unlisted, November 21, 2010 4:46 PM
G-d gave us solutions to stress-- not mentioned in story
The issue is not "freedom." For a Jew, the issue is understanding where all of life's challenges come from. That's one reason why G-d gave us Shabbos. And it's not just a nice thing to consider doing; for a Jew, Shabbos is a mitzvah (obligation)! That's also why we're taught to have emunah and do everything b'simcha (with joy). Everything that happens to us is caused by G-d, and is ultimately for good! I'm sorry the MD didn't address the JEWISH answers to these issues.
(20) Anonymous, November 21, 2010 3:03 PM
thanks, dr. jackie
beautiful article. profound.
(19) Anonymous, November 21, 2010 2:28 PM
Our choices
A friend of mine once told me that "freedom is having the ability to choose to do the right thing." It seems that the folks in the article above were choosing to do the wrong thing, and suffering the effects of their choices. We can choose our actions; but, we can't choose the consequences of our actions.
(18) Anonymous, June 3, 2005 12:00 AM
Good Doctor
It is so nice to read a story about a doctor who really cares and puts in the effort to rule out a physical problem in her patients instead of just telling them that it is stress. It is so true that stress can cause a person a lot of physical pain. I know.
(17) Joseph A. Cleary, May 16, 2004 12:00 AM
I loved the story, it really moved me.
It just goes to show you you're never to old to learn something, stress.
Shalom, Shalom, Yoseph of Oklahoma
PS I also want to thank you for writing this, it helps.
(16) Shloimie, May 14, 2004 12:00 AM
Cheerio King--terrific article
I enjoyed your essay so much that I printed copies and gave them to several friends. One friend, a rebbi at a girls' high school in the five towns area, included it as part of his lesson yesterday. About 60 girls in two classes were enthralled with the story and took home copies to share with their families.
(15) rachel lasry, May 9, 2004 12:00 AM
halevy there wud be so many doctors like u!!
i read this article on the perfect night, my night was giving me real heart problems i was stressed out as u wud put it.
the story abt ur child on the beach really got me thinkign, all of us busy ppl need to just enjoy nature and laugh and be as carefree as a young child playing w his cherrios on the beach. why does it have to take a doctor to prescribe freedom????????!!!!! god gave us this beautiful world to enjoy and to make use of - i hope all of us this summer enjoy every bit of it!! thanks for writing this.
(14) Bracha Goetz, May 6, 2004 12:00 AM
Your article was wonderful! I recently came up with this definition for freedom - "a soul in control."
(13) Ludwig, May 6, 2004 12:00 AM
Terrific article
Jackie:Our compliments to your writing talent and hats off to your sensitivity as a physician.Wish we had you as our internist here in New-York Metro area.Keep up the beautiful work,Melitta and Dick(Ludwig)
(12) Dena Gottlieb, May 5, 2004 12:00 AM
Well Said!!!
Good point. Thank you!
(11) Anonymous, May 5, 2004 12:00 AM
Thank You
Your article is so true, I see it everyday in the form of musculoskeletal complaints, mostly. You certainly articulate the point beautifully.
Sincerely,
Mark L. Stutman, DC, Baltimore Md.
(10) Joseph, May 5, 2004 12:00 AM
shalom and todaravah dear Aish
kol tuv
Thank you very much
(9) Alex Talkar, May 4, 2004 12:00 AM
Very nice and meaningful aricle
I think we should keep time for hard work and time for relaxation too. This relaxation could be in the form of anything that gives us pleasure say for example feeding pets, strolling on beaches, sharing and careing, visiting the sick etc. but the most important of all is regular Prayer and reading King David Plasm's as per our convinence will surely help to keep us and our family away from all sort of sickness.
Thank you for your article.
(8) Anonymous, May 3, 2004 12:00 AM
We Can Learn So Much From Our Little Children
A very nice article, Jackie. For me, it once again pointed out just how wise our 3 and 4 year olds can be and how, even as doctors, lawyers and Indian Chiefs, we can still learn so much from them. If only we took the time to listen to them, to notice what they do. Sometimes, they know what's what far more than we do.
(7) Anonymous, May 3, 2004 12:00 AM
beautifully written article
Dr. Yaris writes so eloquently. It's a pleasure to read her descriptive writing.
(6) Anonymous, May 2, 2004 12:00 AM
Thank you
Thank you for a wonderful article. If only people would listen to your stress diagnosis and tell their friends, and if only places like Starbucks would stop putting yet more choices into our ever more stressful daily lives.
Thank you also for your insight into the lives of little children. Now I want to find a beach to take my son to, with a bag of cheerios of course!
(5) Anonymous, May 2, 2004 12:00 AM
Shalom, we need peace and take time too pull our self way and this is something we all need to learn, this world is not nice at times.
Thank you, I was looking for something to bring to my friend who's nece is staying with her for a week who has had a bad bolt with her job and is feeling under the weather. I will bring this to her and pray it will ligther up her days and she will be given the wisdom to know what she should do.
Hope the speling is ok.
(4) Beverly Kurtin, May 2, 2004 12:00 AM
The phone doesn't ring
How lovely to see a doctor (your mother must be so proud) spill the beans on stress and anxiety. I have seen many of my generation go to an early grave because of stress. Stress in some offices I frequent is so prevalent that it can be felt when one simply enters the room.
The simple art of doing nothing seems to have gone the way of the do-do bird. Just sitting in semi-silence (the world has its own noises, yes?) would drive most people so far up a wall that they’d have no need for a door. What a shame.
As I sit here in Texas, all I am hearing is the clicking of my keyboard, the hum of the electric fan, and birds in my backyard raising a lovely racket. Oh, and two of the cats that allow us to live with them just meowed too. Neat sounds.
My TV hasn’t been on all day! It usually isn’t on unless there’s something I want to watch. That drives most of my friend crazy, they MUST have the sound “for the background noise.” They try to turn it on, but to no avail. It takes flipping a switch to supply power to the contraption before it can be turned on.
After having a series of life-threatening events, I decided to retire rather than die. Now I work for myself and simply don’t allow stress producing situations to occur. Heck, I don’t even answer my telephone unless I want to.
Want to drive someone nuts? Just let your phone ring sometime. They’ll strain to keep themselves from answering your phone. My cell phone is currently on, but the ringer is turned off. I simply don’t want to be disturbed right now; I’m enjoying myself too much.
By the way, doc, my blood pressure is 119/55 at the moment and I’m not taking any blood pressure meds. It’s just from relaxing and kicking back. Life is good!
(3) jennifer, May 2, 2004 12:00 AM
de-stress
Prescribe massage therapy!
(2) Bonnie, May 2, 2004 12:00 AM
A heart of worship
What came to mind as I read of your Cheerio King dancing in the sand, is that even at four, he experienced freedom of worship--that point where we aren't influenced by anything around us but the knowing G-d is there and is touchable. As you joined him, it was there for you as well. And it is the best medicine there is: Praise G-d!
(1) Anonymous, May 2, 2004 12:00 AM
Mixed up priorities=stress
Cheerios...those perfect little circles offer insight into more than just your cereal bowl...as for stress, it's a state of mind... yes, we have the freedom to choose, but our priorities are mixed up!