I recently read a “letter to the editor” in a print publication (yes they still exist and I still read them!) about an elderly Jewish man from Morocco. Although blind and suffering from dementia, having learned the whole Tanach (the Torah, Prophets and Writings) by heart as a child, he can still recite any passage upon request. Yes, you read that correctly – any passage!
He still goes to the synagogue and if the reader of the Torah makes a mistake in pronunciation, the blind grandfather with the failing memory will correct him. The power of what we learn as a child!
There was someone similar at my local synagogue for many years. He came to shul with his name pinned to his jacket since he was liable to forget who and where he was. Yet the same phenomenon occurred. If the person reading the Torah portion made any error, he immediately corrected him. So deep were the memories.
If I search the recesses of my childhood memories, I can probably conjure up the words to the theme from “Gilligan’s Island” or “Green Acres.” There are even the melodies and lyrics to many Christmas carols. But all the words of the Torah with their proper pronunciation? Now that would be something.
The point of encountering such people, such an experience of this powerful phenomenon, is not to beat ourselves up if our childhood memories aren’t in sync with his. We probably had no control over the situation.
Our opportunity now is what to teach our own children – and what to expose them to. If we recognize that the songs and chants and prayers and stories they hear as children will remain a part of their psyche forever, if we particularly appreciate the power of repetition and that repeated stories, songs and ideas can be inculcated in our children to last their entire lives, then maybe we will make different and more conscious choices about what we teach them.
Maybe we will think more carefully about what knob we turn on the radio or what CD’s (am I dating myself?) we play in the car. Maybe we will examine with greater forethought the stories we read to them or the tales we tell. Maybe we will really listen to the words of the songs we are singing or parse carefully the messages we are conveying.
Our lives are very busy and parenting is very hard work. Sometimes important things fall through the cracks. But an encounter with someone like this can remind us of the opportunity we have and encourage us not to waste it.
I may be condemned to know by heart the theme to “The Beverly Hillbillies” and most Rogers and Hammerstein musicals, but my children needn’t be. They had a fresh start and an opportunity to master Tanach by heart. They could have it at their finger tips, even in their old age. I envy them.
But I haven’t given up. When I recite my Psalms every day, I think about that man, the one who attended my synagogue. And while I hope to retain my eyesight and my memory long into old age (please God), I hope even more that the words of King David will have been burned so deeply upon my soul that the memory of them will last long after my senses fade and that those are the words I will have on my lips as my life slowly diminishes, and not the lyrics from The Mary Tyler Moore Show theme song.
(9) Mike, June 23, 2016 7:37 PM
I definitely agree
I also had an elderly neighbor (probably past 90) with a hearing problem/occasional forgetfulness/occasional confusion who was a sweet person. He was from North Africa and his father had been a Rabbi. This neighbor used to read the parasha every week in his apartment and also read from the Torah.
He had excellent midot, and even when one person spoke to him very nastily and shouted at him, he never lost his temper, never raised his voice and while he stood firm, he still treated the other person as a human being.
I was also thinking that his ability had to do with what he learned when he was young, else I don't know how he could have done this.
(8) Mike, November 7, 2015 5:45 PM
agree
I have recently met several hareidi people by coincidence.
I was surprised by their clearity of thought and I was also impressed by their wealth of ideas and humanity.
The truth is that I had had a thought in my mind, how can they be normal people without watching TV series, etc.
The truth is that they are missing nothing.
(7) Simcha, November 6, 2015 1:14 AM
Loving Nostalgia!!!
I LOVE nostalgia!!! Although it is important to know Tanach and Torah in general by heart, it is great to remember the songs, TV shows, movies, books, etc. from yesteryear except for the X-mas carols and anything opposed to Judaism which we should do our best to forget about.
(6) Howard Sanshuck, November 5, 2015 11:04 PM
What's More Important
The two men who did that amazing feat deserve our praise. I hope that their lives so far have been filled with joy and fulfillment. Nevertheless, I do not recommend that children do that. Did their fathers force the two men you mentioned? Were they prevented from going outside and playing with friends, because they had to memorize the Torah? I hope not. The Jewish bible books are readily available and it is not necessary to memorize them. If you want to help children develop memorization skills then teach them something that has a direct application and develops a useful skill.
(5) Nancy, November 5, 2015 10:35 PM
I have one more comment to make.
Re: Rogers and Hammerstein. Oscar Hammerstein was Jewish.
(4) Nancy, November 5, 2015 10:31 PM
To commenter #2 Sanford Kadish
I'm sitting here laughing out loud at your post. It's hysterical! Kol Tuv and Shabbat Shalom.
Sharona, November 8, 2015 7:21 AM
Me Too
yes, a hysterical post!
(3) Anonymous, November 5, 2015 4:40 PM
Love nostalgic songs
I totally agree with you that it would be wonderful to know Tanach by memory... But those sweet innocent songs of yesteryear helped fine tune our childhood memories in that relaxed happy way that children need to be relaxed happy adults
(2) Sanford Kadish, November 5, 2015 3:25 PM
Songs from Our Youth
Important Torah Question:
What's the first thing you know?
The first thing you know old Jed's a millionaire.
Shabbat Shalom
(1) Nancy, November 1, 2015 12:32 PM
Mixing apples and oranges.
The lyrics to MANY Rogers and Hammerstein musicals were very powerful. Just think about the song "Carefully Taught" from the musical South Pacific. Comparing those lyrics to the TV theme songs is not really a fair comparison.