Fans of The Crown may be shocked by some of the behaviors in Season 4 – no I don’t mean Diana’s struggles with an eating disorder or Charles’ unattractive, bullying treatment of her. These issues have been tabloid headlines for years and, although painful and tragic, little is new.
What is appalling is the supposed behavior of the royal family towards their guests. (Keep in mind, we cannot take the show's depiction as fact, but we can still take the opportunity to learn from it.)
When Diana is first introduced to the family, she is publicly humiliated for her failure to understand whom to curtsey to, the proper order of said curtsies and the correct way to address the various family members. Certainly not a strategy that makes anyone feel welcome, let alone a future daughter-in-law. But according the show (so we should not fully accept its veracity), it didn’t stop with Diana.
When Margaret Thatcher and her husband came to visit, they were exposed to similar public embarrassment. It’s almost as if the Queen and her entourage deliberately misinformed them of palace protocol so that they would show up dressed very formally for dinner at a time when the family was still in their casual hunting attire.
That kind of cavalier, even cruel, attitude towards guests in your home runs contrary to everything I have learned about hospitality in the Torah. From our father Abraham interrupting his conversation with the Almighty to take care of weary travelers, to the oft-told story of the host who, after witnessing his guest spill wine all over the tablecloth, “innocently” knocks over his own glass to remove the humiliation from his guest. Our job as hosts is to be sensitive to our guests needs (and I haven’t even mentioned steering clear from the more grave prohibition of embarrassing someone in public!).
If we look deeper into the Jewish way of hospitality, we find a whole list of rules whose sole goal is to encourage sensitivity towards all the needs of our guests and thereby maximize their experience. From making their favorite foods to not forcing them to eat it(!), from giving them extra comfortable accommodations to filling their room with extra toiletries, to listening to their stories and even to not contradicting them (perhaps a particular challenge in today’s fraught society), the Torah is replete with instructions on how to treat our guests, how to make their experience pleasant and joyful, how to tailor it their unique needs and requirements.
I am grateful to have been reared on a steady diet of these strictures, to have listened to many variations on these stories, and to have the sensitivity to the guests and the holiness of the mitzvah emphasized and reinforced through classes and daily prayer.
Whether The Crown is an accurate depiction of the royal family or not (and according to many it is clearly not accurate), I'm grateful for the reminder of Judaism's sensitivity in how to treat guests.
(5) Anonymous, December 3, 2020 2:35 PM
The Heartbreaking Evils of Slander
The very fact that this column was written (I have no problem at all with the point of the article itself!) shows how the evil of slandering others spreads like spilled mercury. Anyone who has had any connection to the Royal family knows that the Queen and her husband's dedication to making sure that their guests and people around them are made as comfortable and put as at ease as possible is legendary. But because Netflix chose to attack these living people in a vicious and fictitious way for the sake of increasing drama in their show, the Queen is now being used as an example of an uncaring, almost vicious host - even in the pages of Aish HaTorah. That is how in one episode, a slanderous TV show can destroy a kind, cheerful, and considerate person's good reputation of 90 years. (For creds, both my mother and grandmother served as ladies in waiting and my cousin worked for Mrs. Thatcher. I am not a blind fan swallowing tabloids, which is why seeing this here is particularly heartbreaking.) One cannot just throw in a line about how "we can't take the show's depictions as fact" and think that is enough to allow one to use real people as examples of abhorrent behavior, even if they are not Jewish. If you wanted to use the show as the basis for this column, then at least please present it clearly as a screenwriter's made-up, nasty drama about characters he has created from his imagination. Please, please let us all be more careful about how we portray other people, no matter who they are. When we are not careful when about protecting other people's reputations, we often end up damaging our own as well.
(4) Lori, December 1, 2020 11:37 PM
Interesting!
Nice article! I assume that since Netflix depicts religious Jews in a negative, inaccurate, overly dramatic fashion in shows like Unorthodox they probably do the same to the royal family in The Crown!
(3) Andrea Schonberger, December 1, 2020 8:18 PM
The common touch
There's an anecdote about Queen Victoria and a visiting maharajah from India who, when presented with a finger bowl, drank the water from it and remarked that English water tasted good. Apparently the other guests were shocked at this breech in etiquette but Queen Victoria just smiled and drank the water from her finger bowl too. Not embarrassing guests is the mark of a good host.
(2) Jane, December 1, 2020 6:02 PM
Amen! I couldn’t agree more!
(1) Bobby5000, December 1, 2020 3:48 PM
they espouse the standards they keep
I have some 80 family members and have heard: it's too cold, where' the food, he doesn't know what he's talking about, not too bright, absolutely not, why is this taking so long. Imagine travelling, going to 150 events per year, smiling complimenting people on sometimes mediocre food, tolerating various things, being in a constantly good mood, refraining from criticism or untoward comment.
I think the show humanizes royalty, showing the challenge of self-discipline in various areas. They only expect the standards they apply, such as being familiar with local customs.