Spicey Gefilte Fish

New cooking demo featuring Jamie Geller.

Comments (12)

(12) Louisa Bieler, April 20, 2012 7:20 AM

I believe in vegetables

Chaim, I have a book written by Rav Falk, shlita, of Gateshead, where he details a method of dealing with celery - simply cutting off the leaves and the stalk so that there is no "joint" left, and scrubbing it well with a synthetic, hard bristle brush - this is the method in Europe. I do believe that G-d gave us vegetables to keep us healthy, and that if there is a way to clean them, we should use it and enjoy the vegetable. Also, Rav Falk is a great rav, and if he permits something, I take it seriously. In addition, the Star-K allows celery, as do numerous other hashgochos which operate in the US.

(11) esther, August 5, 2008 11:45 AM

I made this last Shabbat

The gefilte fish tasted just like ordinary gefilte fish, but the vegetables were a very nice touch, they were very soft and had a delicate "fishy" flavor. It's also convenient just to stick this in the oven when you're cooking other Shabbos food, and not to have to boil it on the stove separately, as with normal gefilte fish.

Re the vegetables - in the past it's traditionally been acceptable to just wash vegetables thoroughly. (For leafy vegetables, it's a bit more stringent: I always was taught to wash in three changes of water, 20 min. each change, and the middle one salted.) However, people nowadays try to screen for all sorts of microscopic bugs that in the past we wouldn't even have known about. Check with your individual rabbi about how stringent you want to be, instead of just relying on some anonymous posting on the internet.

(10) mm. mintz, August 4, 2008 9:42 AM

I am amazed at the ignorance of some of the people who respond to the gefilte
fish recipe. Any one who uses celery or any other vegetable when cooking should
rinse before use.

(9) Aidel, July 31, 2008 12:55 PM

Bugs and Veggies

About celery: It's best to take a vegetable peeler and peel off the ridges on the outside of each stalk. If there are any bugs, that's where they will be. Also, if the stalk is very curled, slice it in half and check for discolorations. As alwasy, you have to rinse the stalks and rub them with your fingers while under the water.

About fresh herbs like parsley: Soak in a bowl of soapy water for 3-5 minutes, then rinse well. Throw out any brown leaves/stems. Soaking in soapy water forces the little buggies to lose their grip, and then you rinse them away.

Not eating bugs is a Torah commandment. I feel many cookbooks don't spend enough time emphasizing how important checking for bugs is. I was glad to see that Mrs. Geller in her video mentioned checking the celery. I was taught that it's best just to peel the celery because it's too hard to check all those ridges.

Hatzlocha everyone.

(8) Chaim, July 30, 2008 5:17 PM

Bugs bugs bugs

Celery is a BIG problem with bugs. They have been found to burrow through the celery. It's extremely hard to check. Best not to use! Also, fresh dill and parsley are also very buggy.

(7) Nancy and Mike, July 29, 2008 9:34 PM


really nice presentation

(6) Pamela Elam, July 28, 2008 5:21 PM

Tried it...my family loved it....

I made your gefilte fish. The Elam mishpacha loved it. I made it again for Shabbat oneg and everyone that had some loved it. Thanks for such a straight forward cooking video. It was so easy to follow. Please do another kosher cooking video. You made me look like a good cook!

(5) dsafasd, July 28, 2008 8:51 AM

please can we have more cooking demonstrations!!

(4) Rosen, July 27, 2008 4:04 PM

I like gefilte fish!

I like eating gefilte fish when I get a chance to. I don't quite understand why others are squeamish when it comes to eating either gefilte fish or whitefish. Even if it is processed fish somehow, it does taste really good. It's at least an acquired taste for such kosher food. One may have to get used to it like how I got used to the smell of brisket (not that I never really didn't like that dish).

(3) Anonymous, July 27, 2008 11:02 AM

Can't wait to try this. Thank you.

(2) Anonymous, July 27, 2008 10:48 AM

sounds so good can't wait to try this

I use the frozen fish all the time. I am going to try this receipe this Friday

(1) Hadassah, July 27, 2008 9:56 AM

WOW - Get This Cookbook!!!!!

I LOVE YOUR COOKBOOK!! I just received it and tried 4 recipes from it and everyone of them were FABULOUS! My husband said the Seared Ahi Tuna and the Parmesan/Sun Dried Tomato Crusted Fish were the best fish he has EVER HAD!! I love to cook and trying your cookbook has given me a new excitement, especially with Kosher recipes! I can't wait to try this Gefilte Fish recipe! THANK YOU FOR MAKING COOKING A GREAT DELIGHT!


Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment

Receive Weekly Recipes Emails

Sign up to our Recipes Newsletter.

Our privacy policy