Many of us have swallowed the idea that equates masculinity with being macho, what some people refer as toxic masculinity. Macho often comes with behavior like showing off, feeling superior, being self-absorbed, arrogant, and aggressive. Macho men treat women as objects and can behave in a controlling fashion.
A man doesn’t have to be macho to be masculine. A genuine masculine man is confident yet open-minded to others. He treats a woman as an equal partner and inspires respect. Real men understand that it takes courage and strength to become vulnerable and show their emotions. They exert self-control, rein in their anger and make others a priority in their life.
Some women are turned off by a nice guy because they have bought into the erroneous definition of masculinity, confusing macho with masculine. Nice guys are in fact a great catch; it‘s certainly not a reason to write him off. Nice guys exhibit healthy behaviors that everyone should be on the lookout for.
Nice guys treat you well
The most important thing to look for in a long-term relationship – and especially in marriage – is someone who is kind and compassionate. Dating the fun, noncommittal bad boy can sometimes be exciting, but he is also likely to not answer your calls, ghost you, and come with less-than-wonderful personality traits.
Loyalty and commitment are in their nature
The nice guy is the one who is going to be there for you during rough the times, the one who’ll take care of you when you’re sick in bed. He’s loyal and caring, two super important traits to look for in a spouse. Don’t expect Mr. Macho to suddenly change his nature and turn into a kind, selfless soul.
Sometimes we are more focused on chemistry, passion, spontaneity and fun than good character traits. A relationship shouldn't be boring or lack passion – but it’s crucial to have your priorities straight and factor in character towards the high end of the scale. When you’re in a committed marriage, the most important things become having a kind person next to you day in and day out who is dependable, stable, loyal and exhibits loving behaviors. Sharing your life with someone who doesn’t treat you kindly isn’t anyone’s idea of a happy ending.
Nice guys show appreciation and express gratitude regularly
Nice guys tend to say thank you and show their appreciation for what others do for them. They pay attention to you and are attune to what you like. It feels good to be appreciated. This is healthy for both partners in a relationship, and it means that in the long run, you’ll be more likely to do the same for them, and both of you will feel grateful and appreciated.
Nice guys are more likely to act nice than cool
Nice guys care more about treating you well than looking good in front of others. Being with a nice guy, you’ll be number one in his book. Choosing a cool guy means you’ll more likely be second to him and his needs. A cool guy may put you down because he thinks it makes him look good. He may crack a joke at your expense because he was able to get a laugh, and then say, “I was just kidding, can’t you take a joke?”
A mensch will ask for your opinion and actually care about what you say. Cool guys will talk about their opinions and great ideas, obliging you to listen without engaging you in conversation. They will “fan their feathers” to impress you and talk at you, more than with you.
I think it’s time we reconsider who would make a healthy life partner. Ladies, look around. What do you see? A bunch of nice guys who you are friends with but could never marry? Why are you turning down responsible, reliable, good-hearted, emotionally available guys who have the potential to make you happy?
Don’t overlook the nice boy next door type. When it comes to a life partner, choose a nice guy.
(13) Anonymous, February 20, 2019 5:14 PM
if only...
This article actually irritated me.
As someone who has been dating and actively looking for a nice guy, it is not easy to find a nice guy. Nice guys don't grow on trees. I have countless stories demonstrating that there are few nice guys out there. Go write articles towards men explaining to them why they should behave nicer. As someone looking for a nice Jewish guy, it makes me question why men that supposedly believe in Gd could behave that way. I pray to Gd that one day, when I have sons they don't behave in the undignified manner that I have witnessed from the NUMEROUS men I have dated.
(12) Anonymous, February 19, 2019 7:22 PM
Honestly easier said than done. It is incredibly hard to find a nice guy. I have been dating for 6 years and looking back, very few I would consider a mentsch. It is not an easy choice to just “date a nice guy”.
(11) Leah, February 4, 2019 5:46 PM
Excellent
The best compliment I received was when my mother looked at me and said, "You married for all the right reasons." I married a nice guy. I am grateful. I used to date both nice men and jerks. It is not easy to find a nice guy. Aish has great articles on the questions one should ask oneself and the other person while dating to see if it's a healthy relationship etc...
(10) Anonymous, February 3, 2019 6:43 PM
I totally agree!! I married the “cool guy”, with all of the great chemistry...& everything else U write...so true!!
(9) Yael, February 1, 2019 2:13 PM
you are right
I have rejected a nice guy and I have accpeted the wrong guys. Now I realize how wrong that is. Thanks.
(8) craig clugston, January 31, 2019 2:52 PM
nice guy
hello I am 54 years old and been married for 28 years and when I was younger I tried to do the dating thing but wasn't successful in dating the types of girls I liked. I always met the types I didn't like. I noticed that the girls always had there picks- they wanted the body builder macho type or successful high income types of guys. I wasn't macho even though I tried. I was the nice guy. I soon found out that the nice guy always finishes last. Just rely on God sending you the right one.
Dvirah, February 4, 2019 6:07 PM
Worth the Time
The "fast/cool" ones end up throwing away much of value. Nice guys may finish last, but their hands are full of treasure.
(7) Scott, January 30, 2019 8:26 PM
Nice sentiment
Thanks for this article. Perhaps some lady might read it and some nice guy might get lucky. But the sad reality of this world remains, that brokenness is attracted to brokennes and most people are broken. Unfortunately that means that nice guys loose unless they are prepared to pick up the broken pieces left behind by the cool guys and girls.
(6) Anonymous, January 30, 2019 4:38 AM
Nice guys are hard to find
I do understand your article and it is written very eloquently and is important to open peoples mind up to the NICE GUY. Unfortunately, Very few NICE guys out there. Very disappointing. The girls and women of our generation and in general have an innate sense of midos. Sensitivity is a woman thing. In this generation, more has to be done at the grass roots level to instil midos in the JEWISH male gender. I personally believe that is why there is a shidduch crisis. We are trying to pick up the broken pieces too late in the process. I think women would only be too happy to engage with a truly NICE GUY.
(5) Elliott Katz, January 29, 2019 8:58 PM
What's often missing from nice guys
This is an excellent article about the positive qualities of many men who are nice guys. But it overlooks a common complaint I have heard from many women about nice guys -- they don't show leadership and they don't make decisions. They think they are being nice guys when they ask a woman out and then can't even choose a place for a cup of coffee. He wants her to decide. Many women have told me that when they always have to tell a man what to do it makes her feel like he is a child and she is his mother. It makes her wonder how he would handle important decisions in a family. But the man thinks he's showing her that he is a non-controlling nice guy.
Please look at my article on the Aish website called "5 Things a Man Needs to Do in a Successful Relationship." Look at some of the comments from women to see how important these 5 Things a Man Needs to Do are to them. I believe these woman want a man who has the positive qualities described here combined with the 5 Things -- show leadership, make decisions, be manly, be strong and take responsibility.
jake, January 30, 2019 7:23 AM
disagree
That is a false dichotomy. Nice guys can of course show leadership skills and be decisive. The two are not mutually exclusive. And men make a terrible mistake in thinking they are.
Anonymous, January 30, 2019 5:57 PM
All women would rather marry a strong guy who is also nice than a "nice guy". A person can be both nice and strong, but you only get the title "nice guy" if you have zero other positive qualities.
Rachel, February 1, 2019 5:41 AM
Huh?
Kindness is a strength. I’m kind of surprised that Aish published this. “Nice” is a bland word, I would say my husband is wonderful, kind, intelligent, hardworking, helpful. We celebrated our 36th wedding anniversary last year.
Anonymous, February 4, 2019 5:47 PM
It's like when you look at someone and say "Well you must have a great personality", and what you're really saying is that they are ugly.
(4) Helen Dudden, January 29, 2019 5:52 PM
Very useful
A man that can make me smile.
(3) Anonymous, January 29, 2019 4:47 PM
thanks for your help. Looking forward to hearing from you soon.
I read the AISH emails I already get.
(2) Anonymous, January 29, 2019 1:32 AM
So called "nice guys" are usually far from nice. They think they are entitled to their pick of women just because they hold doors.
(1) MESA, January 28, 2019 3:35 PM
Many years ago, a friend of my sister's (at my sister's suggestion) called me about setting me up with a guy who was "too nice" for her. My first thought was "if he's too nice, send him to me." She did send him to me. He and I are happily married with adorable children.
I think too many women have fallen for that Hollywood fantasy and they want to hear that line "you make me want to be a better man." It's not real, but too many women want that fantasy to be real.
Anonymous, January 29, 2019 1:33 AM
Table, people don't want "You make me want to be a better man", they want "I respect you as a person, but get your own sandwich".