The government of Canada recently issued an official apology – and acknowledged awarding an "undisclosed" sum of money – to Toronto-born Islamist terrorist Omar Khadr for his "ordeal" at the U.S. military base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and "any resulting harm" he was caused by the "torture" (specifically, sleep deprivation, solitary confinement and threats) that led to his confession.
On July 7, Canadian Foreign Minister Chrystia Freeland and Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Ralph Goodale released a statement announcing the "hope that this expression, and the negotiated settlement reached with the Government, will assist him in his efforts to begin a new and hopeful chapter in his life with his fellow Canadians."
The civil settlement was reached with Khadr, 30, who was 10 when his family returned to the Middle East, and 15 when he was arrested fighting in Afghanistan with al Qaeda and the Taliban, the terrorist organizations to which his father was affiliated – on the basis of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Omar Khadr
In 2003, Khadr confessed to throwing the grenade that killed U.S. Special Forces Sgt. 1st Class Christopher Speer and caused Sgt. 1st Class Layne Morris to lose an eye. Years later, he retracted his confession, claiming it had been extracted under duress. In fact, it was part of a plea deal that enabled him to be extradited to Canada to serve the rest of his sentence there.
With news of the large settlement he received – 10,500,000 Canadian dollars (approximately USD $8,000,000) – he gave an extensive interview to CBC's Power & Politics host Rosemary Barton, in which he said he thinks that the apology from the Canadian government "restores a little bit my reputation here in Canada, and I think that's the biggest thing for me." He declined to comment on having just received multi-millions in tax-free dollars.
Sgt. Christopher Speer
He also had the effrontery to say that he just wants "to be a normal person" and finish his nursing degree to help under-served communities. "I have a lot of experience with... and appreciation of pain," he explained, expressing only sorrow that the Speer and Morris families consider him responsible for their own pain.
Amid harsh criticism against the Liberal government by opposition Conservatives and members of the public outraged that their tax dollars are going to a convicted terrorist, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau responded to reporters' questions on the matter during a press conference marking the July 8 close of G20 summit in Hamburg.
The public is outraged that their tax dollars are going to a convicted terrorist.
Trudeau said that the settlement had nothing to do with Khadr's 2002 actions on the battlefield in Afghanistan, but rather with the fact that his rights had been violated. This is precisely what the Canadian Supreme Court ruled in 2008 and 2010, after Khadr's lawyers sued for damages.
Trudeau added that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects all Canadians, "even when it is uncomfortable. When the government violates any Canadian's Charter rights, we all end up paying for it."
Meanwhile, Goodale tried to evade responsibility, by casting aspersions on the previous government, headed by Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper, in power when Khadr was returned to Canada in 2012 to serve the remainder of his prison sentence for five counts of war crimes. Goodale accused Harper of having "refused to repatriate Mr. Khadr or otherwise resolve the matter."
In spite of the fact that Khadr was arrested and detained when Liberal governments were in power in Canada, Goodale was referring to appeals during Harper's tenure – which began in 2006 – by Canadian Liberal and human rights lawyers to "bring Omar Khadr home."
In 2008, former Canadian Justice Minister Irwin Cotler wrote: "I join other scholars and associations of jurists in calling for Omar Khadr to be transferred into the custody of Canadian law enforcement officials, to be afforded due process under Canadian law, with prospects for appropriate rehabilitation and integration."
Cotler also stated, "Admittedly, the Khadr family has emerged, as some have put it, as synonymous with terrorism. But, the test of the rule of law is not its application in the easy cases, but its retention in the unpopular ones... Omar Khadr, a child victim, should now be afforded the justice denied him all these years, however unpopular and unpalatable his case may appear to be."
"Has any soldier who fought FOR Canada ever received as generous a reward as this soldier who fought against us?"
In response to Goodale's implication that had it not been for the previous government, the current one would not have been forced to apologize to and pay Khadr, Harper immediately took to social media, writing:
The government today attempted to lay blame elsewhere for their decision to conclude a secret deal with Omar Khadr. The decision to enter into this deal is theirs, and theirs alone, and it is simply wrong. Canadians deserve better than this. Today my thoughts are with Tabitha Speer and the families of all Canadian and allied soldiers who paid the ultimate price fighting to protect us.
Canadian Senator Linda Frum railed against the settlement, tweeting: "Has any soldier who fought FOR Canada ever received as generous a reward as this soldier who fought against us?"
Given Khadr's family history, Frum's fury is justified.
As the New York Post reported, Khadr is the son of a Palestinian mother and an Egyptian father (Ahmed Khadr), who had strong ties to the Muslim Brotherhood, and became one of Osama bin Laden's loyal lieutenants. After 9/11, Ahmed Khadr was placed on the FBI's most-wanted list in relations to the attacks. He was arrested in Pakistan in 1995 on suspicion of financing the suicide bombing at the Egyptian Embassy in Islamabad, in which 16 people were killed. Protesting his innocence, he went on a hunger strike, and the Canadian government, then headed by Liberal Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, rallied behind him.
While on a trade mission to Pakistan, Chrétien appealed to Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, and a few months later, Ahmed was released from prison and sent back with his family to Toronto. However, according to the New York Post, the Khadr clan soon returned to Pakistan, where Ahmed Khadr resumed his connections with al Qaeda and the Taliban. Young Omar Khadr not only met with the leaders of these terrorist groups, but lived with his parents and siblings in the bin Laden family compound, attending al Qaeda training camps, which his father – who was killed in 2003 – partly funded.
The report continued:
"A month before he joined an al Qaeda cell in 2002, Omar was sent by his father for private instruction in explosives and combat... [where he] learned to launch rocket-propelled grenades and became skilled at planting improvised explosive devices that were used to blow up US armored vehicles in Afghanistan."
In his interrogation about the incident that led to his arrest and subsequent incarceration at Guantanamo, Omar Khadr said he had been on a suicide mission "to kill as many Americans as possible."
In this still image taken from a video found in the rubble of the compound where Omar Khadr was captured on July 27, 2002, a 15-year-old Khadr constructs an improvised explosive device. (Courtesy U.S. Defense Operations/Wikimedia Commons)
This did not prevent the U.S. military from flying an ophthalmologist to the Bagram Air Base – where was being treated for wounds he sustained while fighting American and Canadian soldiers – to save his eyes and keep him from going blind.
Nor did it cause Omar to experience gratitude on the one hand, or remorse on the other. On the contrary, as military court documents revealed, when he was informed that Speer had died, he said he "felt happy" for having murdered an American. He also said that whenever he remembered killing Speer, it would make him "feel good."
According to a report in the Globe and Mail, the Toronto lawyer representing Morris and Tabitha Speer – who won a default judgment in 2015 in the U.S. against Omar for $134 million – began proceedings to contest the Canadian government's settlement and prevent it from going forward.
It is clearly too late for that; the money has already been transferred to Omar. Furthermore, the transaction was done swiftly and "quietly," to make legal action by taxpayers in Canada or the Morris and Speer families in America virtually impossible.
Morris is understandably angry and hurt. "The fact is Chris Speer and myself were fighting with Canadians in Afghanistan," he said.
"We were alongside the PPCLI (Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry). There was a Canadian flag flying along with the American flag at our base there, so it's quite a thing that now Canada is giving millions to a guy who would attack a compound where Canadians were serving. I don't see this as anything but treason... As far as I am concerned, Prime Minister Trudeau should be charged."
Thus far, the administration in Washington has remained silent on Khadr pay-out, which came to light during the weekend of the G20 summit in Germany, where the leaders of the G20 signed the "Statement on Countering Terrorism."
Its 21 clauses include a commitment to "address the evolving threat of returning foreign terrorist fighters ... from conflict zones such as Iraq and Syria and remain committed to preventing [them] from establishing a foothold in other countries and regions around the world," and to "facilitate swift and targeted exchanges of information between intelligence and law enforcement and judicial authorities... [to] ensure that terrorists are brought to justice."
Such words are empty without actions to back them up. Omar Khadr is a classic example of a "foreign terrorist fighter." Yet the Canadian legal system categorized him – in Cotler's words – as a "child victim, [who] should... be afforded the justice denied him all these years."
It is bad enough to describe a teenager who set out to "kill as many Americans as possible" in this way. It is far worse that he is a free – and still very young – man, paid not only respect by the government whose values he was raised to abhor, but millions of dollars, to boot. If anything serves to encourage other terrorists to leave North America and Europe to fight in the Middle East, it is stories such as this one.
Ruthie Blum is the author of "To Hell in a Handbasket: Carter, Obama, and the 'Arab Spring.'"
This article originally appeared in www.gatestoneinstitute.org/
(10) jacques villeneuve, March 18, 2020 11:41 PM
Obama & Trudeau! same cut of cloth!
I was born and raised in a French Canadian family in 1943! I converted to Judaism in 1988! I have both a Canadian and Israeli passport as I did Aliya in 2001! We question why the coronavirus If I am disgusted with this incident that took place, why would I question the motives of Hashem! In the Torah, with the incident of the Golden Calf?
Moschia ben Yosef!
(9) Steve Brenner, January 19, 2020 6:42 PM
Canada is too Liberal!! Please Remember Canada does not back or support the
Canada is Rotten! We need to get out of The United Nation’s and only Protect the United States ?? of America and The State of Israel ?? our only Country that helps and supportive of our USA ??! Israel gives us intelligence information on the entire world!
(8) Marion, July 20, 2017 2:11 PM
I agree
I agree with paying him out. If we compare him to Harris and Klebold who were only a little older but who had the same end goal: Harris and Klebold weren't raised in an environment where they were indoctrinated, brainwashed, and drilled into them what America has done to Afghanistan, Iraq etc and how it was morally their responsibility to right it or they were going to hell. No, they and they alone chose to hurt and kill as many people as possible and damn the consequences. Omar... Oh boy. His dad most likely indoctrinated him since he was a toddler about how he was morally responsible if he didn't fight and was going to hell. He was fifteen when he threw the grenade and fifteen when he was sent to Gitmo, which isn't an appropriate place for anyone, let alone a minor. So yeah, pay him out.
(7) Katie, July 19, 2017 10:49 PM
Ms Blum has missed half the story
Ms Blum has conveniently ignored several facts in this story. One is that a juvenile Canadian citizen, a child soldier, was detained illegally for years and the Canadian government did nothing. Another is that Omar Khadr has repeatedly expressed his disagreement with his family about violence and terrorism.Teenagers are young and impressionable. Most of us would make choices now quite different from those when we were 12 or 13 or 18 years old. He studied and read under a university professor during his time at Guantanamo (late teens/early 20s) which reformed many of his beliefs.
As for the payout amount, there are many Canadians who are shocked (and not a little unhappy) at the amount but not necessarily with the apology. It is unfortunate that the Aish opinion survey did not offer a third option. The PM's reason for the $10M is that a court case "would have cost taxpayers $40 M so this was the cheaper option."
Michael, there are many Canadians who don't want to put a toe into your country under the current administration either!
Lee, July 20, 2017 8:40 AM
Settlement
The Canadians who buy Trudeau's rationale about saving money - and truly they are very few and very far between - are short on critical thinking skills. There are about 20 million taxpayers. The 10.5 million payout plus Goodale's reported 5 million in legal fees adds up to 75 cents per taxpayer. A tally of 40 million (20 million for Khadr's requested amount plus that much again in legal fees) would be 2 bucks per person.
The $1.25 difference per taxpayer was not worth capitulating over. Trudeau is like a kid in a candy shop when it comes to spending on travel, retreats, holidays, etc etc. Only the very naive would swallow his "fiscal responsibility" rationale.
Various polls have said that 71 percent of all Canadians disapprove of this deal. I don't know where you are getting your info about people being okay with the apology from.
Alexander, July 24, 2017 4:52 PM
Settlement
Lee's tearing apart Trudeau's rational is supported by the method of the settlement - secret , hidden from tax payers. Why are we working so much more intelligent liberals can squander money...
(6) Lee, July 18, 2017 11:00 PM
There are so many layers to this situation, but it is awful that Canada is not learning from this horrible case by having the right conversations for the future. One can have some modicum of sympathy for a kid dragged by a zealot father to take part in a terrorist fight, but to apologize and compensate, it's too much. As conservative pundit Margaret Wente wrote in the Globe and Mail, many Canadians feel that the right to return to Canada to make a fresh start is compensation enough for a person who spent the vast majority of his life outside of Canada, taken by his father to Pakistan/Afghanistan for most of his life, and had never really absorbed the lifestyle and values of a true Canadian citizen.
Trudeau's execution of this deal is despicable. The case should have gone through a full trial in the Supreme Court, it is just bad and wrong to cut a deal - especially since Parliament is not in session and Trudeau could not be questioned by opposition members. He also refused to hold onto payment until the widow of the American medic could file a motion in Canadian court, having been awarded over 130 million in the US from Khadr (she filed a claim for just this scenario, wanting to get some form of restitution if Khadr should ever win money.)
I donated a small amount to speerkids.ca as a gesture to the Speer family.
While this case is terrible as truly, the culpability of a minor whose parents brainwashed and brutally used him (what kind of mother allows her child into a terrorist battle?) is very complex, but Trudeau's refusal to learn and to allow the stripping of Canadian citizenship of dual citizens convicted of terror is so alarming. It wouldn't have affected Omar, as he was born in Canada, but his father could have been affected for his part in the embassy bombing. People who actively participate in terrorism have obviously got citizenship through fraud; I don't know why Trudeau feels it's noble to refuse to acknowledge that fact.
(5) Liliana, July 18, 2017 9:08 PM
It is appalling that the Canadian government release him and gave him such a large amount or any money at all as compensation. What about the victims of his atrocious act, or future victims for that matter.
Liliana
(4) Liliana, July 18, 2017 9:03 PM
It is appalling!
(3) Rachel, July 18, 2017 3:22 PM
Good for Canada
Under international law, child soldiers are regarded as victims. This is Canada following its domestic due process. The law protects everyone from civil rights abuses by zealous governments in time of war.
Michael, July 19, 2017 3:59 AM
A Humiliating, Dangerous Precedent for Canada
I’ll repeat this from a previous response … a Delta Force medic is dead, killed by this Taliban terrorist. Several other Soldiers are wounded, one blinded, also by his actions. For truth in lending, I’m a former US Soldier who lived in Alaska twice and served with Canadian forces in Germany, the Middle East and Africa. I won’t bore you with the details. Suffice to say I’ve spoken at funerals, buried friends, and there is/was a base in the Middle East named after a friend and colleague.
I don’t know you, but wonder if you would like to define your general frame of reference; how old are you, where are you from (Canada?), what is your education, where have you travelled, and do you have any experience at all about this topic? Finally, for a specific frame of reference; have you ever seen a woman beaten in the street or have you ever seen someone you know killed, or anyone for that matter? I suspect you are speaking from a position of sublime, spoiled ignorance. Probably to the point that I shouldn’t waste my time responding to you. But I will do so for the others reading this article.
I will say this as a matter of context and for you to measure the effect of this travesty. Despite my friendship throughout my life with Canadians, and regardless of your laws that allowed this, I will not visit Canada while your current Prime Minister is in power. Despite my Love for Quebec (I ran the marathon there), I will ensure that I don’t contribute one dime to Canada. Nothing. I think that this episode is appalling, a humiliating embarrassment, and sets a very dangerous precedent for Canada.
(2) Mordy, July 18, 2017 3:20 PM
Irwin Cotler's Bleeding Hart
Irwin Cotler, former Canadian Liberal Justice Minister, stated in 2008, "Omar Khadr, a child victim, should now be afforded the justice denied him all these years." Child victim? He was 15 when he murdered Christopher Speer, and had been brought up in the compound of Bin Laden and shared his radical views, as Khadr himself said he was sent "to kill as many Americans as possible." What about the true victims, the widow and her children, and the man who lost an eye? "Woe to those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for light and light for darkness." (Isaiah 5:20) Don't forget that it was Cotler who as Justice Minister tabled legislation allowing for same-gender marriages. After all, equal rights for all, even when it goes against Judaism and good 'ol common sense.
(1) Earl Gardner, July 18, 2017 3:08 PM
This payout is an afront to all Canadian Veterans who served our Country.
As a retired Jewish Canadian Army Officer, I am disgusted and ashamed of the Liberal Government for this payout and apology. My feelings are shared by every veteran and serving soldier I know, and there are hundreds if not thousands among my social circle. To my American comrades, I apologize for this shameful act by a Government that I hope will get voted out in the next Federal Election.
Anonymous, July 19, 2017 4:01 AM
Thanks Brother
Thanks for your support and sentiment. See my comment to the individual above. I'm truly sorry that I had to say that.