For much of my adolescence and adult life, I mostly dismissed my mother as irrelevant. It was my charismatic, larger-than-life father upon whom I focused, a gifted Yiddish writer and editor who constantly stirred things up in our parochial neighborhood with the contentious articles he wrote, a Polish Holocaust survivor who -- he was very proud to point out -- had once been Elie Wiesel's editor on the underground Irgun newspaper in Paris. My soft-spoken mother was eclipsed by my father's magnetic presence. While he was warm and effusive, she was reserved, almost withholding. .
When I wrote my first puerile poem at the age of eight, I found myself whisked away from my mother's kitchen to my father's study, from shopping expeditions to library and bookstore forays instead, metamorphosing quickly into my father's daughter.
My father took charge of my upbringing. It was my father who tutored me in Jewish subjects, who brought me home stacks of instructive books to read, who edited my callow writing attempts.
When my mother hit 40, an amazing transformation took place. She began devouring endless volumes of spiritual literature and signed up for a plethora of courses that today would be consigned to the "self-growth" category -- anything that could give her a handle on a life she now regarded as poorly spent, and could provide her with the key to fulfill her personal aspirations.
I did not -- I am sorry to say -- applaud my mother's struggle to break out of the cocoon.
I did not -- I am sorry to say -- applaud my mother's struggle to break out of the cocoon in which she had hung in limbo for so many decades and evolve into a butterfly.
During my adolescence, I had brooded over what I perceived as her limitations as a parent. My mother had given me little emotionally, but at least there had been dinner on the table, freshly laundered clothes, food in the cupboard, physical manifestations that she was performing her maternal role. Now those amenities were gone. At midlife, she had probably begun to count her days with more precision, realizing that the sands of time were rapidly falling away, grasping at things that had previously eluded her and would soon disappear altogether. As my mother threw herself fully into all her various activities, she became increasingly absent from our lives.
This deep-felt hurt became more deeply entrenched over the passage of time.
And when my father died, too young at 62, leaving my mother a widow at 56, she suddenly began to need all kinds of assistance.
My generous husband agreed that we would pay my mother's monthly rent and other expenses. A non-driver, whenever my mother needed to visit the doctor, go shopping, or run other errands, it was I who played chauffeur. I acceded to all her demands, reminding myself that she was now a poor widow, but I did so with stony eyes flecked with fury.
Slow Amends
A few years before my mother died, she started seeing a psychologist who had a profound effect on her. Slowly, she set about making little gestures that I knew were amends. When I went on book tours across the country, my mother prepared healthy meals for me to take along to replace "toxic" airplane fare. She suddenly offered to baby sit, although my youngest son was practically a teenager now, and the need was now moot. She volunteered to cook special holiday delicacies that I had never learned to master.
But what touched me most of all was a little thing that happened when I took her on a vacation to Florida, just the two of us, and we shared a hotel suite. I opened my eyes one night to find her tenderly tucking a blanket around me that had fallen to the floor. That small act of maternal kindness almost took my breath away.
She had a sudden and massive heart attack two weeks after Passover, only three months after the Florida trip. We had spent a beautiful Passover together, our frozen relations almost completely thawed. I had recently begun to reflect on the irony that now that things were getting better, she was getting older, and time was slipping away. And since I was approaching menopause myself, I had new understanding of the dynamics that had probably driven her so many years before. In retrospect, I viewed her mid-life crisis as an act of desperation, a flailing for freedom and personal choice. I softened towards her considerably, taking her to an endless round of lectures, concerts and movies and surprised to find myself actually enjoying her company. But our time together became tinged with poignant hues. There wasn't that much time left, I knew. Still, she was 72, so I thought she had more.
I said the words I had withheld for decades: "Ma, I love you. I love you so much. Please, please get better."
When the call came that she was in the hospital, I vomited. At her side in the ICU, I cried endlessly, huge sobs of deep anguish. It was then that I said the words I had withheld for decades: "Ma, I love you. I love you so much. Please, please get better." To which she suddenly opened one eye and faintly said, "Don't you worry, I'm not going yet!" I felt cheered by her statement. She had always been a fighter, and surely she could keep death at bay even now.
The last 12 days of her life in the hospital were a revelation. A mask seemed to have been stripped off her persona, unveiling an entirely different human being than the one I had previously known. Her essence seemed so pure, so sweet now. Each time I walked into the hospital room, she stretched her arms out in almost childlike delight, embracing me with a warmth I had never experienced before, heaping constant praise upon me, plying endless compliments. "I am so lucky to have such great children!" she proclaimed over and over again. I bombarded her with all the kinds of presents she typically enjoyed -- flowers, books, nightgowns, scarves, jewelry, but the only thing she wanted from me now was strawberry ice cream -- her favorite -- so I indulged her with a pint every day. She savored every mouthful as I fed her with a spoon.
On the last day of her life, I brought her a CD player along with tapes from the legendary Jewish singer, Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach, whom she adored. As his music played in her ear, she tried to sing along. It was then that I began to get alarmed.
A social worker had already interviewed her and was preparing discharge papers. Plans had been made to hire full time companions to assist her (she didn't want to move in with me) and we were gearing up to take her home. But when she tried to sing along with Shlomo Carlebach, her clear, beautiful, melodious voice -- the toast of Squirrel Hill High School where she had sung solo in the school choir -- cracked and faltered. Tears rolled down her cheeks.
"Such a beautiful song!" she cried. "Shlomo Carlebach composed such beautiful songs!"
Then she did something remarkable. She had been confined to the bed all week -- unable to walk despite the incessant cajoling of the physical therapists -- but she suddenly lifted herself off from it and stumbled over to the window. Her sudden movements made it impossible for me to intervene and my mouth dropped at this unexpected surge of activity. But I understood what had compelled her to leave her bed. She loved nature and it was a beautiful spring day. The leaves on the trees had blossomed, the sun shone brightly and the morning was full of promise.
My mother turned to me, her face radiant with light and said: "God's world is sooo beautiful!" With this exuberant statement I thought she was validating life in general and her own life in particular. I didn't realize that what she was actually saying was goodbye.
Cleaning Mother's Apartment
After the shiva, my sister and I forced ourselves to visit our mother's apartment. I could not believe that she was gone. I kept waiting for her voice to cheerily call out, for her still-lithe figure to emerge from another room.
"I can't do this," I sobbed to my sister. "How is it that inanimate objects survive, but the person who owned them doesn't?" My sister cried too, and then pulling herself together, gently told me that my mother's landlord wanted to rent the apartment as soon as possible and we simply had to clean it out.
My mother's bedroom contained very little. My sister and I stared at each other in dismay, trying for black comedy: "Do you want mommy's $1.99 costume jewelry, or should I take it?"
I felt tremendous pain to see how pinched her life had become. The closets were stuffed with all the clothes that I had bought her over the years, but save the extensive wardrobe, there was nothing of real material value that she had left behind. No precious pieces of jewelry or silver or china anywhere, not a single treasure to take away as a memento of her existence, a living memorial. Even her candlesticks (the original silver ones had been stolen long ago) were sterling plate. I felt guilty that with all that I had given her, I hadn't given her more. I hadn't known. I hadn't known how much her material world had shrunk so pitifully since my father's death.
That's when we found them. Four checks in my mother's handwriting, each one made out for $100,000.
"Well, at least we won't be like other siblings...fighting over mommy's inheritance," my sister said. We both felt so sad. We wished there was something we could take away with us, not because we needed anything, but because we wanted some assurance that our mother hadn't needed anything. We tackled the first box.
That's when we found them. Four checks written out in my mother's handwriting, made payable to each of her three children and one to her new age psychologist.
"One hundred thousand dollars," was the sum of each check. My sister and I stared at each other in shocked silence. We knew that our mother didn't have any money in her bank account; it had in all probability been closed long ago. This was likely an exercise in "visualization." Decades before "The Secret" climbed onto the best-seller charts, my mother was already practicing sending out "energy" to the universe in the hope that her thoughts would create her reality, and that she could receive from the world's abundance anything she wanted. (It didn't quite work out that way.)
What stunned my sister and I most was that our mother wanted to gift us with $100,000 each, and that she had apparently spent time and energy immersed in visualization exercises to make it happen. Even more surprisingly, we found no check made out to her. There were only the checks to us. We sat down on her bed and cried again.
And then my sister made another startling discovery: "Look, Yitty!" she shouted. "Here's a box filled with all your old newspaper and magazine articles."
"What?" I asked in disbelief. "What are you talking about?"
"Look for yourself."
I reached for the large box and found articles that I had written spanning four decades. Over the years, I had been careless about saving my published work and possessed few clippings of my own. As I grew older, I became remorseful that such important pieces of my past were lost to me forever. Several of the publications in which my articles had once appeared had ceased to exist and others simply didn't have archives.
Everything I had ever believed about my mother and the role she played in my life was suddenly turned upside down.
I was thunderstruck that it was my mother who had cared enough to collect these clips so painstakingly and preserve them all these years. What did it imply -- this vigilant and conscientious assembling of practically every article that I had ever written? Everything I had ever believed about my mother and the role she played in my life was suddenly challenged, turned upside down. For there it was: from the old, yellowing, brittle newspapers of 40 years ago to the newer shinier glossy pages of just a few months before: proof that I had been wrong about my mother all this time.
I buried my face in my hands and wept in contrition. Ultimately, the articles I had once thought irrevocably gone were now resurrected, but the years lost between my mother and myself could never be.
I had misinterpreted the narrative of our relationship and so, all these years, I missed the greatest gift of all.
I thought there would be no inheritance from her; I knew she was poor. But the clippings that she had saved were more precious to me than any financial bequest. This then was her legacy to me. A box of withered articles that told me clearly that my mother, all along, loved me.
BIO: Yitta Halberstam is the co-author of the best-selling "Small Miracles" series and author of "Holy Brother:Inspiring Stories and Enchanted Tales of Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach."
(27) Anonymous, June 29, 2017 7:21 PM
You have a good neshama
And both of your parents knew that!
(26) Anonymous, July 16, 2009 6:16 AM
I am deeply moved by this article. Perhaps many of us need to reconsider and reevaluate those impressions of our parents. They just may need to be fine-tuned.
(25) RAL, July 12, 2009 12:36 PM
A clear message on how to live while dying
We get away from what is truly important only to practice what we learned is important. Irony is, we always have all that we need witihn arms length and without struggle.
(24) Victor, July 10, 2009 4:09 PM
I need to call my mom
I was nearly in tears reading this article, thank you so much for sharing. Also reminds me I should call my mom and tell her I'm alright.
(23) ettel, July 9, 2009 6:53 PM
self-awareness
Thank G-d Hashem gave the two of you time to reconnect. He helped you open your eyes, what a gift He presented you with and you grabbed the opportunity. Did you ever think that it was you who came out of your coccoon/shield and you were the one who was changing and seeing who (mom) was there all along. Obviously, your mother always loved you and was always there for you, maybe your interests and activities brought her to look outside the house. since you weren't there. She loved you and respected what you did enough not to stand in your way and ask for your love and attention. She loved you dearly. I'm so glad you found each other "in time."
(22) Anonymous, July 9, 2009 6:02 PM
very distrubing
I have been troubled for days since first reading this article. This article shows little sympathy for, understanding or awareness of what women's lives were and often are like. Intelligent women were relegated to the kitchen and housework, not having the opportunity to share in the intellectual life of the world or family or synagogue, wasting away while the husband was and is able to study and work in a meaningful and self fulfilling endeavor and receives accolates from the community and his daughters while the daughters can only criticize their mother. While being mother is wonderful it is not intellectually challenging and as this daughter demonstrates, does not gain one respect or consideration from either father or children. This article was still more about what mother should be or should have done and comparing her to father who does not seem to have held her in high esteem nor taught his daughters to.
Anonymous, January 1, 2012 5:12 PM
Who said so?
Get off your high horse. Don't judge everyone by your own opinions.
(21) raye, July 7, 2009 6:04 PM
An Unwanted child's compassion for her mother
When I was a grown woman and newly divorced after ten years of a childless marriage, my mother told me that I was an unwanted child, the youngest of five. She used me in all sorts of shocking ways and kept me from living a normal child's life. The rareexamples maternal love were dramatic in their impact. Though the damage to my development as a viable human being took ages to overcome, once I was out of her clutches, I was able to understand what made her tick and though I could not love her, my compassion was infinite.
(20) Zelig Pliskin, July 7, 2009 10:34 AM
A POWERFUL LESSON FOR ALL OF US
I found this beautifully written article highly inspiring. The lesson is one that we all need. When we build our impressions of our parents and how we project their view of us we start out as young children. As we get older we still view our parents from our own subjective eyes. We can't really enter our parents' minds. This article describes an awakening of a child to the reality of how she was actually viewed by her mother all the time. There are many lessons here. One lesson is for all parents to verbalize their positive thoughts about their children when their children are young and to keep upgrading it as their children grow up. This article will also open up the possibility in many reader's minds, "Perhaps I was viewed more positively than I realized."
(19) John Power, July 7, 2009 2:05 AM
G_d is reproducing Himself.
Yitta will see her mother again and they will fulfill the loving purpose He has purposed for them for all eternity. Thank you for sharing.
(18) Grace Fishenfeld, July 6, 2009 11:35 PM
Keep Learning
I am glad that you cried. Your mother needed your understanding a long time ago . Finally she served as an echo for your beautiful career by saving articles about you, her beloved daughter, she has earned some worth. She needed respect and attention. It appears that there were too many egos dominating the the family. From what I gather, all of you placed intellectual accomplishment above menchlaughkite. You all seem to have been short on empathy . Even now when you admit that you misinterpreted the narrative of your relationship, you love her for her reflecting your accomplishments. What about hers? Surely, you must realize that you all short changed her. I'm glad you wrote your story and that you can still learn a lesson in humility.
(17) Sarah Hirsch, July 6, 2009 7:47 PM
This was how it was with my mother and me too
I also lost many years with my mom because I felt "abandoned" by her. She also took steps to come back into relationship with me, and I spent years withholding myself from her - out of anger. A year and a half before she died of Lou Gehrig's disease, I realized that while she was reaching out to touch me or brush the hair from my face - I was 40 at the time - I was refusing to touch her - even though I knew that was what she needed and wanted. One day, sitting in the livingroom with her, this overwhelming love for her washed over me, love that I hadn't felt for year, and I thought, "I love this woman...and she is going to die." From that day, I was the daughter she needed and wanted. I wrote to her every other day, called her regularly, sent her picltures of my home, and my life. Still, in the end, her passing was bittersweet, because we had lost so much time. We healed some, not all, but maybe enough. I always wished that there were some way to let others know NOT to withdraw from their parents, no matter how much hurt there is between you, and now here is this article that touched me, and I hope, will touch others. Thank you!
(16) Anonymous, July 6, 2009 3:23 PM
Understand thoroughly
Yitta, Your article was moving. After going over and still going over my late mother's notebooks and effects (she died 5 months ago), I got to know a new person whose inner life I was not enoough entirely aware of. I guess this is a common experience. Yael
(15) melbert, July 6, 2009 8:09 AM
wonderful!!!
it made me cry to realize the beauty of having our parents loving us so much. they gave so much but received little from us and yet never lamented of our neglectfulness. thanks a lot for your wonderful story. it pounded my heart into pieces just to smell the sweet savor of our parent's unconditional love for us in a way that reflects our Father's love for us. Blessed be the name of HaShem!!!
(14) Florida, July 6, 2009 6:32 AM
What happened between you and your mother affirms the possibility of real growth in the way we give and receive love--even in the final moments of a complicated relationship. Thank you, Yitta, for sharing your painful but ultimately very positive story with such openness and self-honesty. I think it has the makings of a great book.
(13) Mae, July 6, 2009 4:26 AM
Squirrel Hill in Pittsburgh PA
My heart is beating for you as I read Squirrel Hill High School. That has to be Pittsburgh, PA. I tried to student teach there only the teacher I had been assigned was rude with me and her Gospel music so I left and interned in East Liberty. My mom did the same for me, only both my Mom and my Dad, died when I was 25, so you are most fortunate you had your Mom for so long....
(12) ANGELA, July 6, 2009 2:56 AM
MY HEART CRIES WITH YOU
Tears fall from my eyes while reading your article cause likewise i lost my mother last year and that's the only time i truly knew her... She had spend her days far from me and we seldom see each other... The only time i took care of her is when she is bedridden because of cancer... till the end of her life. MORE POWER
(11) miriam, July 6, 2009 12:00 AM
It is not until we are fully grown that we understand our parents.
And in doing so, we understand ourselves. What a beautiful story.
(10) Anonymous, July 5, 2009 8:49 PM
Mothers are remarkable - we try to be perfect and yet make so many mistakes.
Hope to read other biographies of remarkable mothers.
(9) Chana Jenny Weisberg, July 5, 2009 8:27 PM
wonderful!
Dear Yitta- thank you so much for sharing this incredibly poignant story! What an amazing article!
(8) Sara Rigler, July 5, 2009 8:17 PM
What a beautiful, poignant story!
I share Yitta's remorse at not being the daughter that now, 18 years after my mother's death, I realize I should have been. I'd love to read more articles by Yitta Halberstam.
(7) Linda M. Cucher, LPC., CCH, July 5, 2009 7:03 PM
The ironic nature of a mother/daughter relationship
Truly, it is one of the tougher ironies of life that in our youth, we are so utterly wrapped up in our own needs, expectations and subjective perspective, we lack the "eyin tov", the gracious perception that allows us to see our parents as the people they actually are...the appreciation of all the complexities, subtleties and stories of the heart that exist within every person provide an understanding of which would undoubtedly help us to relate differently to our mothers when we have reached the maturity to do so. That said, I believe it is the built-in nature of the mother/daughter chemistry to be either too close (not healthy), or too removed, also not helpful. Eventually, mother and daughter alike must grow, develop, become self-sufficient emotionally and physically. As the child, we have come from the very closest connection one has to another individual...happily thriving in her womb and our mother, feeling the indescribable fulfillment of carrying us right inside her; the utter miracle of it all! It is indeed, one of life's great challenges, for mother to let go without shutting herself down and for daughter to emotionally manage her expectations...the tug of war between needing mom too much and not wanting to need her at all. Finding the relationship, with all it's history, potential, texture and richness somewhere in the middle: this is the key. Thank you, Yitta, for a fearless sharing of your journey with your mother and although is was a briefer experience than you would have wished for with her in those last years, what a great blessing from Hashem that you had the opportunity to find that delicate balance. You enjoyed one another, you appreciated one another and now you have honored your mother in this moving tribute.
(6) Miriam Adahan, July 5, 2009 5:52 PM
Thank you for your honesty. Most people have complicated relationships with their parents, and most of us live with the shame, fear, confusion and mistrust which result. Articles like yours help us feel more normal and human.
(5) Anonymous, July 5, 2009 4:31 PM
I was moved to tears by your article,thank you so much for it! My mom passed away at the age of 49.I feel very much connected to this story.
(4) Linda, July 5, 2009 3:56 PM
Beautiful story
I found your article extremely moving. Thank you.
(3) Bliss, July 5, 2009 2:19 PM
Unspoken love resounds ...
How beautifully you tell of how loved you are ~ as a mother I hope my children & grandchildren appreciate my actions in their behalf as you do your mothers. Love does not shout; love speaks softly & one has to be silent in order to hear it.
(2) Lawrence, July 5, 2009 2:07 PM
Alice Through The Looking Glass
Blessed be the Name !!!! I was a youngster whose mom died when I was seventeen and as my mother was a teacher, was raised in many capacities by my grandmother. I also experienced enigmatic vistas of my grandmother, who ran a candy store, as a youth and never got to see the mastodonic dimensions of her persona until I lived with her until the age of thirty-one. I never realized how sensible and realitistic her philosophy of life was. One can read Alice In Wonderland as a child, and as a doctoral candidate in mathematics. If G-d is good to you, you get the opportunity to experience parents/grandparents as a child and as an adult. We should profoundly count our blessings if we're given the opportunity to reinvent our psycho/social family realities and relate to these zokainim adult to adult.
(1) Deborah Rey, July 5, 2009 1:07 PM
A lucky woman
A tribute to a remarkable woman, a Mother to be proud of, a Mother who truly loved you. You are a lucky woman, Yitta Halberstam. I'm happy for you, very happy, that eventually you two found each other. May you always have Light, Deborah Rey I Speak My Soul. I Write. http://www.immasgirl.blogspot.com/