A friend of Lucy Letby, 30, described her as seeming “like a kindhearted person.”
The comment was offered last week after Ms. Letby, who had worked as a nurse at the Countess of Chester Hospital in northwest England, was charged with the murder of eight babies and the attempted murder of 10 others in the hospital’s neonatal unit.
The hospital conducted an internal inquiry after an inordinate number of premature babies had suffered heart and lung failure since 2016.
Ms. Letby not only worked at the hospital’s neonatal unit but had been active in a fundraising campaign to build a new one, expressing her hope that it would “provide a greater degree of privacy and space.” In retrospect, her desire for privacy reads somewhat less innocently than it must have seemed at the time.
If the charges against Ms. Letby shock you, that’s understandable; they are shocking. But they should not be surprising. We’ve seen this horror before.
In 2002, for instance, Charles Cullen, a nurse who had worked in hospitals in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, told investigators that he had ended the lives of 30 to 40 patients over 16 years in order to “alleviate pain and suffering.”
Other known medical personnel killers include Beverley Allitt, an English nurse who murdered four children and tried to murder another three in 1991; Massachusetts nurse Kristen Gilbert, who also murdered four patients and attempted to murder another two; and Donald Harvey, an orderly who claimed to have murdered 87 patients in hospitals in Kentucky and Ohio.
There are others.
Though some of the medical facility murderers may have been mentally deranged, some clearly saw themselves as “angels of mercy,” doing the right thing by dispatching people, even babies, whom they saw as facing lives that the killers felt were not worth living.
Believing Jews are guided by the Torah, not the zeitgeist, and we see the life of a human being as on an entirely different plane.
Unfortunately, larger society is increasingly seeing things very differently. It has begun to follow the path of Professor Peter Singer, the Princeton philosopher who is well-known for his advocacy of active, legal euthanasia for severely handicapped infants and the elderly.
Professor Singer, who heads the university’s Orwellianly named Center for Human Values, has characterized human infants as the moral equivalent of animals. “The life of a newborn,” he has written, “is of less value than the life of a pig, a dog or a chimpanzee.”
Asked by The New York Times several years back what idea, value or institution that the world takes for granted today he thinks may disappear in the next few decades, the professor responded: “The traditional view of the sanctity of human life.”
Unfortunately, the vanishing act, with no small amount of help from Professor Singer, seems well underway.
In the United States, physician-assisted suicide is legal in ten jurisdictions, and according to a 2018 Gallup poll, fully 72 percent of Americans favor legalizing it. It is already legal in Canada, Switzerland and a number of other countries.
Including the Netherlands, where a 15-year-old with parental consent can enlist a doctor’s help in killing herself; and if she can just wait until her sixteenth birthday, her parents will have no say in the matter. Nor need she be suffering any terminal medical condition; “emotional” pain is enough.
Some Dutch doctors, moreover, are reportedly known to choose, on their own, to “terminally sedate” patients in pain – that is to say, administer a dose of a narcotic that will not only alleviate pain but bring about death.
All in the name of mercy. After all, what good is a life if one is severely health-compromised, or very old or immobile? Or when a condition is “terminal”?
Such “merciful” folk might wish to ponder the plight of those with 23rd chromosome pair syndrome, which is invariably fatal.
Sufferers are susceptible to a host of maladies, including heart disease, high blood pressure, asthma and various cancers, and they are likely to suffer bouts of depression over the course of their lives.
They are also prone to headaches, nosebleeds, painful joints and broken bones. At some point, they can become so disabled that they require others to care for them.
The syndrome is quite common.
It’s what we call normal human life.
It merits mercy, to be sure. But expressed as preserving – not ending – it.
(4) Emma, December 17, 2020 10:41 PM
Interesting article but maybe you could've waited until when and IF the nurse in question is actually proven guilty in a court of law? I thought someone so concerned with the sanctity of life might also be aware of innocent until proven guilty yet nowhere do I see you allude to the fact she has not yet been proven to be a baby killer. She very well may have done this but the fact is we don't yet know what any of the evidence is that the police think they have and they have been wrong before. The unit was a mess and very badly run. It could be she is a scapegoat for a failing unit and no babies were murdered at all, or that another member of staff did it. I think I'll wait until after the trial or if she pleads guilty to condemn her!
(3) Anonymous, December 2, 2020 8:28 PM
Well-said and much needed
The culture of death, exemplified by abortion, is spreading. Glad you mentioned the abhorrent Peter Singer. Others waiting in the wings include Ezekiel Emanuel MD, whose name and credentials are an affront to education and to the Almighty. Thank you, Rabbi.
(2) Anonymous, November 24, 2020 9:54 PM
We have to have the same respect for human life in our response to COVID
I agree with everything Rabbi Safran wrote, which is why I don't understand why elements of the orthodox community have not been zealously careful reagrding Corona safety. I have 92 year old parents, and my worst nightmare is that they may become infected. As much as we keep them as isolated as possible, their caregivers still need to take public transprtation and go out for some necessities.. Every indoor minyan without masks, every wedding with too many people, increases the chance that someone will infect my parents directly or indirectly. Where is the respect for preserving life that the author advocates in this article?
Rachel, November 25, 2020 1:31 AM
Thank you— and nursing burnout is also real
I live in a Modern Orthodox community and social distancing, masks, etc are required to attend minyan. As long as the weather holds, outdoors minyanim are also being held.
I have attended 3 Zoom weddings this year.
As for the article— I think there are different things going on in different instances. Murdering newborns is awful. So is pushing for laws allowing medical suicide by anyone.
But I have a family member in nursing school. They are exhausted from the work and from struggling to help people survive, some of whom are miserable and in great pain. If you have spent time with a terminally ill person, you know how many suffer terribly. Now imagine working every day with the dying, and see if you still want to preach about the sanctity of life. No one’s life should be taken intentionally. However,DNR orders are a matter of letting nature take its course. Likewise, every patient should be entitled to maximum pain relief.
Finally, I respectfully suggest that the Orthodox world should do more to promote a life long healthy lifestyle,including moderate eating habits, sufficient exercise, and vaccinations.
Nancy, November 25, 2020 11:29 AM
Perhaps we need to remember that each patient is an individual
Rachel mentioned nursing burnout. I imagine physicians feel it as well. When someone is burnt out and exhausted how can they be objective? I would like to believe that the nurse in the article is the exception way more than the rule.
Rachel, November 25, 2020 1:31 PM
All health care providers
I focused on nurses bc that was most addressed in the article, but yes, others are also affected.
(1) Anonymous, November 24, 2020 11:54 AM
I have a question
This was of course a very chilling article. Here is my question. If someone has a terminal illness and has chosen palliative care over more aggressive treatment, are there people who would call that similar to suicide? I do not have a medical background and I would like other folks to weigh in here.